ccrobinson
Active Member
InTheLight said:Some really good stories, Impossible Astronaut...
I thought you didn't like The Impossible Astronaut?
There's just so many questions and goofy plot points.
I liked it a lot better when he was a quirky time lord traveling about with reluctant companions and getting into trouble then using his wits to save the day. Now he is resetting the universe, using shape-shifting robots, taking on a fresh set of regenerations, etc.-- and his character has generally become way larger than life.
I don't disagree, per se, but I've also enjoyed the story arcs. I think there's room in the Who universe for both.
But, I want to point out that this was the whole point of this paragraph.
ccrobinson said:Steven Moffat has single handedly extinguished the crazy world of RTD Doctor Who...
I think this is what Moffat wants to do, but you just don't go from the nonsense of Journey's End to getting where he wants to go without a "reset". Plus, he had the story of River Song that he wanted to tell. The rumor I've heard is that S7 is going to feature more stand-alone stories that don't have a season long story arc, though there are still some loose ends that haven't been tied up.
This makes the Doctor out to be some sort of a god.
This isn't some new concept that we've only seen in S5 and S6. RTD was doing this throughout his time as showrunner.