• Welcome to Baptist Board, a friendly forum to discuss the Baptist Faith in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to all the features that our community has to offer.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

The Nature of the Church, OT and NT

Status
Not open for further replies.

John of Japan

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Paul alludes to it in Galatians though, as he addresses jersualem of the flesh/earthly, and the one that is spiritually and heavenly...
I don't see "spiritual Israel" there. And I believe the Jerusalem in Heaven is a real, physical place--the New Jerusalem of Rev.
 

John of Japan

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Would anyone care to actually address the OP and my point that the characteristics of the NT church are nowhere seen in any OT setting? If not, this thread is a total win for me. :Cool
 

TCassidy

Late-Administator Emeritus
Administrator
Well said. But don't expect any interaction from individuals who have already convinced themselves (in their ignorance :)).
I'm not holding my breath. It would seem that many (most?) of the posters in this thread have committed the root fallacy by insisting the meaning of the word εκκλησια is based on its etymology rather than (correctly) seeing that the meaning of the word, at the time it was given in the bible, should be understood by its philology.

Dr. Clearwaters used to tell us that a man could not claim good Theology or claim to be a Theologian until he mastered both the etymology and philology of the words in the bible.

In fact he strongly encouraged us to purchase our own personal copies of the Oxford English Dictionary which contains a thorough philological section defining the meaning of the word in common usage.

I bought the "compact" edition (only two huge volumes 12" by 16" and each volume about 4" thick) with four pages shrunk down and put on a single page (they even provided a magnifying glass to read it). It is still available from Amazon for $399 (or used from around $50). The full size 20 volume set is only $1118 plus tax, shipping and handling, of course. :)
 

Jerome

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Dr. Clearwaters....strongly encouraged us to purchase our own personal copies of the Oxford English Dictionary which contains a thorough philological section defining the meaning of the word in common usage. I bought the "compact" edition (only two huge volumes 12" by 16" and each volume about 4" thick) with four pages shrunk down and put on a single page (they even provided a magnifying glass to read it). It is still available from Amazon for $399 (or used from around $50). The full size 20 volume set is only $1118 plus tax, shipping and handling, of course. :)

The entire Oxford English Dictionary is also available online.

I've cited it here numerous times, however 'InTheLight' has said of it:
the Oxford Dictionary...outdated...in the UK, and hardly ever used in the U.S.
 

loDebar

Well-Known Member
Would anyone care to actually address the OP and my point that the characteristics of the NT church are nowhere seen in any OT setting? If not, this thread is a total win for me. :Cool

Do you accept the converse where the OT Israel is a type of the Church, the body of Christ ?
 

Yeshua1

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Would anyone care to actually address the OP and my point that the characteristics of the NT church are nowhere seen in any OT setting? If not, this thread is a total win for me. :Cool
I agree with you that the Church started in the NT, but also do see OT saints as being part of it, included into it by God...
 

John of Japan

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
I'm not holding my breath. It would seem that many (most?) of the posters in this thread have committed the root fallacy by insisting the meaning of the word εκκλησια is based on its etymology rather than (correctly) seeing that the meaning of the word, at the time it was given in the bible, should be understood by its philology.

Dr. Clearwaters used to tell us that a man could not claim good Theology or claim to be a Theologian until he mastered both the etymology and philology of the words in the bible.
Wish I could have taken classes from him.

In fact he strongly encouraged us to purchase our own personal copies of the Oxford English Dictionary which contains a thorough philological section defining the meaning of the word in common usage.

I bought the "compact" edition (only two huge volumes 12" by 16" and each volume about 4" thick) with four pages shrunk down and put on a single page (they even provided a magnifying glass to read it). It is still available from Amazon for $399 (or used from around $50). The full size 20 volume set is only $1118 plus tax, shipping and handling, of course. :)
Wow, I'm jealous! But why didn't you buy the whole 20 volumes--as a young student? :Biggrin
 

John of Japan

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Do you accept the converse where the OT Israel is a type of the Church, the body of Christ ?
No, because this misunderstands the nature of a type, which uses an historical person or event as an illustration. (The Greek word tupos is sometimes translated as "example" or "ensample.") An institution or nation is not really a type.
 
Last edited:

John of Japan

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
I agree with you that the Church started in the NT, but also do see OT saints as being part of it, included into it by God...
So OT saints were baptized in the name of Jesus and celebrated the Lord's Supper? And some of them were pastors and deacons? And they met on Sunday to celebrate the resurrection of the Lord Jesus Christ?
 

Yeshua1

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
So OT saints were baptized in the name of Jesus and celebrated the Lord's Supper? And some of them were pastors and deacons? And they met on Sunday to celebrate the resurrection of the Lord Jesus Christ?
No, they are included into the body of Christ because they were saved same way we all were, but the death/resurrection of jhesus christ on their behalf!
 

TCassidy

Late-Administator Emeritus
Administrator
Wish I could have taken classes from him.
He was a brilliant man. He had a Masters in New Testament Greek, having studied under Edgar Goodspeed, and, like Dr. Cedarholm, completed his work for a Ph.D. but found himself in dire financial straits and never completed his dissertation. But he did have the teaching of such greats as Robert Dick Wilson, R.A. Torrey, G. Campbell Morgan, Griffith Thomas and Billy Sunday to help shape his ministry.

Wow, I'm jealous! But why didn't you buy the whole 20 volumes--as a young student?
Well, a thousand dollars was a little out of my price range. Okay, okay! Ten dollars would have been out of my price range! Look up "starving student" in the dictionary and all you will see is a picture of me! :D
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top