• Welcome to Baptist Board, a friendly forum to discuss the Baptist Faith in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to all the features that our community has to offer.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

Prozac

LadyEagle

<b>Moderator</b> <img src =/israel.gif>
The Bible says, "Don't be anxious," do you have a verse that says the opposite?
Yes it does. But you are making the faulty assumption that being anxious and depressed are the same thing, that anxiousness and depression are interchangeable. They are not.

Originally posted by ShagNappy:
After you do the same for the flu, cancer, enlarged prostates, yeast infections, pnuemonia, ingrown toenails. If you cannot provide scriptural proof an ailments exists, I must demand you never seek medical help for it or else you are turning your back to God.
Originally posted by Lorelei


God didn't tell me in His word NOT to have those things, so I haven't turned my back on Him. He does say NOT to be anxious, so I have learned to trust in Him and am now, no longer anxious! How wonderful it is to experience the peace He has promised!
Again, being anxious and being depressed are two different maladies. Being anxious originates from fearfulness, a spiritual condition, sin. Having biological depression does not originate from the emotions or will of the individual and is therefore not sin. It is the result of the curse, as are all physical maladies, but does not originate, nor is it centered in the will.
 

JGrubbs

New Member
I am saddend by the fact that so many in the church are so quick to "shoot the wounded" within the church when it comes to the issue of mental disorders. I will be the first to agree that the world is too quick to diagnose people with depression, etc., but that doesn't mean that there aren't people who DO suffer from these disorders. I have been studying and working with those with mental disorders for over five years now. You can't tell me that someone who is bi-polar is that way by choice. Many great pastors across America suffer from clinical depression, don't be so "holier than thou", that you ignorantly label these people as suffering because of their choice to "live in sin".
 

Thankful

<img src=/BettyE.gif>
I feel as if some of you are confusing the mind with the soul.

Your soul experiences joy, peace, and love.

Your mind is going to die with your body.

Your soul goes to heaven.

A person does have a choice to accept Jesus as Savior which will give the soul eternal life and joy, peace, and love.

The soul of a Christian who is depressed never loses its joy, peace, love, or salvation.


The mind and body are connected. Each influences the other.

And with your logic, I could probably come up with scripture that would say that a person chooses cancer, heart disease, or diabetes which, of course, is not true.
 

Thankful

<img src=/BettyE.gif>
He does say NOT to be anxious, so I have learned to trust in Him and am now, no longer anxious! How wonderful it is to experience the peace He has promised!
Amen, Sister Lorelei. I totally agree with that statement. I had trouble with worry for many years until I learned to lay all my troubles at the foot of the cross and let our Lord God take care of me. You are correct. It is a wonderful peace to experience.

BUT, I have never had depression and I praise God for that! If I did have depression, I would go to a doctor and take the medicine he prescribes for it.
 

Lorelei

<img src ="http://www.amacominc.com/~lorelei/mgsm.
Originally posted by I Am Blessed 16:
What are your thoughts concerning Prozac? Do you know anyone who is taking it? What is the good/bad? Anyone familiar with it? Please help.


My thoughts concerning Prozac are addressed in my thoughts concerning depression. The bad thing about it is that is prescribed to treat spiritual problems, not physical ones.

~Lorelei
 

Lorelei

<img src ="http://www.amacominc.com/~lorelei/mgsm.
Originally posted by Charles Meadows:
I assume that by anxious you refer to Paul's use of "merimnao" - used here as a present imperative. This word refers to having care for things of life - specifically spending alot of time worrying about the little things of life and not the things of God, thus being carnally minded. It does not address, nor does it mean biologic depression.



Web Mdsays that "GAD (Generalized Anxiety Disorder) is characterized by excessive, exaggerated anxiety and worry about everyday life events."
Like Depression, this is treated as a clinical disease, when the Bible says it is not.

I used this verse to prove that anxiety is not a disease. I used the verse about the fruit of the Spirit being joy and peace as proof that depression is not a disease.

Both of these disorders are claimed to be medical disorders. The Bible says they are not.

Originally posted by Charles Meadows:
Yes you quoted scripture - never mind that you misapply it!
I applied it to the appropriate disorder. Do you or do you not think "anxiety" is a disease?

You still have quoted no scripture that says it is ok to have "clinical anxiety" and not experience "joy and peace" if you suffer from "clinical Depression."

~Lorelei
 

JGrubbs

New Member
I highly recommend browsing the Christian Depression Pages found online at http://www.gospelcom.net/cdp/

Depression has afflicted man for hundreds of years. King David had some very depressing times in his life. He wrote in Psalm 31:9,10:

"Have mercy on me, O Lord, for I am in trouble; My eye wastes away with grief, Yes, my soul and my body! For my life is spent with grief, And my years with sighing; My strength fails because of my iniquity, And my bones waste away."
 

Lorelei

<img src ="http://www.amacominc.com/~lorelei/mgsm.
Originally posted by LadyEagle:
Yes it does. But you are making the faulty assumption that being anxious and depressed are the same thing, that anxiousness and depression are interchangeable. They are not.


No, I was addressing what is referred to as clinical anxiety. Do you believe that anxiety as well as depression is a medical rather than spiritual disorder?

Originally posted by LadyEagle:
Again, being anxious and being depressed are two different maladies. Being anxious originates from fearfulness, a spiritual condition, sin. Having biological depression does not originate from the emotions or will of the individual and is therefore not sin. It is the result of the curse, as are all physical maladies, but does not originate, nor is it centered in the will.
Depression is feeling "sad or despondant." The fruit of the Spirit is not extreme sadness or "hopelessness." The fruit of the Spirit is the opposite of the definition for "depression." Depression is often equated with anxiety. Webmd says that it is often caused by other "mental illnesses" such as anxiety disorder. The medical community often speaks about depression and anxiety disorders together, so I have chosen to do the same. Most anti-deppresant drug commmercials claim that their medication can help depression and anxiety. I am simply showing that the Bible teaches that both are behavioral disorders that the Spirit can correct. Do you have any Scripture that proves that anything other than God and His Spirit helped anyone in the Bible overcome depression or anxiety? Are there any Scriptures that excuse such behavior?

~Lorelei
 

Lorelei

<img src ="http://www.amacominc.com/~lorelei/mgsm.
Originally posted by NetPublicist:
Depression has afflicted man for hundreds of years. King David had some very depressing times in his life.
Yes, and what was His solution to the problem? Did he seek a therapist or the counsel of God?

Ps 62:1 My soul finds rest in God alone; my salvation comes from him. 2 He alone is my rock and my salvation; he is my fortress, I will never be shaken... 5 Find rest, O my soul, in God alone; my hope comes from him. 6 He alone is my rock and my salvation; he is my fortress, I will not be shaken. 7 My salvation and my honor depend on God; he is my mighty rock, my refuge. 8 Trust in him at all times, O people; pour out your hearts to him, for God is our refuge. (NIV)
~Lorelei
 

I Am Blessed 24

Active Member
LL: You have quoted no scripture that says it is NOT all right.

The Bible DOES tell us to be anxious for nothing, but nowhere in the Bible does it say we cannot achieve this with the help of medication and/or counseling.

You are adding to God's Word...
 

JGrubbs

New Member
Some have a false belief that committed Christians will never get depression. Or if you have depression, you should just pray more, have more faith, trust God more-only sinners or weak Christians get depressed. I guess these people forget about men of God like Job, King David, Jeremiah, and many more Bible characters who experienced depression at times in their life.

Other Christians believe depression is caused by demonic oppression or possession. We do not deny that their at times may be demonic influences in regards to depression. However, too many Christians give the devil too much power. No where is scripture does it state that Job, King David, or Jeremiah were oppressed or possessed. There is not a demon behind every corner.

Another false concept is that depression or mental illnesses are only symptoms of spiritual problems. This also is a lie from the enemy of our souls. Yes, mental illness and depression can be a spiritual issue, but most of the time it is caused by chemical/hormonal imbalances in the body. Counseling alone is not always effective in helping a person come to emotional health. There are times for medication which helps bring the chemical/hormonal levels to the proper level. Christians will take medication for diabetes, heart disease, headaches, migraines, arthritis, ulcers, etc. but if you suggest medication for depression, they suddenly think you do not have enough faith. What is silly is that many of the physical sicknesses mentioned can be caused by bitterness, unforgiveness, perfectionism, malice-which are spiritual, mental, and emotional issues. But guess what? If you have migraines, I would suggest you take medication until you work out the root cause of getting migraines. And the same for depression or mental illness-take medication until you work out the root causes. I speak from experience. I was on Prozac for a year to work through my depression. For literally years before then I struggled as a Christian with depression. Maybe I should have had more faith-but the reality I didn't, and medication got me back to health.

One final point about depression and medication. Don't think that taking medication will remove all your problems, remove emotional pain, make life "wonderful", bring total peace, give you false hope. The proper administration of medication will not do any of these things. What it does do is help bring balance and a proper perspective to life. You will still experience the 'bumps in life'. It just removes The Edge.

SOURCE
 

Lorelei

<img src ="http://www.amacominc.com/~lorelei/mgsm.
Originally posted by LadyEagle:
Lack of understanding of physical illness and medicine without the benefit of technology developed in the last 50 years drove people to burn some people at the stake, too.


No one here is condoning such absurd behavior or suggesting that anyone be burned at the stake. The Bible never commanded such a thing and to do so was sinful.

Originally posted by LadyEagle:
Named for St. Anthony, the patron saint of those infected with the disease, "St. Anthony's Fire" was sometimes linked with epidemics of "dancing mania" which occurred between the thirteenth and sixteenth centuries, and may explain the psychosis and convulsions attributed to the women accused of witchcraft in the Salem trials of 1692.


Yes, ingesting toxic chemicals will do terrible things to your body. There are chemicals that can effect our behavior. Alcohol is one of them, and we can see from the Scripture's admonition to refrain from becoming intoxicated, that is an undesired effect. Of course Paxil, Prozac, Zoloft and other drugs also effect your behavior. Would God really condone one drug over another?


Originally posted by LadyEagle:
Another not mentioned in the Bible:

</font><blockquote>quote:</font><hr />
Tourette Syndrome is a neurological disorder that manifests itself in the form of body and/or facial tics, and sometimes verbal tics, in the thousands of children and young adults who live with this disorder. This neurological disorder is hereditary.

Throughout history this disorder of the neurological system has been misunderstood. In the past many Tourette Syndrome sufferers, particularly those with severe tics, were often thought possessed. They were often isolated from the public, and many underwent extreme and harsh treatment (burned at the stake, flogging, lobotomies, etc. ) by the public, authorities and/or medical community. Many people with Tourette's were often committed to insane asylums.
source

Does the person with Tourette syndrome have a "choice?"</font>[/QUOTE]


I take it you are assuming that Tourette Syndrome is a provable physical disorder. I actually thought the same thing until I did a bit of research. It appears that the medical community has lied to us again.

<a href="http://www.tsa-usa.org/" target="_blank">
Tourette Syndrome Association</a>
David Pauls, Ph.D., a Yale Child Study Center population
geneticist, said that the Consortium's study discovered "two small pieces of the genome that may be strongly implicated with TS and four additional regions that may contribute" to Tourette Syndrome.

"This is the best information that we've ever had in terms of the actual location of a gene of genes for TS," Dr. Pauls said. "It is a major step forward."
A step forward, but still they have nothing to prove thier theory! They have not proven that TS is a physical disorder. There is NO "physical" way of testing to see if a person has TS.

http://www.tourettesyndrome.net/tourette_primer3.htm
Currently, there is no brain test or laboratory test to determine if someone has Tourette's. The diagnosis is a clinical one, which means that it's based on the professional taking a careful history, observing the patient, and arranging for any tests that might be necessary to rule out other conditions that could look like Tourette's or that could cause tics.
In fact, TS is still treated as a "mental" disorder. You will find it listed in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders IV. If it is a "physical" disorder beyond our control, why is it being treated as a "Mental" one?

Who "discovered" Tourette Syndrome anyway?

<a href="http://www.tsa-usa.org/" target="_blank">
Tourette Syndrome Association Georges Gilles de la Tourette </a>

Georges Gilles de la Tourette (born Georges Albert Edouard Brutus Gilles de la Tourette!) in 1857, made several valuable contributions to medicine and literature. His greatest achievements were in the study of hysteria and hypnotism; a competent neuropsychiatrist, he was particularly interested in therapy. With a colleague, he wrote a highly perceptive analysis of Sister Jeanne des Anges' account of her "hysterical illness" which was caused by her unrequited love for a priest.
Someone accused me of thinking that I am "smarter" than the researchers. Well, I am not suggesting that I am "smarter" than anyone. The facts have been presented.

The Bible tells us not to sin and TS is supposed to cause a person to curse uncontrollably.


Georges Gilles de la Tourette, a man who spent his life studying "hypnotism" says that it is, and everyone chooses to believe him. Among all of the writings and research that has been done since He discovered TS there is still NO evidence to prove anything they say.

I choose to continue to believe that God would not allow a person who was controlled by the Spirit of God to break the commandments of that Spirit. I do not believe that any ailment has more power than God's Spirit. When the Bible says that the fruit of the Spirit is joy and peace, then that is what I expect a person who is "walking" in the Spirit to have. Otherwise, the Holy Spirit is not as powerful as our bodies.

One last thought:

Does anyone know what neuroscientists study?

http://faculty.washington.edu/chudler/what.html
What do neuroscientists study

1. Behavioral Level: study of the neural basis of behavior. In other words, what causes people and animals to do the things they do.
People, psychology and science believe that behavior is caused by the neurons in our brains! If this is true the entire Bible is a lie! Wake up, this is not Scriptural! If you believe the Bible you should oppose anything that tries to discredit it. The Bible says we are responsible for our behavior! Is this true, or is God sending people to hell for making them with nuerons that make them engange in sinful behavior? In other words, they can't help it! My God did no such thing! We have been warned about such things in the Bible.

Col 2:8 See to it that no one takes you captive through hollow and deceptive philosophy, which depends on human tradition and the basic principles of this world rather than on Christ.
(NIV)
~Lorelei
 

Lorelei

<img src ="http://www.amacominc.com/~lorelei/mgsm.
Originally posted by I Am Blessed 16:
LL: You have quoted no scripture that says it is NOT all right.

The Bible DOES tell us to be anxious for nothing, but nowhere in the Bible does it say we cannot achieve this with the help of medication and/or counseling.

You are adding to God's Word...
No, I am simply believing it.

Phil 4:6-9
6 Do not be anxious about anything, but in everything, by prayer and petition, with thanksgiving, present your requests to God. 7 And the peace of God, which transcends all understanding, will guard your hearts and your minds in Christ Jesus.

8 Finally, brothers, whatever is true, whatever is noble, whatever is right, whatever is pure, whatever is lovely, whatever is admirable-if anything is excellent or praiseworthy-think about such things. 9 Whatever you have learned or received or heard from me, or seen in me-put it into practice. And the God of peace will be with you.
(NIV)
If I do these things then the God of peace will be with me and guard my heart and mind. Is this true or not?

This is the way to experience the peace of God. The bible does not tell me that medication is the way, that counseling is the way, or any other method known to man. The Bible says THIS is the way to experience peace.

Believe it, or beleive man, but quit pretending you can beleive both.

~Lorelei
 

Lorelei

<img src ="http://www.amacominc.com/~lorelei/mgsm.
Netpublicist,

You have no Scipture to back up what you said. When men of God experienced depression they went to God for help.

When man takes medication for a disease he has usually been tested for that disease. Someone mentioned Down Syndrome, a genetic disorder that my daughter has. Before my daughter was diagnosed, they "tested" her for this disease. They found that she had 3 of the #21 chromosome instead of two like most everyone else.

No one tests anyone for depression and in fact no amount of medication ever "permanantly" fixes the amount of "chemicals" in our brain. You will notice that the meds are constantly adjusted and changed because the "chemicals" are constanstly adjusting and changing. If there is no "normal" known "number of "chemicals" that will cause "normal" behavior, then how do we know that the "chemicals" that are out of wack are the cause rather than merely a symptom?

The fact is they don't know that. My mother has been on anti-depressants for 15 years. She has been on several different kinds and had several different doses of each. She still suffers from depression.

Yes, people were depressed in the Bible. But...when they were, did they stay that way and say "they couldn't help it?" No! They turned to God for help and guess what? They weren't depressed any longer! They didn't need medicine or therapy, all they needed was God, who supplies ALL of our needs!

2 Tim 1:6-7
7 For God did not give us a spirit of timidity, but a spirit of power, of love and of self-discipline.
(NIV)
~Lorelei
 

Charles Meadows

New Member
Lorelei,

Your degree of misunderstanding defies description!

You have done research and discovered that there are no accurate diagnostic testes for Tourette's syndrome? Do you think that every disorder must have a "test" to prove it? Do you think a "test" proves anything 100%?

You don't agree that behavior is "caused by neurons in our brains"? Do you think that the brain operates by magic or something? There is a physical basis for everything - science simply tries to find it out!

"When men of God experienced depression they went to God for help."

This is what all of us have been saying from the beginning! What Christian wouldn't say this? There still is no scripture to say that taking a dose of antidepressant is sinful as long as the believer first puts things in God's hands.
 

PastorGreg

Member
Site Supporter
Lorelei,

I appreciate your positions and your dependence on Scripture, but you are wasting your time. It's interesting that on the Baptist Board (Baptists being those who claim to have the Bible as their only rule of faith and practice) those who depend on the Bible as their only rule of faith and practice are shouted down and called all kinds of names by those who humanistically argue from experience or the findings of the "experts." No one will respond to your Scriptural points because they cannot. Their authority is psychology (anti-God by definition) and experience.
 

Jeff Weaver

New Member
Pastor Greg

You got it partly right. The Bible is the only rule of faith and practice. It is not a book on biology. The brain and how it functions is biologoy.
 

Charles Meadows

New Member
PastorGreg:

2 Pet 1:20 "Knowing this first, that no prophecy of the scripture is of any private interpretation."

You say that the bible should be our only rule book. That's all well and good - it should be our rule book. But the verses of the bible were meant to address certain things. As I've explained umpteen times before - Paul clearly is not even addressing depression or any mental illness in Phil 4:6-8. He is basically saying to trust God in all things - and no rightminded pastor or Christian doctor would advocate anything else.

The problem is that you and others have decided to put words in Paul's (and God's) mouth and hijack this verse, making it say something it didn't intend to say. You are privately interpreting the verse - and that is false doctrine.

Then you accuse anyone who uses his or her mind (a tool which God gave us) of bowing to humanism. This is like an ostrich putting its head in the sand!! God does not expect Christians to be stupid!!

I think you and some of these others have a preconceived notion of how things should be and you twist scripture any which way to make it appear so.

***Edited to strike personal attacks***

Blackbird--Moderator

[ May 11, 2004, 06:04 PM: Message edited by: blackbird ]
 
Top