• Welcome to Baptist Board, a friendly forum to discuss the Baptist Faith in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to all the features that our community has to offer.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

The Value of Books

Status
Not open for further replies.

Reynolds

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Recently there was a thread where it was (falsely) claimed that I discourage literacy (that I believe reading Christian books are bad).

This comes from my statement that God gives us teachers, but these are men who interact with the congregations to whom they are given. God gifted men and women to assume many roles within the church.

I had also said that Scripture, not books written by men expounding on Scripture, is the authority of our faith. Christians need to first study God's Word and when mature enough to read the opinions of others be very careful not to be indoctrinated but to work out their own faith (don't steal the beliefs of another but hold your own).

This is what I get in reply:
We all know you want to burn down all the libraries. Might as well not try to deny it
 

JonC

Moderator
Moderator
He only thinks his posts are readable. Sinclair Ferguson is respected worldwide and has helped many.
JonC probably has not read anything by him yet he "knows" should not be viewed by Baptists.
This is childish.

I read Joel Berk, John Owen's, Tim Keller, John Macarthur, David Wells, etc.

But I will NEVER declare that a Christian who has not is deficient.

Our sufficiency is Christ and the measure of our faith is God,'s Word.

That is where you and your gang go. And you are wrong.
 

JonC

Moderator
Moderator
I would say with some brethren its an acquired taste... Someone recommended I read Freedom Of The Will by Jonathan Edwards, so I found it in pdf and started reading and half way thru it, I still didn't get, so I stopped reading it... How many on here read Spurgeon?... Kind of like Owens but again its an acquired taste... I like Pink and have many of his books but do I always agree with him... NO!... The one I recommend that every Baptist should read is Pilgrims Progress... I've read Josephus, Edersheim, Irenaeus, Gadsby, Philpot, Bunyan and a slew of other old theologians and ancient writers... And like deacon I like to step away and read other things... Take a breather so to speak... And right now at the age of 76 you will not believe what I am reading?... The Chronicles Of Narnia by C.S. Lewis... All because a good preacher friend of mine recommended that I do... I did not know that C.S. Lewis and Tolkien were friends... Loved Lord Of the Rings, both the books and the movie... Well I'm off to continue the adventure and Icon's an acquired taste too but sometimes he's on vacation... Brother Glen:)
I love how Spurgeon applied Scripture. Read "Choice Portions" if you get a chance (that's one of my favorite sermons).

If you don't like it then....well....you may not be a Baptist :Tongue .
 

Iconoclast

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
This is childish.

I read Joel Berk, John Owen's, Tim Keller, John Macarthur, David Wells, etc.

But I will NEVER declare that a Christian who has not is deficient.

Our sufficiency is Christ and the measure of our faith is God,'s Word.

That is where you and your gang go. And you are wrong.
Do not twist my words.
I do not like the slimy way you do that.
I do not think I should have to go back and show how you twist it.
I said something along the line of a if a Baptist was not willing to read and learn from men like Owen or Ferguson it is defective.
It is not mandatory but to say they are not God given teachers has been shown to be an absurdity.
 

canadyjd

Well-Known Member
If your theology is determined by people that you listen to or the books that you read rather than the bible then you should be questioning the foundation of your theology.
And yet, reading the Bible on your own has led you to believe “many people are saved never having heard the gospel”. An egregious error.

You read what others have written and compare it to scripture. Many of these folks have been gifted by God with wise discernment of scripture.

The great value of books is you don’t have to work out the same errors in every generation. Throughout history, we see the same errors over and over concerning, primarily, the person and work of Jesus.

All those claiming reformed believers just follow the teachings of men and not the Bible are simply ignorant of the truth.

In my experience, reformed believers are the most committed to understanding scripture in context.

That is readily seen on this board where many posting in this thread make outrageous accusations against reformed believers and rarely engage in serious discussions of scripture.

peace to you
 

JonC

Moderator
Moderator
Do not twist my words.
I do not like the slimy way you do that.
I do not think I should have to go back and show how you twist it.
I said something along the line of a if a Baptist was not willing to read and learn from men like Owen or Ferguson it is defective.
It is not mandatory but to say they are not God given teachers has been shown to be an absurdity.
This is a false accusation. I said that John Owen's, John John Wesley, Dwight Moody, etc were given by God as teachers.

This is what you said, and then what you defended:

If a Baptist does not read books by Owen or in our day Sinclair Ferguson, It shows defective thinking.

I appreciate you trying to back track, it was a false teaching you posted. But don't pretend I twisted it or changed it.

***. Members - This is why I use the quote feature. You can simply click on the arrow in the quote box and it will take you to the original post.
 

Iconoclast

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
And yet, reading the Bible on your own has led you to believe “many people are saved never having heard the gospel”. An egregious error.

You read what others have written and compare it to scripture. Many of these folks have been gifted by God with wise discernment of scripture.

The great value of books is you don’t have to work out the same errors in every generation. Throughout history, we see the same errors over and over concerning, primarily, the person and work of Jesus.

All those claiming reformed believers just follow the teachings of men and not the Bible are simply ignorant of the truth.

In my experience, reformed believers are the most committed to understanding scripture in context.

That is readily seen on this board where many posting in this thread make outrageous accusations against reformed believers and rarely engage in serious discussions of scripture.

peace to you
Some want to rewrite history.
Reformed teaching is alive and well.
There are people called holocaust deniers who say it never happened.
Some deny Spurgeon was a Calvinist or that non Baptist theologians should not be read.
 

Iconoclast

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
This is a false accusation. I said that John Owen's, John John Wesley, Dwight Moody, etc were given by God as teachers.

This is what you said, and then what you defended:



I appreciate you trying to back track, it was a false teaching you posted. But don't pretend I twisted it or changed it.

***. Members - This is why I use the quote feature. You can simply click on the arrow in the quote box and it will take you to the original post.
You denied they were useful you said they were only for their people in there time.
You have denied they were God given teachers.
Clarify for us....
Does God give teachers at all. I said He did quoting Eph4.
 

JonC

Moderator
Moderator
You denied they were useful you said they were only for their people in there time.
You have denied they were God given teachers.
Clarify for us....
Does God give teachers at all. I said He did quoting Eph4.
I never denied they were useful! I even said I found Owen's very useful.

What do you do...just sit around trying to falsely accuse the breathen??!!!!

Dude....I am human with enough flaws you don't need to go to the trouble to invent false accusations to insult me.

And yes, God equips the church with pastors and teachers.

No, God did not give you those teachers (all you have are their writings).

Yes, Christians can learn from John Owen, Karl Barth, C.S. Lewis and John Wesley.

No, Christians are not defficient if they have not read those men's writings.
 

Martin Marprelate

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Christians should read as much as they are able. 'In the multitude of counsellors there is safety.'
Reading older books is very valuable (cf. Jeremiah 6:16). John Owen is hard reading, but there are some excellent abridgments. To me he is, along with Jonathan Edwards, the greatest of all theologians. But of course, all Christian books have to be measured against the plumb line of the Bible.

Banner of Truth has published some of Owen's later sermons in their 'Puritan Paperback' series as Searching our hearts in difficult times. We have such times upon us right now and Owen's insights are as up-to-date as tomorrows newspapers with a lot more truth in them. The book was very reasonably priced and of such importance that I bought a copy for each of our church officers.
 

JonC

Moderator
Moderator
Christians should read as much as they are able. 'In the multitude of counsellors there is safety.'
Reading older books is very valuable (cf. Jeremiah 6:16). John Owen is hard reading, but there are some excellent abridgments. To me he is, along with Jonathan Edwards, the greatest of all theologians. But of course, all Christian books have to be measured against the plumb line of the Bible.

Banner of Truth has published some of Owen's later sermons in their 'Puritan Paperback' series as Searching our hearts in difficult times. We have such times upon us right now and Owen's insights are as up-to-date as tomorrows newspapers with a lot more truth in them. The book was very reasonably priced and of such importance that I bought a copy for each of our church officers.
Counselors. Teachers. NOT claiming Christians who have not read certain authors are deficient in thinking!

You should know better, Martin.

Ironically we have read much of the same writings.
 

Iconoclast

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Counselors. Teachers. NOT claiming Christians who have not read certain authors are deficient in thinking!

You should know better, Martin.

Ironically we have read much of the same writings.
No...a baptist not willing to read a non-baptist author.
 
Last edited:

Iconoclast

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Christi
ans should read as much as they are able. 'In the multitude of counsellors there is safety.'
Reading older books is very valuable (cf. Jeremiah 6:16). John Owen is hard reading, but there are some excellent abridgments. To me he is, along with Jonathan Edwards, the greatest of all theologians. But of course, all Christian books have to be measured against the plumb line of the Bible.

Banner of Truth has published some of Owen's later sermons in their 'Puritan Paperback' series as Searching our hearts in difficult times. We have such times upon us right now and Owen's insights are as up-to-date as tomorrows newspapers with a lot more truth in them. The book was very reasonably priced and of such importance that I bought a copy for each of our church officers.
Every respected Bible teacher advocates a healthy diet of reading teachers and theologians from the past to supplement our Bible reading.
Never saw any respected theologian to compare them to reading the book of Mormon.
 

JonC

Moderator
Moderator
No...a baptist not willing to read a non-baptist author.
Just because a Baptist is unwilling to read non-Baptist authors does not mean he or she has a deficiency.


Let me ask you - God gave Harold Bender as a teacher. What do you think of his books. Have you read enough of them so you are not defficient in your thinking?

What about John Wesley? God gave him as a teacher. Have you read his books?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top