El Guero,
I agree with you. Id forgotten why I hadn't joined this site earlier. So many times the conservatives among us are the ones here that are looked down on and ridiculed.
Now, Elnora was earlier wondering if anyone had an intelligent response to EricB?
Let's get to what music really is, and the study of it will show you (hopefully, if you are willing to take it to heart), that there are unGodly forms of music just as there are Godly forms.
First of all, strictly looking at music....forgetting lyrics for now......there are three basic parts to music.
Melody
Harmony
Rhythm
All three are a valid part of music. Our God is a balanced God....."Let all things be done decently and in order", He is not the author of chaos, etc.....
So, let's agree that God would want balance and order in His music, as well. Anything, when out of balance or out of the natural order that GOD has ordained, has thus been perverted by the world and no longer qualifies as godly. This would then apply to music as well.
Ok, music speaks to us as human beings, on levels that not all of us understand, and no one understands completely. Howver, basically the Melody speaks to our spirit, the Harmony speaks to our soul(emotions, intellect, will) the Rhythm speaks to our body(the flesh)
It is not Godly to totally deny the body and all physical things, correct? Is there a music that does this?
Yes.
There is a music that is ALL Harmony. Basically no melody and absolutely no rhythm. It has no direction, no body to it, very ethereal. Out of balance. This is the music that the New Agers have made so popular. Emotion leads this music, and God tells us that our emotions are not supposed to lead us. While emotions are important they should not be first.
Now, is there a music that is ALL Rhythm?
Yes, that would be rap....the "music" that is being discussed here. It is ALL body, no melody and no harmony at all. It puts the body first, and the Bible tells us that we are to put our bodies into subjection. The body is not supposed to be leading us (carnal Christianity has this problem, we all have a problem in this area.) While the body is important it is not supposed to be first, not even second, it is to be last in line.
Lastly, there is music that is melody led. It speaks to our spirit, the part of us that is supposed to be in charge, under the control of the Holy Spirit.
When judging music, each individual song, we should keep these things in mind. There are variations of unbalance, but the spirit should always be in control, the emotions providing color and "harmony" to our life, and our body in subjection but providing an underlying support system that is used for good.
You can get into lyrics after all this is in balance. Lyrics can take an in-balance tune and turn it into an unGodly venture. BUT, lyrics are really secondary. They canNOT take and OUT OF BALANCE song and turn it into a GODLY song. You canNOT have one thing balanced and the other UNbalanced and still have it be pleasing to God. This would apply in all areas of our life.
I can't say that Im living a Godly life if I cuss and drink and do drugs while Im at home, but I still go to church on the weekends. "Hey, I go to church!" is not going to excuse the parts of my life that are wrong.
In the same way, if a tune (song) has good lyrics but it speaks solely to the body and ignores all the other parts than itis out of balance and is not pleasing to God.