Excellent post Protestant, you have a very clear insight into the issue. One thing that strikes me as the other side forgetting is that Scripture does not contradict Scripture. The salvation of Paul and Christ's prayer to the Father the night before He was crucified should make it clear to anyone, ie "keeping all those You have given Me...." I think several times the free will side was asked for their definition of elect or election. From the posts, I would say a very good definition is to them, election is voting for yourself. The question has also been asked, and these are all straw man questions, is how does a person who believes in sovereignty know that he or she is elected? It is called the Holy Spirit. Another point they fail to address is, if you have the ability to choose within yourself the point of salvation, how come you cannot choose to abandon it?
One thing that really irked me, and I did several posts on this, is the outrageous claim that Calvinists are all hyper Calvinists, that is, they don't believe in missions, and that we believe in predestined for hell. That shows a total lack of understanding. People go to hell because they die in their sins without Jesus Christ, not because they were predestined to go there. Again, another straw man, but this one borders on lets say grievous error to be nice.
As far as their John 3:16 argument ad nauseam, whosoever is not going to believe unless given the ability to.
At the fall, man was not left with a half perfect and half sinful nature. What does Romans 3:10 say? How can one read Romans 1 and find one bit of evidence that saving faith exists in a flawed, sinful human being?
Protestant I have no idea what you do for a living, but it amazes me if you are something other than a called leader of the Christian faith, you can run theological circles around someone who does this stuff for a living and has been to seminary. You have successfully shown solid theology in your posts and exposed the others as a theory built on smoke and mirrors.
To God be the glory that you have been blessed to ‘see behind the scenes.'
For that is what the mystery of our Election is all about: a 'behind the scenes' look at how we were saved.
My background is the Hollywood Entertainment Industry (TV and music). I'm now retired.
As such I thoroughly enjoy viewing documentaries which give a ‘behind the scenes' look at how a feature film was made.
The Making of Jaws was great fun to see how, exactly, they put that masterpiece together. Netflix has a multi-document series on the Beatles with much footage of them in the recording studio. I love watching the creative process. It’s the next best thing for me, if I can’t be the one creating.
Our non-Cal friends find it hard to distinguish between the preaching of the Gospel and the ‘behind the scenes' look at salvation concerning which our Lord desires we Christians rightly understand.
But to rightly understand the 'behind the scenes' view of Election one must begin from God's perspective.
To do that one must rightly understand God.
Our duty is to preach Christ crucified. We know that if any are saved, it is not due to our oratory skills (as was exemplified by Paul’s honest admission), but rather due to God’s Spirit working faith in the newly regenerated heart of the sinner.
It is those whom God has loved with an everlasting love.
It is those for whom Christ prays.
It is those whom the Lord will not lose, not one.
The truths held by the doctrines of grace run counter to the natural mind.
But with diligent study and the grace of God in the Holy Spirit all Christians should at least be able to grasp the fact that their reconciliation with our holy and righteous God, whereby they are accepted in the Beloved, is an incomprehensible miracle of grace…..considering we had nothing whatsoever to offer God or deserve His favor.
Thank you so much for your kind and encouraging words.
I am a nobody who loves the Lord and His Word.
He set me free. I owe Him everything.
It is hard for me to ‘stand still’ in silence when both the honor, grace and truth of our Lord is stained.
I also understand that our non-Cal friends are very sincere and quite zealous.
I pray that they would continue to seek the Lord to discover what is so great a salvation they really have.
Blessings in Christ, my friend.
PS I also pray God's infinite grace for Tom Butler and family.