• Welcome to Baptist Board, a friendly forum to discuss the Baptist Faith in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to all the features that our community has to offer.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

Hybrid Soteriology

Paleouss

Active Member
Site Supporter
Actually I think you are attempting to claim fallen people cannot actually seek God or trust in Christ without supernatural enablement. But of course you did not say that. Scripture says many will seek the narrow door that leads to life but will not find it. No amount of legerdemain will nullify the biblical teaching that many lost people seek God.
Greetings Van. I'm back from my wedding anniversary weekend. Made some good memories. I hope your weekend was a blessed one.
Actually I think you are attempting to claim fallen people cannot actually seek God or trust in Christ without supernatural enablement.
To be more precise, at least in what I think the Bible teaches, I do think that God has made the first move through His Cosmic Triumph of the Powers of Darkness and brought some light to all mankind (one of the multiple intentions of the cross).

One of the multiple intentions of the cross was that Jesus Christ was sent to be the "Savior of the world" (1John 4:14), a "Savior of all men" (1Tim 4:10) from the powers of sin and death that holds mankind as slaves within the kingdom of darkness. Upon His death and resurrection, Christ draws all people to Himself (John 12:32) (I emphasize the word "draws" here). And all people means all people without distinction or limit (the Calvinist are incorrect regarding John 12:32 due to the misunderstanding of multiple intentions).

From what I know of your theology, we are not in disagreement that one of the intentions of the cross was for all peoples. Where we disagree the most is in the working of the Spirit in the world. You, as I understand it, are more like a Diest (please correct me if I am wrong. I don't want to put labels on you that are not correct). I on the other hand am more, at least on this issue, like a prevenient grace or enabling grace type (I understand that neither you nor the Calvinist will accept my position)
Scripture says many will seek the narrow door that leads to life but will not find it.
I agree. Many may seek but not find. For those many will see the light that has been shown into this world that gives light to every man (John 1:9, John 3:19, John 8:12, John 9:5, John 12:46). Again, where I think you and I disagree is that I contend that the scripture attests to the fact that Christ has brought light to the world, first, and that light is accompanied by the Spirit (in some way). All see some amount of this light...some hide for they love sin and do not want their sin exposed, and some even seek the light but then fall away (sower parable). This is not a testament to a salvation that has failed but a demonstration of a lack of faith and belief (which in the end is submission) to a grace that God has afforded to all men.


Keep seeking God as if He was hidden treasure (Prov 2)
 

Van

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Greetings Van. I'm back from my wedding anniversary weekend. Made some good memories. I hope your weekend was a blessed one.

To be more precise, at least in what I think the Bible teaches, I do think that God has made the first move through His Cosmic Triumph of the Powers of Darkness and brought some light to all mankind (one of the multiple intentions of the cross).

One of the multiple intentions of the cross was that Jesus Christ was sent to be the "Savior of the world" (1John 4:14), a "Savior of all men" (1Tim 4:10) from the powers of sin and death that holds mankind as slaves within the kingdom of darkness. Upon His death and resurrection, Christ draws all people to Himself (John 12:32) (I emphasize the word "draws" here). And all people means all people without distinction or limit (the Calvinist are incorrect regarding John 12:32 due to the misunderstanding of multiple intentions).

From what I know of your theology, we are not in disagreement that one of the intentions of the cross was for all peoples. Where we disagree the most is in the working of the Spirit in the world. You, as I understand it, are more like a Diest (please correct me if I am wrong. I don't want to put labels on you that are not correct). I on the other hand am more, at least on this issue, like a prevenient grace or enabling grace type (I understand that neither you nor the Calvinist will accept my position)

I agree. Many may seek but not find. For those many will see the light that has been shown into this world that gives light to every man (John 1:9, John 3:19, John 8:12, John 9:5, John 12:46). Again, where I think you and I disagree is that I contend that the scripture attests to the fact that Christ has brought light to the world, first, and that light is accompanied by the Spirit (in some way). All see some amount of this light...some hide for they love sin and do not want their sin exposed, and some even seek the light but then fall away (sower parable). This is not a testament to a salvation that has failed but a demonstration of a lack of faith and belief (which in the end is submission) to a grace that God has afforded to all men.


Keep seeking God as if He was hidden treasure (Prov 2)
I see a lot of verbiage, but apparently of the double talk variety. The issue is not the "light" brought by God to humanity, the issue is whether or not lost humanity is able to receive it and respond such that God saves them without being enabled by supernatural alteration. I say the lost are able to respond to "spiritual milk" the fundamentals of the gospel.

All people are NOT drawn "upon Christ's "death and resurrection" People are "drawn" (attracted) when and if they "behold" (become aware) that Christ suffered crucifixion in order to provide the means of reconciliation to all people.

Yes, Christ died as a ransom for all.

You might believe I do not believe God intervenes and alters outcomes, but you have no basis for that fiction. Every salvation is an intervention altering the outcome. Prevenient grace is a fiction, as some of the lost, those fitting the categories of Soils #2, #3, and #4, are able to seek God and believe in Christ. There are absolutely no verses of scripture that teach all the lost are unable to seek God. Therefore "Prevenient grace" is a superfluous fiction.

Hopefully, we agree, once saved, always saved.
 

Paleouss

Active Member
Site Supporter
Greetings again and thank you for your reply.
I see a lot of verbiage, but apparently of the double talk variety.
Ahh, salt right out of the gate. Glad to be back. :) Starting from the end of your post and then moving forward.
Hopefully, we agree, once saved, always saved.
To this, it would seem we agree.
You might believe I do not believe God intervenes and alters outcomes, but you have no basis for that fiction.
Thank you for the clarification. You are here asserting that you are a not a Diest. Got it.
Every salvation is an intervention altering the outcome.
The evidence you give to show you are not a Diest would seem to be salvation. Your holding to the 'intervention' of salvation does exclude you from the strict definition of the term Diest. My apologies.
Prevenient grace is a fiction, as some of the lost, those fitting the categories of Soils #2, #3, and #4, are able to seek God and believe in Christ.
As I said in the other post, I understand you would not accept the concept of an enabling grace. I will point out that your assertion that mankind can 'seek' God needn't and does not logically necessitate that my assertion is false.
those fitting the categories of Soils #2, #3, and #4, are able to seek God and believe in Christ
We agree that Soils #2, #3, and #4 seek God. But you left out some important parts, imo. First, the seed was sown by the sower.

Second, we need to establish that the “Sower” is reasonably considered a vessel of God. The vessel isn’t doing his own work but the work of his Master. Further, “it is God who works” (Phil 2:13) in the vessel (Heb 13:21, Phil 2:13) so that His word is shown through the work of the man. As Zechariah 7:12 teaches, the “Lord of hosts” sends His “law and the words” by “His Spirit” through the vessels. In other words, it is the Spirit that accompanies the gospel words through the evangelist, which is the vessel of God’s work, to the listener. For what does the verse say, God sends his word by “His Spirit” (Zech 7:12). Likewise, it is the Spirit that is ever present and accompanying the utterances of the gospel words, called the “seed” that is being sown, through the sower. This presence of the Spirit in this gospel message of life, or sowing of the seed, is what makes “the word of God… living and powerful” (Heb 4:12) and of “spirit, and are life” (John 6:63).

Germination, which is what is shown in Soils #2, #3, and #4, serves as a powerful symbol of the beginnings of the informative and transformative power of God’s word. To me the point of the sowers parable isn't that man can seek God (although I accept your assertion that it shows this). The sowers parable's significant point is that there was germination, i.e., evidences of some life within (if only to be brief and fleeting as they fall away).

The words that contain life, which are the seeds, are literally “living and powerful” (Heb 4:12) because the words are accompanied by “His Spirit” (Zech 7:12) that are sown in the hearts of men (the soil). And the only explanation for benign concrete words being expressed as being of spirit and life is that the ever present Spirit is the ultimate source behind the sowing of the words, symbolized as seeds, to the heart (symbolized as soil).

In other words, it may be me as God’s servant who utters benign lifeless words, but it is the Spirit who works through me accompanying and sowing those words as “living and powerful” (Heb 4:12) to every heart. For what does Scripture say, the Spirit not only “upholds all things” (Heb 1:3), but is active and present in every moment in time (Psa 139:7). The Spirit is constantly “searching all things” (1Cor 2:10) especially the hearts of all men (Rom 8:27), judging the thoughts and attitudes of the hearts of all men (Heb 4:12). Further, this activity in conjunction with the experiential moment that the Spirit is upholding, exposes motives (1Cor 4:5). Thus, God “is actually not far from each one of us” (Acts 17:27, Jer 23:23).

The Spirit is every present and ever working in this world. In every moment of time.
Yes, Christ died as a ransom for all.
As a multiple intentions of the atonement advocate, I agree.
All people are NOT drawn "upon Christ's "death and resurrection" People are "drawn" (attracted) when and if they "behold" (become aware) that Christ suffered crucifixion in order to provide the means of reconciliation to all people.
Can you explain how your statement measures and explains John 12:32? I'm unclear on whether your objection is simply semantics or the taking of what I wrote as some literal version of drawing all people as Christ is ascending.

Can you explain your interpretation of John 12:32 so I can understand where you stand when Christ said, I "will draw all [peoples] to myself".
The issue is not the "light" brought by God to humanity, the issue is whether or not lost humanity is able to receive it and respond such that God saves them without being enabled by supernatural alteration. I say the lost are able to respond to "spiritual milk" the fundamentals of the gospel.
Considering that some would deny that there is a light to all mankind. It would seem that it would apply to this subject. But let me get more focused on what you want to talk about.

1. Does lost humanity receive the "light". I think as you can see through my posting, my answer is yes.
2. Can lost humanity respond to the light... of course. Even those in the body were once lost. But you want to also include all the others of humanity. So to them I also say yes. And yes there are some that actually do respond and seek for a time and fall away (this is not a denial of once saved always saved).
3. Can humanity respond to the light without an irresistible grace (I'm assuming this is what you are getting at. If not let me know).... this answer is yes.

So there you go, got off track. My apologies.


Peace to you brother.
 
Last edited:
Top