Actually, that's exactly what MacArthur says is required in LS.
Site it. Where does Mac Arthur say promises have to be made ot be saved. I listen to MacArthur quite regularly. I ahve never heard him say such a silly thing.
How does one "surrender your life, your all" prior to faith in Chrsit? How can one promise to be a disciple without knowing what is required of a disciple?
What does this question have to do with anything?
I'm opposed to Lordship Salvation, but I CAN sing that song, as I have been regenerated, justified and can NOW understand what being a disciple consists of and having this new Spirit within CAN surrender totally.
"take me Jesus, take me now"???
Actually, in your view you better not sing it, as every time you sin you are not surrendering your all to Him, are you! Each sin you commit you surrender to your flesh and not what God desires. If you think this out to it's conclusion, unless you have sinless perfection, you are not saved under LS!
Now this is actually fair. Kudos. It does seem that way. However, Lordship is about acknowledgment and surrendering one's self to the fact it.
If a foreign power conquers these United States and I surrender myself to the new Kingdom, I am not committing myself to keep every new law perfectly. I am acknowledging the right of the new power to rule and surrendering myself to that power.
I may break the speed limit. I may murder someone. But as long as I recognize the power and allow that power to reign over me that power is Lord of me.
I remain a citizen until I deny that the power has the right to rule over me.
Before I was saved I denied the right of Jesus to reign in my life. When I was saved I recognized it and yielded my heart to it. Since then I have broken plenty of his laws, but that he is Lord and ruler of me, there is no doubt.