Rep. Patrick Kennedy Denied Communion

[Agnus_Dei]

On the whole "does it damn Catholics to not receive communion" issue, there are plenty of practising Catholics who don't and can't receive. Who are they? Those who are divorced and remarried. At no stage have I ever heard the Catholic Church call their salvation into question because of that.

When I was in Roman Catholic RCIA classes, our class was informed that missing communion out of laziness or without prior approval from your parish priest was a mortal sin.

From an Orthodox Church perspective, it's up to me when and if I should abstain from the chalice...meaning if I haven't properly prepared myself for communion, I should abstain. I know some Orthodox Christians that take communion only on major feast days or only on Pascha. BUT, for example, if an Orthodox Christian is separated from his or her spouse or is divorced, they will not be allowed to approach the chalice for communion until the priest sees fit.

So from a RCC perspective, I'm sure if the parish priest tells a practicing Catholic to abstain from the elements (for whatever reason), their salvation isn't in jeopardy...but it seems to me from my RCIA class if you willfully abstain then it is a mortal sin, until he/she confesses...maybe I should've asked more questions, but didn't.

In XC
-

 

[lori4dogs]

When I was in Roman Catholic RCIA classes, our class was informed that missing communion out of laziness or without prior approval from your parish priest was a mortal sin.

From an Orthodox Church perspective, it's up to me when and if I should abstain from the chalice...meaning if I haven't properly prepared myself for communion, I should abstain. I know some Orthodox Christians that take communion only on major feast days or only on Pascha. BUT, for example, if an Orthodox Christian is separated from his or her spouse or is divorced, they will not be allowed to approach the chalice for communion until the priest sees fit.

So from a RCC perspective, I'm sure if the parish priest tells a practicing Catholic to abstain from the elements (for whatever reason), their salvation isn't in jeopardy...but it seems to me from my RCIA class if you willfully abstain then it is a mortal sin, until he/she confesses...maybe I should've asked more questions, but didn't.

In XC
-

I believe your explanation is accurate. For a person to know that they have a broken relationship with the Lord due to sin and to willfully refuse to confess that sin would be mortal sin. Also, St. Paul makes it clear that there are consequences for knowing that you have sin in your life and to take communion without re-establishing that broken relationship.

 

[Zenas]

On the whole "does it damn Catholics to not receive communion" issue, there are plenty of practising Catholics who don't and can't receive. Who are they? Those who are divorced and remarried. At no stage have I ever heard the Catholic Church call their salvation into question because of that.

I think they would. They can't receive communion because they are living in the mortal sin of adultry, unless their previous marriage(s) have been annulled. Under these circumstances going to confession would avail them nothing because the adultry is a continuing sin. The church would regard them as still being married to their former spouses.