Just as you do.
"The overwhelming majority of Christians who reject limited atonement also reject universal salvation. They are particularists, not universalists. They insist on the doctrine of justification by faith alone. That is, only believers are saved by the atonement of Christ.
"If that is so, then the atonement, in some sense, must be limited, or restricted, to a definite group, namely believers." *
So you, just like me, believe the Atonement is limited to believers.
*
Biblical Scholasticism by R.C. Sproul, Ligonier Ministries.
Biblical Scholasticism by R.C. Sproul