The point is that it really makes no difference. We no longer act in any way like we are "under God."
I would rather we not acknowledge God at all than some ethereal "God" without meaning or substance. Jesus spoke against "vain repetitions" such as you would continue to have a secular government impose.
I am a firm believer is individual soul liberty. No one should be forced to worship or even acknowledge God. It must be a matter of the heart. An unbeliever cannot be forced to acknowledge God by saying a socialist pledge at school every morning.
No is doubting that God played a greater role in our national psyche 50 years ago than He does today. No one is doubting that God, (even a secular deist god) played a greater role amongst the founding fathers. The point is that in 2005 America is no longer a nation who thinks of herself as under God. We kill millions of innocent children. We pollute the world with our pornography and so many other vile sins.
In some ways it is a slap in the face of God to proclaim in a pledge to a flag, or even a nation (no longer a true republic), to throw His holy name into the mix to give a semblance of recognition. In a day when the VAST majority of teachers in our tax sponsored schools are non-christians I would not want the question, "What is God" being answered by one of them, for most of them have no concept of the true God.
As to the Star Spangled Banner question, the answer is yes. If we ever get to the day when school children are compelled daily to recite the latter stanzas of it, then it probably will be called into question.
This country existed, thrived, and even endured a civil war without any pledge of allegiance. She survived and was victorious in two world wars without "under God" being included in a pledge. Look how the country has done since it was added. It hasn't helped much, has it? We lost a war, we have legalised infanticide, the Playboy (born about the same time the words were added) generation has sprung up, and marriage has collapsed as an institution all since "under God" became a part of the pledge. Maybe we were better off without these two words in our pledge.
[ September 17, 2005, 01:53 AM: Message edited by: C4K ]