• Welcome to Baptist Board, a friendly forum to discuss the Baptist Faith in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to all the features that our community has to offer.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

The Spiritual Life of Infants

JonC

Moderator
Moderator
If Adam was spiritually dead before he sinned simply because he was flesh and had not been born spiritually, then what death was threatened in Genesis 2:17?
God tells us what the Genesis 2:17 death was im Genesis 3:19 when He tells Adam the consequences of his actions. God says it is "returning to the ground", returning to "dust". It is physical death, but as it is appointed man once to die (physical death) and then the Judgment this death held a sting.


This is an interesting topic. But it is not the topic of the OP.
 

Ben1445

Well-Known Member
God tells us what the Genesis 2:17 death was im Genesis 3:19 when He tells Adam the consequences of his actions. God says it is "returning to the ground", returning to "dust". It is physical death, but as it is appointed man once to die (physical death) and then the Judgment this death held a sting.


This is an interesting topic. But it is not the topic of the OP.
It was mentioned a while back that Adam sinned because he was made of dirt. It has been a kind of running sidetrack for a while now.
 

JonC

Moderator
Moderator
It was mentioned a while back that Adam sinned because he was made of dirt. It has been a kind of running sidetrack for a while now.
It has. I do not get the "made of dirt" argument. But Adam sinned because he was flesh with the desires of the flesh. When desire conceives it gives birth to sin, and sin when it is fully grown brings forth death.

I think it is important when reading Genesis to allow Scriptute interpret Scriptire. Sometimes chapter and verse divisions mislead people into fragmenting God's Word. But Genesis 3:19 (where God tells Adam the consequences of his actions) is in the same narrative where death is presented as a comsequence of sin.

We know this death speaks of "returning to the grpund", returning to "dust". But we debate what kind of dying (the body dying or one dying spiritually) this is.

If we read carefully we may realize that the wages of sin, this death, is never called God's judgment. Judgment comes afterwards.


But you are right - this has nothing to do with the OP.
 

JonC

Moderator
Moderator
@Anthony Pritchard wrote about separation. Sin separates us from God as it is disobeying God.

Infants simply have not sinned. They are not separated from God. In fact, to them belongs the kingdom. They are innocent. They have no knowledge of good and evil. But once this knowledge comes, once their eyes are opened to this knowledge, sin exists in them.
 

Ben1445

Well-Known Member
It has. I do not get the "made of dirt" argument. But Adam sinned because he was flesh with the desires of the flesh. When desire conceives it gives birth to sin, and sin when it is fully grown brings forth death.

I think it is important when reading Genesis to allow Scriptute interpret Scriptire. Sometimes chapter and verse divisions mislead people into fragmenting God's Word. But Genesis 3:19 (where God tells Adam the consequences of his actions) is in the same narrative where death is presented as a comsequence of sin.

We know this death speaks of "returning to the grpund", returning to "dust". But we debate what kind of dying (the body dying or one dying spiritually) this is.

If we read carefully we may realize that the wages of sin, this death, is never called God's judgment. Judgment comes afterwards.


But you are right - this has nothing to do with the OP.
Are you saying that Adam had the desires of a sin nature before sin because he was made from dirt?
Fleshly desires are the desires of fallen man. It isn’t hunger. The desires In question are those that war against the spirit. God gave man an appetite and food designed to feed it. Adam didn’t have a sin nature just because God gave him a body made from earth.
 

JonC

Moderator
Moderator
Are you saying that Adam had the desires of a sin nature before sin because he was made from dirt?
Fleshly desires are the desires of fallen man. It isn’t hunger. The desires In question are those that war against the spirit. God gave man an appetite and food designed to feed it. Adam didn’t have a sin nature just because God gave him a body made from earth.
No. I am not saying that Adam had the desires of a sin nature because he was made of dirt.

I am saying that Adam was made a living being, made flesh, and had the dedires of the flesh.

Here is the process by which sin occurres-

1. Every man is tempted, when he is drawn away of his own lust, and enticed. Adam was tempted to disobey God (either by the fruit itself, by Eve, or perhaps both).

2. When lust has conceived, it brings forth sin

3. Sin, when it is finished, brings forth death.

It has nothing to do with dirt.
 

percho

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
It was mentioned a while back that Adam sinned because he was made of dirt. It has been a kind of running sidetrack for a while now.
That post did not say Adam sinned because he was made of dirt. It says because he was made fleshly out of the dust of the ground he was sold under sin. Sold for the purpose of being redeemed from sin and death.

Romans 8:20 for to vanity was the creation made subject -- not of its will, but because of Him who did subject it -- in hope, that also the creation itself shall be set free from the servitude of the corruption to the liberty of the glory of the children of God;

The creation was subjected to servitude of the corruption, not of it's will but in hope.

I ask you. Is the hope of R 8:20 redemption?
According to V23 redemption of what?
According to V's 24,25 is it, unto that hope, that we have been saved by the death and resurrection of Christ?

Does 2 Cor 5:1-5 not speak of the very same thing? The flesh body of the earthly house of tabernacle being dissolved compared to the incorruptible house from heaven along with the Spirit of adoption V 5 ?
 

percho

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
No. I am not saying that Adam had the desires of a sin nature because he was made of dirt.

I am saying that Adam was made a living being, made flesh, and had the dedires of the flesh.

Here is the process by which sin occurres-

1. Every man is tempted, when he is drawn away of his own lust, and enticed. Adam was tempted to disobey God (either by the fruit itself, by Eve, or perhaps both).

2. When lust has conceived, it brings forth sin

3. Sin, when it is finished, brings forth death.

It has nothing to do with dirt.
Amen brother.

Sin, when it is finished, brings forth death

Also a interesting rabbit trail also from 2 Cor 5

V 21 for him who did not know sin, in our behalf He did make sin, that we may become the righteousness of God in him.

When Christ was made to be sin, did he say My God My God why hast thou forsaken me, It is finished, I thirst, Father into your hands I commit my spirit and then breath out his spirit life, Dying he did die?
 

Ben1445

Well-Known Member
That post did not say Adam sinned because he was made of dirt. It says because he was made fleshly out of the dust of the ground he was sold under sin. Sold for the purpose of being redeemed from sin and death.
Tell me it’s the dirt while telling me it’s not…

This makes no sense to me.

So God sold Adam into the slavery of sin by making him a body of flesh?

Jesus had a body of flesh and didn’t sin.
 

Van

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Romans 7:9 is a difficult verse, with many commentaries differing as to its intended meaning.

Paul did not directly say he only thought he was alive, but that is indicated by the context. Until the law brought awareness of his sinful coveting, he would naturally believe he was alive. And this awareness that he was actually spiritually dead, opened the door to seeking spiritual life in Christ. The OT scriptures serve as our tutor to lead us to Christ by making us aware of our need for Christ.

Yes, Paul does not explicitly say what I and others have derived from the context, but in my opinion, it is the only solution that fits with all scripture.

Note that Paul says we were "made sinners" which means we were conceived in a sinful state, separated from God as all sinners are. John says we were condemned already because of our "unbelief," and therefore only after our faith was credited as righteousness, were made righteous in Christ, no longer condemned. The word for that is "saved."
 

Van

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Jesus was sinless on the cross, thus He was treated as sin, but was not sin. Anyone who claims Jesus was not the sinless sacrifice that offset the penalty of sin, is pushing another gospel.
 

JonC

Moderator
Moderator
Amen brother.

Sin, when it is finished, brings forth death

Also a interesting rabbit trail also from 2 Cor 5

V 21 for him who did not know sin, in our behalf He did make sin, that we may become the righteousness of God in him.

When Christ was made to be sin, did he say My God My God why hast thou forsaken me, It is finished, I thirst, Father into your hands I commit my spirit and then breath out his spirit life, Dying he did die?
Jesus died the "first death" (physical death) on the cross (death of the flesh). Afterwards there was the judgment and He was glorified with the glory He held before Creation with the Father, given a name above every names, seated at the right hand of the Father, became a life giving Spirit, our High Priest, the Firstborn of many to come.

That is our hope and faith. It is appointed man once to die and then the Judgment. In Him we are called, predestined, justified and glorified. For us death (physical death) has no sting. Although we die yet shall we live.

Our salvation is based on the work of Christ, on Christ suffering the wages of sin (physical death produced by sin) and being judged righteous.
 

JonC

Moderator
Moderator
Tell me it’s the dirt while telling me it’s not…

This makes no sense to me.

So God sold Adam into the slavery of sin by making him a body of flesh?

Jesus had a body of flesh and didn’t sin.
I do not understand your logic here.

Adam was made of the dirt (dust) of the ground. He was made flesh.

But his sin was not because of dirt. It was because he was drawn away by the lusts of the flesh, lust conceived, brought forth sin which brings forth death.

God did not sell Adam into the bondage of sin. Adam sold himself. He allowed himself to be drawn away by the lusts of the flesh. He allowed lust to conceive, to bring forth sin and sin begats death.

And yes, the Word became flesh. Jesus was tempted in all points as is common to man. And He did not sin. Jesus did not allow Himself to be drawn away by the lusts of the flesh, did not allow lust to conceive, even though He was tempted in all points as is common to man.

What does dirt have to do with this?
 

Ben1445

Well-Known Member
I do not understand your logic here.
Read the quote that I am replying to.
Adam was made of the dirt (dust) of the ground. He was made flesh.
And there are some people who keep saying that is why Adam sinned. I don’t keep addressing this because of what you have said. I am answering someone else.

But his sin was not because of dirt. It was because he was drawn away by the lusts of the flesh, lust conceived, brought forth sin which brings forth death.

God did not sell Adam into the bondage of sin. Adam sold himself. He allowed himself to be drawn away by the lusts of the flesh. He allowed lust to conceive, to bring forth sin and sin begats death.
But that is not what @percho believes.

And yes, the Word became flesh. Jesus was tempted in all points as is common to man. And He did not sin. Jesus did not allow Himself to be drawn away by the lusts of the flesh, did not allow lust to conceive, even though He was tempted in all points as is common to man.

What does dirt have to do with this?
Well, in the logic of @percho in his posts, it isn’t the dirt, it is the dust.

That isn’t a satisfactory answer for me. So I keep asking questions to percho to try to make sense of what he is trying to say. There is a determinist aspect in that percho seems to be saying that God intended to make Adam a sinner, so He made him out of, not dirt, but dust.

That post did not say Adam sinned because he was made of dirt. It says because he was made fleshly out of the dust of the ground he was sold under sin.
I know already that my emphasis is not going to be acceptable to the poster, but it makes no difference. Could Adam have been made flesh out of something else? Could Adam have been made out of the dust and not be made flesh? Percho seems to think as if it’s the word flesh that makes the sinner out of dust. But the word flesh is just an indication of life made from dust. They are inseparable.
Animals are made of flesh. They are not considered sinners.

This idea that man sins because he is made of flesh doesn’t explain why angels sin. Do they sin because they are spirit?

What about the angels that didn’t sin? Are they more spirit or less spirit than the angels who did sin?

Note*
Specifically I am talking about the fall. I’m not talking about the flesh of sinful men.
Adam was made flesh and was at one point not a sinner.
 

JonC

Moderator
Moderator
Read the quote that I am replying to.

And there are some people who keep saying that is why Adam sinned. I don’t keep addressing this because of what you have said. I am answering someone else.


But that is not what @percho believes.


Well, in the logic of @percho in his posts, it isn’t the dirt, it is the dust.

That isn’t a satisfactory answer for me. So I keep asking questions to percho to try to make sense of what he is trying to say. There is a determinist aspect in that percho seems to be saying that God intended to make Adam a sinner, so He made him out of, not dirt, but dust.


I know already that my emphasis is not going to be acceptable to the poster, but it makes no difference. Could Adam have been made flesh out of something else? Could Adam have been made out of the dust and not be made flesh? Percho seems to think as if it’s the word flesh that makes the sinner out of dust. But the word flesh is just an indication of life made from dust. They are inseparable.
Animals are made of flesh. They are not considered sinners.

This idea that man sins because he is made of flesh doesn’t explain why angels sin. Do they sin because they are spirit?

What about the angels that didn’t sin? Are they more spirit or less spirit than the angels who did sin?

Note*
Specifically I am talking about the fall. I’m not talking about the flesh of sinful men.
Adam was made flesh and was at one point not a sinner.
Maybe it would have been better put that I do not understand the logic of attributing the desires of the flesh to dirt.

I do not understand what dirt has to do with Adam allowing himself to be drawn away by the lusts of the flesh.

Am I missing something? Are you guys using "dirt" to mean something other than literally dirt?
 

Ben1445

Well-Known Member
Maybe it would have been better put that I do not understand the logic of attributing the desires of the flesh to dirt.

I do not understand what dirt has to do with Adam allowing himself to be drawn away by the lusts of the flesh.

Am I missing something? Are you guys using "dirt" to mean something other than literally dirt?
I’m not. Dirt, dust, it’s all the same to me. That is why it is a confusing teaching. That is why I challenged it.
 

percho

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Tell me it’s the dirt while telling me it’s not…

This makes no sense to me.

So God sold Adam into the slavery of sin by making him a body of flesh?

Jesus had a body of flesh and didn’t sin.
Read the quote that I am replying to.

And there are some people who keep saying that is why Adam sinned. I don’t keep addressing this because of what you have said. I am answering someone else.


But that is not what @percho believes.


Well, in the logic of @percho in his posts, it isn’t the dirt, it is the dust.

That isn’t a satisfactory answer for me. So I keep asking questions to percho to try to make sense of what he is trying to say. There is a determinist aspect in that percho seems to be saying that God intended to make Adam a sinner, so He made him out of, not dirt, but dust.


I know already that my emphasis is not going to be acceptable to the poster, but it makes no difference. Could Adam have been made flesh out of something else? Could Adam have been made out of the dust and not be made flesh? Percho seems to think as if it’s the word flesh that makes the sinner out of dust. But the word flesh is just an indication of life made from dust. They are inseparable.
Animals are made of flesh. They are not considered sinners.

This idea that man sins because he is made of flesh doesn’t explain why angels sin. Do they sin because they are spirit?

What about the angels that didn’t sin? Are they more spirit or less spirit than the angels who did sin?

Note*
Specifically I am talking about the fall. I’m not talking about the flesh of sinful men.
Adam was made flesh and was at one point not a sinner.
I agree I have confused the issue. I can see your point. My point is I believe Adam was made a little lower than the angels for the same reason Jesus was made a little lower than the angels. Because of the suffering of the death. The death brought forth by the sin of Adam. Death that comes to one of the flesh that does not have access to the tree of life.

The living soul of flesh and blood is mortal and corruptible and must be changed, to immortal and incorruptible, to inherit the kingdom of God.
Born from above. I believe that is the teaching of John 3.

God told Adam;

and of the tree of knowledge of good and evil, thou dost not eat of it, for in the day of thine eating of it -- dying thou dost die.'

What was that? What did it mean to Adam?

Heb 2:14 Seeing, then, the children have partaken of flesh and blood, he himself also in like manner did take part of the same, that through [the] death he might destroy him having the power of [the] death -- that is, the devil --

{the], I put that there because it is in the Greek. What death? When God told Adam to not eat of it, was the devil have the power of the death at that time?

Did Adam, "fall,' or is God setting up the devil and his works to be destroyed? Consider
he who is doing the sin, of the devil he is, because from the beginning the devil doth sin; for this was the Son of God manifested, that he may break up the works of the devil; 1 John 3:8
Seeing, then, the children have partaken of flesh and blood, he himself also in like manner did take part of the same, that through [the] death he might destroy him having the power of [the] death -- that is, the devil --

What about Adam?
 

Ben1445

Well-Known Member
I agree I have confused the issue. I can see your point. My point is I believe Adam was made a little lower than the angels for the same reason Jesus was made a little lower than the angels. Because of the suffering of the death. The death brought forth by the sin of Adam. Death that comes to one of the flesh that does not have access to the tree of life.

The living soul of flesh and blood is mortal and corruptible and must be changed, to immortal and incorruptible, to inherit the kingdom of God.
Born from above. I believe that is the teaching of John 3.

God told Adam;

and of the tree of knowledge of good and evil, thou dost not eat of it, for in the day of thine eating of it -- dying thou dost die.'

What was that? What did it mean to Adam?

Heb 2:14 Seeing, then, the children have partaken of flesh and blood, he himself also in like manner did take part of the same, that through [the] death he might destroy him having the power of [the] death -- that is, the devil --

{the], I put that there because it is in the Greek. What death? When God told Adam to not eat of it, was the devil have the power of the death at that time?

Did Adam, "fall,' or is God setting up the devil and his works to be destroyed? Consider
he who is doing the sin, of the devil he is, because from the beginning the devil doth sin; for this was the Son of God manifested, that he may break up the works of the devil; 1 John 3:8
Seeing, then, the children have partaken of flesh and blood, he himself also in like manner did take part of the same, that through [the] death he might destroy him having the power of [the] death -- that is, the devil --

What about Adam?


What God told Adam was that he would not die until he ate the fruit and disobeyed. I can see the point you are getting at. I don’t necessarily agree that that is the only purpose of the creation of man. God could have rightfully judged Satan at any time He wished as soon as Satan sinned.

Why God has chosen to handle it the way He has, I cannot tell any more than what is given in Scripture.
Having promised to handle it in the way that Scripture declares, it will not be done any other way.
 

percho

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
What God told Adam was that he would not die until he ate the fruit and disobeyed. I can see the point you are getting at. I don’t necessarily agree that that is the only purpose of the creation of man. God could have rightfully judged Satan at any time He wished as soon as Satan sinned.

Why God has chosen to handle it the way He has, I cannot tell any more than what is given in Scripture.
Having promised to handle it in the way that Scripture declares, it will not be done any other way.
Thanks for your response.
 
Top