• Welcome to Baptist Board, a friendly forum to discuss the Baptist Faith in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to all the features that our community has to offer.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

The Doctrine of God Requires the Inclusion of Acts 8:37

Kai

Well-Known Member
@Kai,
Regarding Acts 8:37. How do you recognize it as God breathed word?
88% mss omit it? Only.0.6% mss agree with our KJV.
The ". . thou mayist . . . . " Is an legal permission!

I don't think manuscript percentages alone settle the question of originality. The age, geographical distribution, and historical testimony of manuscripts also deserve consideration. A minority reading isn't automatically inauthentic any more than a majority reading is automatically original.

Regarding whether it is God-breathed, I believe the question is which reading best represents the original text. Irenaeus reference demonstrates that this reading has early historical support.

As for "thou mayest," I don't see the problem. It simply expresses permission or allowance in the context of Philip explaining the requirement for baptism.
 

Silverhair

Well-Known Member
"All scripture is given by insiration of God" we are told. I believe that.

I agree but the question is why do you want to insert text that, according to biblical scholarship, is not included in the inspired text?

The best texts omit this verse. Vincent's Word Studies
 

Silverhair

Well-Known Member
I don't think manuscript percentages alone settle the question of originality. The age, geographical distribution, and historical testimony of manuscripts also deserve consideration. A minority reading isn't automatically inauthentic any more than a majority reading is automatically original.

Regarding whether it is God-breathed, I believe the question is which reading best represents the original text. Irenaeus reference demonstrates that this reading has early historical support.

As for "thou mayest," I don't see the problem. It simply expresses permission or allowance in the context of Philip explaining the requirement for baptism.

Yes Irenaeus and Cyprian may have referenced that text but we see from Clarke's comments that the early and wide spread manuscripts did not have it. It most likely had been a side note that letter got copied into the text.

This whole verse is omitted by ABCG, several others of the first authority, Erpen’s edit. of the Arabic, the Syriac, the Coptic, Sahidic, Ethiopic, and some of the Slavonic: almost all the critics declare against it as spurious. ....In those MSS. where it is extant it exists in a variety of forms, though the sense is the same.
Adam Clarke's Commentary on the Bible

When you have manuscripts this wide spread that do not include the text in question then the weight of evidence falls to them and those that side with the inclusion have to provide strong evidence to support their position.

This entire verse is missing in the oldest and best manuscripts - ('Aleph ('), A B C G H, etc.; in the best manuscript of the Vulgate (the Codex Amiatinus of the first hand), in the Peshito Syriac, and in both the Egyptian versions; in Chrysostom also. It must be regarded, therefore, as an interpolation: but certainly it is a very early one; because we find it both in the Greek of Irenaeus and in the Latin version of it, in the second century.
Jamieson, Fausset, Brown
 

Kai

Well-Known Member
Yes Irenaeus and Cyprian may have referenced that text but we see from Clarke's comments that the early and wide spread manuscripts did not have it. It most likely had been a side note that letter got copied into the text.

As I said, I’m not taking a dogmatic stance on it. No one will be led astray either way.
 

37818

Well-Known Member
.
As for "thou mayest," I don't see the problem. It simply expresses permission or allowance in the context of Philip explaining the requirement for baptism.
We don't agree.

Jesus taught the unbaptized thief would be with Him in Paradise.
 

Kai

Well-Known Member
Jesus taught the unbaptized thief would be with Him in Paradise.

He did not need to be baptized in water, because baptism is an outward expression of an inward experience. In other words, it does not save.

One can recognize that with or without the inclusion of Acts 8:37.
 

37818

Well-Known Member
He did not need to be baptized in water, because baptism is an outward expression of an inward experience. In other words, it does not save.

One can recognize that with or without the inclusion of Acts 8:37.
It would seem ". . . thou mayist. . . ." Legal permission was never necessary.
 
Top