• Welcome to Baptist Board, a friendly forum to discuss the Baptist Faith in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to all the features that our community has to offer.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

Do You regard Doctrine of Gifts Continuing/Ceasing as being "essential?"

Status
Not open for further replies.

preacher4truth

Active Member
:confused:

Acts 5:12-16
And by the hands of the apostles were many signs and wonders wrought among the people; (and they were all with one accord in Solomon's porch. And of the rest durst no man join himself to them: but the people magnified them. And believers were the more added to the Lord, multitudes both of men and women.) Insomuch that they brought forth the sick into the streets, and laid them on beds and couches, that at the least the shadow of Peter passing by might overshadow some of them. There came also a multitude out of the cities round about unto Jerusalem, bringing sick folks, and them which were vexed with unclean spirits: and they were healed every one.

This is the apostles, which won't happen today. Nor is it the gift in operation among the members of a NT local body. No need for you to be confused.
 

preacher4truth

Active Member
There came also a multitude out of the cities round about unto Jerusalem, bringing sick folks, and them which were vexed with unclean spirits: and they were healed every one. (Acts 5:16)
--Jesus never turned anyone away.
The Apostles never turned anyone away.
That doesn't happen today! Why? The gift of healing has ceased!

You've failed to properly apply, contextualize, and understand this passage in relation to this thread. There are no apostles today, we're talking gift within the local body since Acts. There is in that context no need to require that ALL be healed in a hospital to prove it true. (although I don't believe this gift is in operation today).
 

DHK

<b>Moderator</b>
You've failed to properly apply, contextualize, and understand this passage in relation to this thread. There are no apostles today, we're talking gift within the local body since Acts. There is in that context no need to require that ALL be healed in a hospital to prove it true. (although I don't believe this gift is in operation today).
These "signs and wonders" and sign gifts were given to the apostles specifically. They authenticated them and their message. The apostles died by the end of the first century, and the gifts of the spirit ceased at the same time. You cannot find the same thing being done today. It has ceased. There is not gift of healing going on today.
 

preacher4truth

Active Member
These "signs and wonders" and sign gifts were given to the apostles specifically. They authenticated them and their message. The apostles died by the end of the first century, and the gifts of the spirit ceased at the same time. You cannot find the same thing being done today. It has ceased. There is not gift of healing going on today.

The gift of healing wasn't only to the apostles specifically, so you are again deficient in your explanation. Paul wouldn't have written 1 Corinthians 12:9, 30 &c to a local body describing their gifts as members thereof who were not themselves apostles.
 

Earth Wind and Fire

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
The gift of healing wasn't only to the apostles specifically, so you are again deficient in your explanation. Paul wouldn't have written 1 Corinthians 12:9, 30 &c to a local body describing their gifts as members thereof who were not themselves apostles.

Yea Preach but your talking to "Mr Show Me".....Makes you feel like your in Missouri .... oppsey......my bad:laugh::p:thumbs:
 

DHK

<b>Moderator</b>
The gift of healing wasn't only to the apostles specifically, so you are again deficient in your explanation. Paul wouldn't have written 1 Corinthians 12:9, 30 &c to a local body describing their gifts as members thereof who were not themselves apostles.
Here is context:

How shall we escape, if we neglect so great salvation; which at the first began to be spoken by the Lord, and was confirmed unto us by them that heard him; God also bearing them witness, both with signs and wonders, and with divers miracles, and gifts of the Holy Ghost, according to his own will? (Hebrews 2:3-4)
--They were given primarily to the apostles for authentication.

Furthermore, if they were for today we would see them in operation today. But we don't. Give the evidence. Where is the gift of healing in operation today? Where is your proof?
Or is it you that believes in "name it; claim it" with no evidence.
 

preacher4truth

Active Member
Here is context:

How shall we escape, if we neglect so great salvation; which at the first began to be spoken by the Lord, and was confirmed unto us by them that heard him; God also bearing them witness, both with signs and wonders, and with divers miracles, and gifts of the Holy Ghost, according to his own will? (Hebrews 2:3-4)
--They were given primarily to the apostles for authentication.

Furthermore, if they were for today we would see them in operation today. But we don't. Give the evidence. Where is the gift of healing in operation today? Where is your proof?
Or is it you that believes in "name it; claim it" with no evidence.

Nice way to bypass the passage I gave you proving the gifts weren't only to the apostles. You're incorrect as I've shown you.

No need to continue the path of "is the gift in operation today", and beg me for "proof" when I've already said I don't believe it is in effect. That's just you pretending there's an argument when there isn't one so you can avoid the proof I've given you, in that, you are incorrect stating the gifts were only Apostolic.

Stay on track, OK? It's not really that hard. I've shown you the gift wasn't only, nor was it specifically an Apostolic only gift. I know it's hard to admit that you're incorrect, and to admit you have been proven incorrect.

No need for your false trail for me to "prove" a gift in existence when I've concisely stated I don't believe it is.
 

Iconoclast

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
One more time, NONE that I am aware of in Charasmatic/pentacostal groups hold to "ongoing revelations" from the Lord, there are still Gifts operating, But NOT in abasis on ongoing revelation!

ONLY heretical groups like WoF, health and wealth etc are there erronous "revelations" and teachings, as they get it from AntiChrist spirit, not the HS!

So I guess the BAPTIST Systematic Theologian DR Wayne Grudem is NOT a real baptist, eh?

It looks as if you do not grasp the issue.....let me try this

If you believe you spoke in a tongue.....did it come directly from God?
or did it only come out of your mind?

Then you say in another post...we have to check it in the word???
if it is already in the word...we do not need a tongue to repeat it...we CAN READ THE WORD.

Wayne Grudem ....has seriously blundered on his ideas...and is almost universally rejected for this major error.....
This kind of error is serious enough that he is to be avoided....his systematic theology ....has other problems...I personally think it does more harm than good.....
All he did was piggy back on other systematic theologies...put them in modern english.....them ask questions in a compromising fashion...that can be harmful.
 

DHK

<b>Moderator</b>
Nice way to bypass the passage I gave you proving the gifts weren't only to the apostles. You're incorrect as I've shown you.
You are text proofing. There is no Scripture that says that gift of healing is for today. 1Cor.12-14 are three chapters written about spiritual gifts, mostly written about the misuse of the gifts by the Corinthian Church. Notice he doesn't write about these gifts to other churches. This is one of the first epistles written (ca. 55 A.D.). By the time the other epistles were written (8-12 years later) the gifts were already passing out of existence.
No need to continue the path of "is the gift in operation today", and beg me for "proof" when I've already said I don't believe it is in effect.
What are you talking about. Are you contradicting yourself or arguing for the sake of argument; being contentious for the sake of contentiousness. If so I should take this post to the administration. We have enough contention on this board then to deal with foolishness.
That's just you pretending there's an argument when there isn't one so you can avoid the proof I've given you, in that, you are incorrect stating the gifts were only Apostolic.
You haven't given any valid proof. The fact that I have ignored what you put forth, doesn't make it valid. Whatever gave you that idea?? :rolleyes:
Stay on track, OK? It's not really that hard. I've shown you the gift wasn't only, nor was it specifically an Apostolic only gift. I know it's hard to admit that you're incorrect, and to admit you have been proven incorrect.
It was primarily an apostolic gift which can be shown through Scripture, but not confined to the apostles.
No need for your false trail for me to "prove" a gift in existence when I've concisely stated I don't believe it is.
Yes there is a need. If the gift was in existence today, it would be prevalent today. No evidence of the gift today, then it is not operative today. Ergo--it has ceased as the Bible teaches; as history teaches; as our own current events of today teaches.

You don't have the evidence.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

righteousdude2

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
I Don't Believe in Doctrines, SO...

....I'd have to say, and this is merely my opinion, based on intellectual understandings and Scriptural interpretation (over the years), and personal experience; the gifts were meant to continue into, and through, the end of ages, or until He returns for the church!

This is why I consider myself to be non-denominational, with Baptist inclinations.

I've come to see doctrines as the mere spiritual hypothesis' of mans collective and intellectual understanding of Scriptures. And in all truth, the doctrines of any one particular denomination or faith doesn't necessarily impress me. Nor will it cause a change in my relationship with Jesus as Lord and Savior!

Don't get me wrong...while doctrines are the basic foundations upon which mainline religions are built upon. No one doctrine is necessarily more sound than another. There is always going to be room for error in all doctrines. To hitch y wagon to the one doctrinal interpretation, or another, or many, is going to be based on what best suits our way of belief and life!

Time has taught me well, and I have developed a faith built upon some very sound principles of many different doctrines, and I personally can't see where this way of believing is going to keep me from eternity any more than throwing everything I have into the box of one set doctrinal stand.

This is why I can clearly say, for me, the gifts were meant to go long beyond the time of the Apostles.

What I believe and what you believe is ONLY important if we choose to make it an issue and let it separate us from the fellowship we were meant to have with those who have given their life to Christ and been born-again!

It shouldn't matter if I'm a supporter of Peter, or Paul, or Timothy? The important question is: Do I follow Jesus? And the answer is, not only do I follow Him, I've given my life to Him, followed Him in water baptism, and dedicated myself to spreading the good news of His life, death and resurrection. Is there anything more??? :wavey:

Again, nothing that I said above will keep me from eternity. My name has been written in the Lamb's Book of life,right along side of yours. And that is really all that should matter to any of us in the end! :thumbs:

Shalom,

Pastor Paul :type:
 

preacher4truth

Active Member
You are text proofing. There is no Scripture that says that gift of healing is for today...You don't have the evidence.

Proof-texting? LOL!!!!! I gave you Scriptures proving the gifts weren't only apostolic. Deal with it, you're wrong again and its beginning to look like you're chronically wrong.

What a load of bunk, you're still pretending that I said the gift exists today, when I clearly said it doesn't, yet you still pretend you have a cause to fight after I clearly showed your view is deficient in understanding. And then to top that off you bring in your strawmen.

But you can't stick to the facts and truth here because when we do, well, you're clearly in error, so you keep pretending that you have an issue to argue about by pretending I've said something I haven't. I find this humorous behavior. :laugh:

Here is what you are doing basically and what is happening in essence: :laugh:

I said; "I don't believe the gifts exist today."

Then you :rolleyes: say; "Prove that the gifts exist today, you don't have the evidence."

Try staying on track and paying attention? Yes? No? (unless you still need to play "pretend"). :wavey:
 
Last edited by a moderator:

DHK

<b>Moderator</b>
....I'd have to say, and this is merely my opinion, based on intellectual understandings and Scriptural interpretation (over the years), and personal experience; the gifts were meant to continue into, and through, the end of ages, or until He returns for the church!
A careful study into the Word of God would reveal otherwise, particularly in 1Cor.13:8-13.
This is why I consider myself to be non-denominational, with Baptist inclinations.

I've come to see doctrines as the mere spiritual hypothesis' of mans collective and intellectual understanding of Scriptures. And in all truth, the doctrines of any one particular denomination or faith doesn't necessarily impress me. Nor will it cause a change in my relationship with Jesus as Lord and Savior!
As one man said: "Salvation (or the winning of souls) is not the most important thing in the Bible, obedience to God is." Put in that context all of God's doctrines become important to us. We are commanded to Study to show ourselves approved; to search the Scriptures; to be able to give to every man an answer; etc. Whether or not specific doctrines impress you is not important. They are important to the Lord. That is why God left His revelation in His book written for us. The more we know it, the more we know about our Lord, and the more we can draw closer to Him. We can only draw closer to the Lord as we find him through the Scriptures. There is a direct correlation between the study of the Scriptures and our relationship with Christ.
Don't get me wrong...while doctrines are the basic foundations upon which mainline religions are built upon. No one doctrine is necessarily more sound than another. There is always going to be room for error in all doctrines. To hitch y wagon to the one doctrinal interpretation, or another, or many, is going to be based on what best suits our way of belief and life!
Not necessarily so. This particular field of study is currently the devil's playground. The Charismatic movement is one of the fastest growing movements in our age today. It is infected with demon possession, and ungodly error where people have put their experiences as more important than the Word of God. Jesus said "Beware of the leaven of the Pharisees." In other words beware of the false teaching of the false teachers/false prophets. That exists in abundance today. Jude commanded us: "that we should contend for the faith." We must not only know what you believe, you must know why you believe what you know.
Time has taught me well, and I have developed a faith built upon some very sound principles of many different doctrines, and I personally can't see where this way of believing is going to keep me from eternity any more than throwing everything I have into the box of one set doctrinal stand.
There are many doctrines (such as the importance of baptism) that will not keep you from eternity. But does that make it any less important? Obedience to the will of God is the most important thing.
This is why I can clearly say, for me, the gifts were meant to go long beyond the time of the Apostles.
What reason? That they aren't important??
What I believe and what you believe is ONLY important if we choose to make it an issue and let it separate us from the fellowship we were meant to have with those who have given their life to Christ and been born-again!
Should I have fellowship with those that bark like dogs, hiss like snakes, etc., as well as those that believe that speaking in tongues is obligatory for being saved? It is a slippery slope? Where does it end. The AOG, one of the tamest of the groups believe that speaking in tongues is evidence of being baptized in the Spirit; that it is a subsequent blessing to salvation. They also believe that everyone should have it, and if they don't have it they should seek it. If you don't have it you are looked upon as someone who is "less spiritual." Do I fellowship with people that are so deeply in error?
Here is the Biblical teaching on that issue:

Now I beseech you, brethren, mark them which cause divisions and offences contrary to the doctrine which ye have learned; and avoid them. (Romans 16:17)
--Tongues is a divisive issue.
It shouldn't matter if I'm a supporter of Peter, or Paul, or Timothy? The important question is: Do I follow Jesus? And the answer is, not only do I follow Him, I've given my life to Him, followed Him in water baptism, and dedicated myself to spreading the good news of His life, death and resurrection. Is there anything more???
There is much more. There is the matter of fellowship with those who hold to Biblical error; serious Biblical error.
Again, nothing that I said above will keep me from eternity. My name has been written in the Lamb's Book of life,right along side of yours. And that is really all that should matter to any of us in the end!
Baptism won't keep you from eternity either. But I believe it is important, as is the Lord's Supper. Why are they so much more important than the gifts of the Holy Spirit. All of God's doctrines are important.
 

J.D.

Active Member
Site Supporter
DHK has pretty much expressed my own opinion on the issue. But in response to the OP:

1. Essential: "Let all things be done decently and in order."
2. Not essential: Sign gifts. There is "a more excellent way".
 

Earth Wind and Fire

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
DHK has pretty much expressed my own opinion on the issue. But in response to the OP:

1. Essential: "Let all things be done decently and in order."
2. Not essential: Sign gifts. There is "a more excellent way".

wow, you two agreeing....have you read ML-J books?

1. Revival
2. Joy Unspeakable

Knowing you, you might be enlightened!
 

J.D.

Active Member
Site Supporter
wow, you two agreeing....have you read ML-J books?

1. Revival
2. Joy Unspeakable

Knowing you, you might be enlightened!
You might be suprised how much DHK and myself agree!!! :)

But no, I have not read the two books you mention, but I have read Grudem's defense of continuationism - did a study of it in college - and if those books are no different than Grudem's, then I'm not interested.

A summary of my studies:

My pentecostal uncle and every other pentecostal I know (getting right to the point): "Speaking in Tongues is true because I've experienced it".

Grudem (after a long-winded psuedo-scriptural lead-in): "Speaking in Tongues is true because people have experienced it".
 

righteousdude2

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
As one man said: "Salvation (or the winning of souls) is not the most important thing in the Bible, obedience to God is.

I have obeyed God by following Him in Salvation and water baptism, and now I am following and obeying Him by spreading the Gospel and making disciples of men and women.

" Put in that context all of God's doctrines become important to us. We are commanded to Study to show ourselves approved

I have and continue to study and show myself approved before the Lord

to search the Scriptures; to be able to give to every man an answer; etc. Whether or not specific doctrines impress you is not important. They are important to the Lord. That is why God left His revelation in His book written for us. The more we know it, the more we know about our Lord, and the more we can draw closer to Him. We can only draw closer to the Lord as we find him through the Scriptures. There is a direct correlation between the study of the Scriptures and our relationship with Christ.

I couldn't AGREE more!

Not necessarily so. This particular field of study is currently the devil's playground.

As is the many different doctrines that man beholds. These doctrines have been used of Satan to divide and conquer saints and sinners and bring down churches and major denominations for centuries now. Who's to say that at this present time, with your adamant discourse over doctrines you hold near and dear, that you, yourself are not subtly caught up in the devils own follies?

The Charismatic movement is one of the fastest growing movements in our age today.

I have made it quite clear that I do not consider myself a "charismatic"

It is infected with demon possession, and ungodly error where people have put their experiences as more important than the Word of God.

No argument here. However, not all of us have thrown in with these folks. Their error filled doctrines, and false teachings. Or, lies and mass mind control (WOF movement)

Jesus said "Beware of the leaven of the Pharisees." In other words beware of the false teaching of the false teachers/false prophets.

We must also beware of those who teach a stale and stoic doctrine that paralyzes and holds its followers by fear. Keeping them in the on the farm, so to speak, and not letting them seek further knowledge by moving outside the age-old perimeters set by those who drafted their own comfortable doctrine's years ago.

That exists in abundance today. Jude commanded us: "that we should contend for the faith." We must not only know what you believe, you must know why you believe what you know.

There are many doctrines (such as the importance of baptism) that will not keep you from eternity. But does that make it any less important? Obedience to the will of God is the most important thing.

And I believe I already said that I am obedient. Who are you to judge my level of obedience? What gives you license to judge my measure of obedience? I may be more obedient to Him than you who has locked himself inside the perimeters of doctrines that are long overdue for examination and updating.

Should I have fellowship with those that bark like dogs, hiss like snakes, etc., as well as those that believe that speaking in tongues is obligatory for being saved?

It is not I who sound like a barking dog and hissing snake at this very moment in this conversation. You are madly and wildly barking and hissing because I have disagreed with some of your precious doctrinal stands.

I never once claimed that because I may, or may not speak in tongues THAT the masses that follow the Christ I serve must speak in tongues as evidence of being His, or being filled with the presence of the Holy Ghost.

I have always contended that it is man's testimony of salvation and water baptism that demonstrates their being a follower of Jesus!


It is a slippery slope? Where does it end. The AOG, one of the tamest of the groups believe that speaking in tongues is evidence of being baptized in the Spirit; that it is a subsequent blessing to salvation. They also believe that everyone should have it, and if they don't have it they should seek it. If you don't have it you are looked upon as someone who is "less spiritual." Do I fellowship with people that are so deeply in error?

It is unfortunate that your strict adherence to your precious doctrines keeps you from fellowship with fellow followers of Jesus Christ. As I said, it is not that important who we claim as our teacher (Timothy, Peter, Paul or John), what is important is that we fellowship as one by the name of Jesus regardless of our doctrinal stands?

It is you who will slide down that proverbial slippery slope of life is you continue to judge those who have doctrinal differences that may not line up with yours.

Heaven will be filled with more than one kind of Baptist. Filled with Lutherans, Methodists, AOG believers (singing in their tongues), and what have you.

The cornerstone to the church is built upon the premise of Jesus being our Lord and Savior, and I feel sorry for you because you have set your mind at being inflexible when it comes to accepting those who believe differently than you!


Here is the Biblical teaching on that issue:

Now I beseech you, brethren, mark them which cause divisions and offences contrary to the doctrine which ye have learned; and avoid them. (Romans 16:17)
--Tongues is a divisive issue. I couldn't AGREE more with you. Look at how you are allowing something that YOU think I practice and say is mandatory for all believers. Your mind set has divided us, not my doctrine and differences.

There is much more. There is the matter of fellowship with those who hold to Biblical error; serious Biblical error.

Who are you to say that I am holding to Biblical error? Maybe it is, and has been you all this time, who is in Biblical error of the truth?

My heart and arms of fellowship are open to you DHK, regardless of your beliefs and differences. I offer a hand of fellowship, yet it is YOU, not me, who viciously slaps it away, with words of judgment and disdain! Now tell me who is exercising more error, you, or me?


Baptism won't keep you from eternity either. But I believe it is important, as is the Lord's Supper. Why are they so much more important than the gifts of the Holy Spirit. All of God's doctrines are important.

In conclusion, I couldn't AGREE more with you. All of the ordinances, and I include foot washing, are important doctrinal teachings. The only difference between us, and I am NOT holding it against you, is that I believe the gifts are as much for today, as they were for the days of the Disciples and apostles.

I really can't find CONCLUSIVE Scripture(s) that demonstrates to me (when it comes to the gifts, and subsequent signs and wonders), that there was an EXPIRATION date in place.

You seem to lack trust in your fellow persons to know what is good teaching and what is bad teaching.

As I've said before, WOF teachers have left a path of destruction, miles wide, in their aftermath. I have had to step in and help restore the faith of so many who were destroyed by WOF teachers and left for dead.

My ministry (Remove the Haze) is spent showing people who have been beaten up spiritually, that they are still a child of God, useful, and ready to return to that narrow, yet difficult path to the narrow door of Heaven.

I am not the enemy, DHK, but if you allow your mindset to keep you from working outside of the (doctrinal) box, you are the biggest loser because you have alienated yourself from the joy and blessing of knowing a sweet fellowship with people of different understands.

There are those in the Charismatic world who are as adamant as you, and they too lose the opportunity to be one with the entire body of Christ, which is much larger than any one denomination or set of doctrinal standards!

It's time to get yourself down from that "better-than-thou" perch and join the Jesus people of this world.

The time for judgment will be soon enough, and it really should be left up to God to tell us who is right and wrong. However, I'm sure He'll not keep many out of heaven because they may speak in tongues, or hold tightly to Calvinism.

His only criterion is that those who pass through that narrow gate is that we have the blood of Jesus covering our sin, and I know without a doubt that I am covered from head to toe with His blood.

I see a heaven where the doctrines and denominational walls that once separated us on earth are cast aside, and we all stand in awe of our heavenly Father around that throne.


Thanks for your long explanation, and please forgive me if mine was a little too long, but, I wanted to point out that our differences are more set in stone in your heart and mind then they are in mine!

Shalom,

Pastor Paul :type
 
Last edited by a moderator:

freeatlast

New Member
I have a question for those who believe that the gifts are still in operation today.
Can anyone point to anyone who has been healed or raised from the dead outside the bible that can be clinically and physically verified? By healed I mean just like in the bible. On the spot not several days later and the condition never returns. This must be someone who you know of personally or can show with absolute proof they had the problem and was healed. This must not be in response to prayer, but because someone went to them and healed them on the spot or raised them from the dead. Anyone?
Or someone with the gift of miracles. They would be able to do things like turning water into wine, walking on water, feeding multitudes with very little and so on. Anyone?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top