You're so stuck on "past sins" that you're overlooking what the job of a pastor is. The pastor is the under-shepherd; the man hired to watch the flock, take care of them, lead them and keep them from going astray, find them when they get separated, etc. That's the analogy. In the case of us poor, miserable, sinful humans, the pastor also teaches and guides and "trains up."
The pastor of any church is the same as any other person who came to Christ for salvation, lost as a ball in the weeds. Look @ the Corinthian church, and read chapter six....
"have ye not known that the unrighteous the reign of God shall not inherit? be not led astray; neither whoremongers, nor idolaters, nor adulterers, nor effeminate, nor sodomites, nor thieves, nor covetous, nor drunkards, nor revilers, nor extortioners, the reign of God shall inherit. And certain of you were these! but ye were washed, but ye were sanctified, but ye were declared righteous, in the name of the Lord Jesus, and in the Spirit of our God."(vss 9-11 YLT)
There were people who had been idol worshippers...there were people there who had stolen off other people, there were former g@ys, covetous people, drunks, who had been saved. Yet, for some odd reason, divorce and remarriage makes someone a second-class citizen in churches.
I agree that sins before, and confessed sins after, salvation are forgiven. What would you have a previously divorced pastor--whether divorced before or after salvation--teach and guide the flock he's been entrusted with about the subject of divorce?
As Sissy Ann already stated, a pastor who has been divorced and remarried can teach others by showing the mistakes he made in his previous marriage(s). Now, I am talking about pastors who had been divorced and remarried prior to being saved. God doesn't throw people's past sins up in their faces, but by golly, some church members do. That's why I stated God's forgiveness goes waaaaaay further than man's does.
And I continue to go back to my question that no one has answered: When you preach/teach this subject, how do you reconcile wife of one husband in 1Tim 5 with husband of one wife in 1 Tim 3?
Well, let us go to 1 Corinthians 7 and see what Paul says about this...
"And to the rest I speak -- not the Lord -- if any brother hath a wife unbelieving, and she is pleased to dwell with him, let him not send her away; and a woman who hath a husband unbelieving, and he is pleased to dwell with her, let her not send him away; for the unbelieving husband hath been sanctified in the wife, and the unbelieving wife hath been sanctified in the husband; otherwise your children are unclean, but now they are holy. And, if the unbelieving doth separate himself -- let him separate himself: the brother or the sister is not under servitude in such [cases], and in peace hath God called us;"
If a christian man has a wife who leaves him, she was the one who broke that covenant of marriage, not him. You're gonna hold him for the misgivings of another woman's deeds. There is a Brother in the association I belong to, that when they married, they were both sinners, iirc. Later on he was saved, and she was later on "saved". Over time, as this is what he told me, his wife at that time wasn't bringing forth good fruit. He was even an asst-pastor at one time. One day she came up to him and told him she wasn't a preacher's wife and left him. I know this man personally, and I even had him preach over my mommy the second night of her wake. He's as good a man as I know, imo. To lay the charges of a failed marriage on him is down right uncalled for. She left him, and in doing so, according to 1 Corinthians 7, he had every right to remarry and maintain his asst-pastorship. But the churches he was in at that time, would have yanked his credentials
thisquick, so he left before his divorce was finalized, iirc.
When a man enters into a marriage, he enters into a covenant with her and God. I do not deny this. Yet, in his sinner days, if he's maried 10 times, the one he is married to when he is saved, is his wife in the eyes of the Lord. If he were to divorce her based solely on the fact the church doesn't want him as a preacher and/or pastor, would have him committing another sin in divorcing her. I am not saying you're advocating that, but people look behind someone's conversion when God does not.
Come, I pray you, and we reason, saith Jehovah, If your sins are as scarlet, as snow they shall be white, If they are red as crimson, as wool they shall be!(Isaiah 1:18 YLT)
ALL of our sin are blotted out, never to be brought back before us ever again...at least not by God. Man will, as evidenced by this thread.........