Is the tithe for today?

And Tomatoes, if we have any...

 

Yep. So did a lot of other things.
And I am 98% certain, having discussed this so many times before, that you are leading up to Abraham's tithes to Melchizadek, the priest in Salem; so I will take the liberty of a short cut instead of having you bring it up.

1) Circumcision also was begun by Abraham to the males in his fold. In the NT, especially seen in Galatians, it means nothing to Christians of the New Covenant.
2) If this indeed does concern Abe and his tithes to Mel, to show that 'tithing' preceded the Law and is therefore under Grace, then everything involved here is under Grace. Or do you think there would be nothing wrong with attacking a region, killing as many people as you can and taking the spoils-- as long you give a tenth to the local priest?
3) There is considerable irony in quoting Malachi 3-- as is so common in lessons or sermons about tithing/giving-- and then shifting to the NT and "...give not under compulsion but love," and "...the Lord loves a cheerful giver." What is claimed here?-- that God will withhold blessings if we don't (at least) a tithe-- compulsion-- or if that message actually affects someone to the extent they do sense such compulsion that love and cheer are absent therefrom? Few topics intermingle Law and Grace more than this one. Nevertheless, the position often taken is "if they won't give cheerfully, then compulsion is better than nothing; the money spends the same."

These are all the answers I will use for now on this.

 

Alcott, I have made the point in the following way, which might be useful for some.

Tithing[1] existed before the Law,[2] in the law,[3] is mentioned in the New Testament,[4] and neither Jesus nor the New Testament writers ever negate it.

Levirate marriage[5] existed before the Law,[6] in the law,[7] is mentioned in the New Testament,[8] and neither Jesus nor the New Testament writers ever negate it.

[1] Giving a tenth of one’s increase.
[2] Genesis 14:18-20
[3] Numbers 18:20-24
[4] Matthew 23:23
[5] Marriage in which the brother of a deceased man is obliged to marry his brother’s widow, when the deceased brother has no children.
[6] Genesis 38:1-30
[7] Deuteronomy 25:5-10
[8] Matthew 22:23-33

 

So what did the tithe foreshadow?

 

"Foreshadow?" Nothing.

 

Then why would it be done away with. If Christ's coming did not fulfill something about the tithe then what makes anyone think it is done.

 

In the same way, what did the 'unfaithful wife' test foreshadow?o

 

I don't get this. How did it foreshadow the NC? In what way are they similar?

 

Sir, could you provide verses that show that time, treasure (e.g. money), talent, and testimony have anything to do with a "tithe" specifically?

Thanks

 

Tomatoes are actually the only Scripturally based example thus far.

 

I figured with the "T" list going, I'd add a scriptural T

 

John - here's a thought: How about we discuss whether the tithe is for today, and what scripture says about it, instead of talking about YOU, and opening it up for criticism of you? Unless that's what you want.

 

If you simply read all the passages in the Bible that mention "tithes" from Genesis 14 to Hebrews 7, you inescapably realize that tithing specifically has nothing to do with the ministry of the gospel in the New Covenant for the church, and that what is taught as "tithing" today--namely, monetary income or wages--has absolutely nothing whatsoever to do with real tithing in the Bible.

 

Interesting concept. Do you keep a time-sheet?