Have of you ever seen those people, especially children, in 3rd world countries who appear to be very fat, but are said to be starving to death?
They have a tape worm. The worm eats all or most of the food that travels into their bodies, causing the worm to become large, but the person is dying. The person will have a very large-looking stomach. At first appearance you would think they eat way too much, but the fact is that they can not eat too much.
They are very overweight to the point of it causing medical problems in them, but it is in no way their fault, and they are not gluttons, but some here would call them sinners nonetheless.
Another thing, have any of you ever been on steroids for a disease? If so, then you can testify to the fact that it makes you gain tremendous amounts of weight.
I have a friend who was bi-polar and was being treated with steroids for several years. He weighed around 300 lbs. When he was taken off of the meds, he lost over 100 lbs. in less than a year. He did not change his eating or excercise habits, he simply was not taking the medicine anymore.
I have seen many people, including my mother, who do not eat all that much and still retain a lot of weight. When your metabloism is slow, it is very hard to lose weight and keep it off.
If she started eating less food, she would starve to death. She barely eats more than my grandmother who weighs 106 soaking wet, yet she vastly outweighs her. (Don't want mom mad at me, so I'll admit that I weigh quite a bit more than she does.

)
I'll agree that if people ate less they would lose weight, but some people's body chemistry is such that they could eat fewer than the recommended 2,000 cals per day and still retain or even gain more weight. Not everyone's body works the same and fat people often eat less than skinny people.
My cousin is skinny as a rail, but could eat me under the table any day of the week.
Fat, or overweight, does not necessarily mean glutton.
And, even if it did, who defines what weight is normal? It has changed over the years, so would our ancestors be considered gluttons for eating so much lard? Would they be considered fat or skinny by today's standards?
DD, is this the only issue you care about? It seems that this is about the 100th time you've posted a thread about fat pastors.