Greetings Silverhair, I hope your weekend is a blessed one.
You are misusing the text. Only those that have shared in the Holy Spirit are saved. The Holy Spirit will convict all but does not indwell all.
The text says share in the Holy Spirit it does not say share in the Holy Spirits work. That is the error you bring into the text.
The text refers to “those who have once” what?
1] been enlightened
2] have tasted of the heavenly gift
3] have been made partakers of the Holy Spirit,
4] have tasted the good word of God
5] and the powers of the age to come
6] and then have fallen away
7] it is impossible to renew them again to repentance
These words obviously refer to those that have been saved that is unless you think the unsaved can fall away from a faith they never had. Or can be renewed to a faith they never had.
You make an interesting distinction between sharing in the Holy Spirit and sharing in the Holy Spirit's work, yet notice that you are the one importing the word
"indwell". Hebrews 6:4 never says they were indwelt by the Holy Spirit. It says they were
metochous (companions or sharers) of the Holy Spirit.
In the New Testament,
metochos means being a companion or participant alongside others (such as Luke 5:7 for fishing partners). Anyone who joined the Christian assembly, in the early church, became a direct participant in the Spirit's corporate presence, teaching, and miraculous distributions (Hebrews 2:4). Scripture gives us clear examples like King Saul (1 Samuel 10:10) and Balaam (Numbers 24:2) who genuinely shared in the Spirit's power and prophecy without ever possessing saving faith. Being a companion in the Spirit's work and presence in the congregation
is not the same thing as indwelling regeneration.
Second, look closely at your final question about point #7. You asked if the unsaved
"can be renewed to a faith they never had." However, Hebrews 6:6 does not say
"renew them again to faith" or
"renew them again to salvation." It says
"renew them again to repentance." This is importing words that are not in the text.
Just five verses earlier in Hebrews 6:1, the author defines "repentance from dead works" as the
elementary starting threshold of turning away from old religious works toward the gospel. An enlightened hearer can turn from dead works, taste the goodness of God's word, and share in the Spirit's convicting presence in the church (verses 4 and 5) without yet reaching rooted saving faith. If they then reject Christ and crucify Him afresh (verse 6), they cannot be brought back to that starting point of repentance again.
The bible is clear that one is saved or not saved. There is not almost saved as you seem to think. What we see in Mar 4:5-8 is speaking of people that have been saved but as we see the 2nd and 3rd type will fall away from their faith. That is not what we see in Heb 3 and 6.
Again, let me clarify your mischaracterization of my position. I agree completely that a person is either saved or not saved, and I have never claimed there is an
"almost saved" category. My point is simply that an
unsaved person can experience real gospel illumination, conviction, and shallow, temporary assent without yet crossing into saving faith.
That is precisely why John 2:23-25 is so important,
which your reply skipped over, btw. In John 2:23, many
"believed in His name" when they saw His signs, yet Jesus refused to entrust Himself to them. Those people were not saved and then lost, nor were they
"almost saved"; they were unsaved people whose shallow, sign-based assent fell short of true saving faith.
I called your view a "stepped view of salvation." as that is what you have presented. You claim that babes in the faith are not really saved but have to wait until they are mature to receive the promise.
You have mistaken the shallow, temporary assent as not being saving faith but the bible disagree with you. You said you agree with Rom 10:9 & Act 16:30-31 but nothing in those verses say that those believers cannot or will not fall away as soils 2 & 3 did in Mar 4:5-7.
Genuine, heart-level saving faith is the faith we see God respond to Eph 2:5 “...even when we were dead in our trespasses. It is by grace you have been saved!” and Eph 2:8 “For it is by grace you have been saved through faith,” It does not say your almost saved and we will wait until you mature to actually save you does it.
You are still arguing against a straw man of my position. You appear to be reading your theology into
"babe" instead of letting the Hebrew text define what
"babe" is. I have never said that a regenerated believer has to reach theological maturity before God justifies them. My point is that in Hebrews 5:11-6:12, the word
"babe" is not describing a regenerated believer who already possesses salvation (that is your position); it is describing a hearer who is stalled in elementary exposure, dull of hearing, and standing outside the promised rest, the exact promised rest the text is telling the babes to move toward (just like Israel stood outside Canaan in Hebrews 3:19).
I have not bypassed any of Hebrews but I have not read into it what is not there either. The warning of Heb 3:12 and 19 is that those that do not believe will not enter God’s rest, will be saved. And in contrast we see that Heb 6:9 is pointing to the better things that come through salvation.
It would appear that you may now be contradicting yourself from earlier emails. You didn't write much here, so let me inquire.... You just said in the quote above that Hebrews 3:12 and 19 (you connected them to Heb 6:4-6 earlier) is a warning that if these Babes do "NOT ENTER GOD'S REST".... they "WILL BE SAVED".
You wrote in another post...
6] then have fallen away
You cannot fall away from a position that you do not hold. They have rejected the only means of their salvation.
7] they cannot be restored to repentance"
If the Babes do not reach the "promise" are they saved or not?
Further, you then wrote...
And in contrast we see that Heb 6:9 is pointing to the better things that come through salvation.
You have again brought in words that are not in the text (which we have seen a couple of times now). No translation, that I know of, says "come through salvation". The text says "things that accompany salvation" (NKJV) OR "things that belong to salvation" (ESV, NASB).
Even using your own phrasing (that is not in the text), your summary actually confirms my point. If the five experiences in Hebrews 6:4 and 6:5 already equaled being saved, then verses 4 and 5 would already describe the things that belong to or come through salvation.
Why would the author
contrast verses 4 through 8 with
"better things, things that belong to salvation" in verse 9 if the people in verses 4 and 5 were already saved? That contrast only makes sense because the initial enlightenment and tasting of verses 4 and 5 fall short of salvation itself, whereas verses 10 through 12 immediately define those
"better things" as the enduring faith, love, and patience that actually inherit the promise.
Keep seeking God's truth as if it were hidden treasure