• Welcome to Baptist Board, a friendly forum to discuss the Baptist Faith in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to all the features that our community has to offer.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

Minimum wage

InTheLight

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
I never said anything about college. You said people having more money to spend means there is more inflation.

So that must mean that if people have less money to spend, there would be less inflation.

So a great way to do that would be for people to take pay cuts!

Where am I wrong?

You're wrong because people receiving pay cuts would not reduce the cost to produce goods. Prices would not drop if people received modest pay cuts, i.e. cuts equal to the percent change in the minimum wage over the years. There would need to be severe deflation before prices would come down across the board.
 

seekingthetruth

New Member
You're wrong because people receiving pay cuts would not reduce the cost to produce goods. Prices would not drop if people received modest pay cuts, i.e. cuts equal to the percent change in the minimum wage over the years. There would need to be severe deflation before prices would come down across the board.

What?

You propose that experienced, skilled workers take a pay cut so that minimum wage workers can be paid more?

That is socialism to the extreme!!!

Who would bother to go to college, or save up to start a business, or even learn a skill if we were all equal in the workforce?

They already tried that in Russia, Poland and several other countries, and all socialism does it to take the motivation out of people.

Think about it....if a school teacher and a ditch digger make an equal living, then how many people will want to go to college for 4 years to be a teacher?

It just doesnt work!

John
 

seekingthetruth

New Member
I never said anything about college. You said people having more money to spend means there is more inflation.

So that must mean that if people have less money to spend, there would be less inflation.

So a great way to do that would be for people to take pay cuts!

Where am I wrong? I'm going by your own logic here, aren't I?

Yes Gina, more money means more inflation...

See Economics 101 in any freshman college text..

Why in the world would you want skilled experienced workers to take a pay cut so that young kids and unmotivated people can make more?

Your logic is socialist at best!

John
 

Gina B

Active Member
You're wrong because people receiving pay cuts would not reduce the cost to produce goods. Prices would not drop if people received modest pay cuts, i.e. cuts equal to the percent change in the minimum wage over the years. There would need to be severe deflation before prices would come down across the board.

That makes no sense. You said that people having more money to spend increases inflation, so that means that people having less money to spend would decrease inflation. Are you changing your mind?

It also makes no sense to state you do not believe in a minimum wage, yet you are using it to gauge what your pay should be based on your education. Why are YOU deciding that? From what you've stated, your employer should have the freedom to only pay you $4 per hour if he so chooses, and if they all had a choice and there was no minimum wage, then I'm pretty sure that even the most educated people would be making less money. Nobody is going to pay more than a competitive rate, and that rate has to start somewhere. Start it at zero and you have major issues right off the bat.

In my mind, you should be thanking me for working for less than my education and experience allows. I can sign a paper right now and triple my salary, but I choose not to because the stress would be harder on my physical health and because we have enough, thanks to my husband having gained a job and them having a minimum wage requirement. More might be enjoyable, but it's not worth it to me to have less time at home and more stress in exchange for a few more creature comforts.

That is...if you honestly believe that people with less spending money help keep inflation down.

Like you said.
 

InTheLight

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
That makes no sense. You said that people having more money to spend increases inflation, so that means that people having less money to spend would decrease inflation. Are you changing your mind?

It also makes no sense to state you do not believe in a minimum wage,

From what you've stated, your employer should

Like you said.

Well, you've got me confused with someone else.

Man, I am just getting beat up this week and for no reason. What is going on?
 

InTheLight

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
What?

You propose that experienced, skilled workers take a pay cut so that minimum wage workers can be paid more?

And where did I say that?

Wow, it seems people's reading comprehension skills and ability to identify screen names are severely impaired. All I know is that I'm getting flak in multiple threads for stuff I never said.
 

Gina B

Active Member
Let's all just end this discussion and go to our respective living rooms for some iced tea, then brush our teeth and get a good night's sleep. :thumbs:
 

Salty

20,000 Posts Club
Administrator
Let's all just end this discussion and go to our respective living rooms for some iced tea, then brush our teeth and get a good night's sleep. :thumbs:

Will you pay me minimum wage if I brush my teeth?

Salty

ps, what was hubby's MOS?
 

Gina B

Active Member
Will you pay me minimum wage if I brush my teeth?

Salty

ps, what was hubby's MOS?

Now you sound like my one child, who thinks he should get paid just to take care of himself. ROFL

I could make this fun and just give you the code, but I'll be nice and make it simple. Vehicle maintenance. Poor guy didn't know any better and joined the AF because he saw a sign that said "Go Army" and thought the Army was leaving.

(oh help, he's gonna get me...hehehe)
 
Top