• Welcome to Baptist Board, a friendly forum to discuss the Baptist Faith in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to all the features that our community has to offer.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

Entering or invited?

Martin Marprelate

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
It is clear that you don't even understand what you write! You say on the one hand, "people do not accept the invitation - they are not WILLING to come"; and then , on the other hand, "This is the glory of Irresistible Grace"! If this grace for salvation is NOT ACCEPTED, as in REJECTED, then HOW can it be called "Irresistible"? do you guys really understand the English language? The one cancels out the other! :rolleyes:
again, if this grace is "Irresistible", then WHY the need to COMPEL anyone? makes ZERO sense!
With much respect, I'm afraid it is you who appear not to understand, though I rather think that you know enough theology to comprehend the difference between the Universal Call and the Particular Call.
The Gospel call goes out to everyone, but people do not receive it savingly unless unless it comes with irresistible power.
Look, Lazarus is dead; he's been dead for quite some time. We can call on lazarus to come back to life; we can tell him how much better it would be if he were alive. We can point out to him the severe disadvatages of b
 

Iconoclast

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
God does NOT play games with anyone! Either He sincerely INVITES the entire human race to repentance and faith and salvation in Jesus Christ, or He does not. All this distinctions are man-made RUBBISH!

Like I have heard, that in God's "revealed will", He desires that the entire human race is saved. But, in His "secret will", He really only desires to save the elect! UTTER RUBBISH!

Reformed theology on the salvation of sinners, is mainly HERESY!
Your evident lack of ability to grasp truth is on display yet again...
Your posts are borderline incoherent in that they depart from any scriptural base.
 

JonC

Moderator
Moderator
The whole human race is indeed invited, and furthermore commanded, to repent and to trust in Christ for salvation. 'For whoever calls upon the name of the Lord will be saved' (Joel 2:32; Romans 10:13). But, as I have pointed out many times, men and women will only reject Christ, not choose Him. 'All day long I have stretched out My hands to a disobedient and contrary people' (Isaiah 65:2; Romans 10:21). As the saying goes, if God did not choose some, none would be saved. So God, in His mercy, has opened the hearts of a vast number of obstinate sinners to receive Christ, and these He has saved at measureless cost.

I understand that you do not like this teaching, but it is the teaching of the Bible, and you shouting

is not going to change that, only engender unpleasantness..
I agree that all men have been invited, and that Christ died to save "the Bride" (or lay down His life for His sheep").

I am curious if you are able to articulate the "invitiation" to all men (without exception) against the effective call to those who will believe (i.e , what part of Christ's work is for everybody and what part is for the elect prior to them believing?).
 

percho

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Maybe I should have asked about a little background.

Just what was Paul on the road to Damascus to do?
 

JonC

Moderator
Moderator
While waiting on @Martin Marprelate I'd like to pose to others, particularly Calvinists who view a general and particular call.

How is this general call or invitation accomplished in relation to the cross? (If Christ's death accomplished salvation or forgiveness of sins for only the elect, what part of Christ's work made it possible for all to be saved?).
 

DaveXR650

Well-Known Member
Jon. I can tell you ahead of time that Calvinists are all over the place on this. Christ's death accomplished salvation for the elect when he died in the sense that what God ordains WILL come to pass. An "elect" person is lost until he comes to Christ by faith. But he will do this. And he will do this because of the work of the Holy Spirit. God is not sitting somewhere saying to Jesus "well, let's hope now that at least some of these people come by faith". This business of election is God's business. But numerous scriptures support it. God has shown it to us in a glimpse into his purpose but he has not given us warrant to speculate on who's in or out. So what does it look like to us?

The general call or invitation goes out to everyone who is within the hearing of it. In other words, everyone who hears the gospel or the word of God is invited to come by this general call. And it is REAL. Any one of those who hear this and come to Christ by faith will be saved. Were they elect? Yes, looking back - but that's as far as we can speculate.

Now, we believe that men are not going to come to Christ by faith without the Holy Spirits direct involvement. You must be born again, regenerated, enlightened, and other terms too. This is the effectual call. What does this look like to us? It looks like the person comes under conviction and has a desire to come to Christ and see's his own sin and the value of Christ. This is a work of the Spirit and you are passive in it.

You are not saved from eternity or from the time Christ died on the cross.
Faith IS a means or a condition.
When you talk about "salvation" for someone who lives a time after coming to Christ then sincere obedience, love, good works, and pursuit of a holy life are requirements for salvation.

Half the Calvinists on here will completely freak out over this.
 

JonC

Moderator
Moderator
Jon. I can tell you ahead of time that Calvinists are all over the place on this. Christ's death accomplished salvation for the elect when he died in the sense that what God ordains WILL come to pass. An "elect" person is lost until he comes to Christ by faith. But he will do this. And he will do this because of the work of the Holy Spirit. God is not sitting somewhere saying to Jesus "well, let's hope now that at least some of these people come by faith". This business of election is God's business. But numerous scriptures support it. God has shown it to us in a glimpse into his purpose but he has not given us warrant to speculate on who's in or out. So what does it look like to us?

The general call or invitation goes out to everyone who is within the hearing of it. In other words, everyone who hears the gospel or the word of God is invited to come by this general call. And it is REAL. Any one of those who hear this and come to Christ by faith will be saved. Were they elect? Yes, looking back - but that's as far as we can speculate.

Now, we believe that men are not going to come to Christ by faith without the Holy Spirits direct involvement. You must be born again, regenerated, enlightened, and other terms too. This is the effectual call. What does this look like to us? It looks like the person comes under conviction and has a desire to come to Christ and see's his own sin and the value of Christ. This is a work of the Spirit and you are passive in it.

You are not saved from eternity or from the time Christ died on the cross.
Faith IS a means or a condition.
When you talk about "salvation" for someone who lives a time after coming to Christ then sincere obedience, love, good works, and pursuit of a holy life are requirements for salvation.

Half the Calvinists on here will completely freak out over this.
I agree. I was a Calvinist for a long time. I still affirm the truths that led me to Calvinism, but departed over other issues.

Anyway, I have learned that Calvinism, like any other view, is not a one size fits all thing. I appreciate you taking the time to explain your position. We have much in common.

I am interested how @Martin Marprelate views this issue as well.

It is good to look at different positions, even if they are similar. Sometimes people can't answer for their faith and conversation may be a benefit. Other times views may need tweaking. And if nothing else, people can learn about others.
 

DaveXR650

Well-Known Member
This thread is not about the controversy of how one is redeemed, but specifically upon the words used in the desire for one to be redeemed.

Whether it be one on one, one to the assembly, or one to those who pass by on a street, how would you put the message of belief?

"I conclude with an exhortation to come to Christ, and accept of salvation in this way. You are invited to come to Christ, heartily to close with him, and trust in him for salvation: and if you do, you shall have the benefit of this glorious contrivance. .....God has already contrived everything that is needful for your salvation; and there is nothing wanting but your consent. ......Salvation is already brought to your door; and the Savior stands, knocks, and calls that you would open to him, that he might bring it in to you. There remains nothing but your consent. All the difficulty now remaining is with your own heart. If you perish now, it must be wholly at your door. It must be because you would not come to Christ that you might have life; and because you virtually choose death rather than life........"
(Jonathan Edwards, Wisdom Displayed in Salvation, sect.XI Exhortation to Come to Christ")

I cut out parts for brevity but if you ask me, this is how you do it and it sounds an awful lot like an old fashioned Baptist preacher. And Edwards was definitely as much of a Calvinist as you can be. Agreeing with the TULIP or believing in God's meticulous sovereignty of everything doesn't mean you don't witness and preach with everything you have and with all the means you have.
 

agedman

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
"I conclude with an exhortation to come to Christ, and accept of salvation in this way. You are invited to come to Christ, heartily to close with him, and trust in him for salvation: and if you do, you shall have the benefit of this glorious contrivance. .....God has already contrived everything that is needful for your salvation; and there is nothing wanting but your consent. ......Salvation is already brought to your door; and the Savior stands, knocks, and calls that you would open to him, that he might bring it in to you. There remains nothing but your consent. All the difficulty now remaining is with your own heart. If you perish now, it must be wholly at your door. It must be because you would not come to Christ that you might have life; and because you virtually choose death rather than life........"
(Jonathan Edwards, Wisdom Displayed in Salvation, sect.XI Exhortation to Come to Christ")

I cut out parts for brevity but if you ask me, this is how you do it and it sounds an awful lot like an old fashioned Baptist preacher. And Edwards was definitely as much of a Calvinist as you can be. Agreeing with the TULIP or believing in God's meticulous sovereignty of everything doesn't mean you don't witness and preach with everything you have and with all the means you have.
Jonathan Edwards was possibly the most brilliant American that has ever lived, and very earnest in his desire that others come to an understanding of the gift of Salvation.
 

agedman

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
While waiting on @Martin Marprelate I'd like to pose to others, particularly Calvinists who view a general and particular call.

How is this general call or invitation accomplished in relation to the cross? (If Christ's death accomplished salvation or forgiveness of sins for only the elect, what part of Christ's work made it possible for all to be saved?).
Jon, should I answer knowing you already know? I will for those reading.

l hold these as foundational and totally agreeable with the most Scriptures.

1) The death burial and resurrection of Christ benefit only believers.
2) The blood shed was for all iniquity for all the creation. That does not mean atonement was made for all, for the atonement had multiple facets.
3) Therefore, it is right to say to everyone, “believe on the Lord Jesus Christ and be saved,” for there is no more sacrifice to be made than has been made.
4) When one believes, that person is given eternal life because Christ rose conquering death and the grave. However, one who does not believe is already condemned.

I just don’t find “only the sins of the elect” as fitting the standard of Scriptures, for we all have, do, and will sin. That results in physical death. Those that do not believe face the second death (lake of fire).

Our late TCassidy put forth “sufficient for all, efficient for some.” I just could not come that far with the whole of atonement.

The blood covers all sin, but rebellion turns the heart and mind away from the light.

What would be our Lord’s response to your question? It would not be the, “I am the resurrection and the life, anyone …”
 

SavedByGrace

Well-Known Member
This does not make any sense!
True -a parable is an illustration -

But what is the part about "lies"

because there are some who say that "parables" are illustrations that can be either true, or even false, like myths, and cannot be taken as serious messages to derive doctrines from. For example, the Rich Man and Lazarus, is not a true account of the after-life for the lost and saved, as this is a parable that does not need to be truthful.
 

Salty

20,000 Posts Club
Administrator
because there are some who say that "parables" are illustrations that can be either true, or even false, like myths, and cannot be taken as serious messages to derive doctrines from. For example, the Rich Man and Lazarus, is not a true account of the after-life for the lost and saved, as this is a parable that does not need to be truthful.

what makes you think that is not a true story.
In fact, If I am not mistaken - that is the only parable which gives the name of one of the individual.
 

SavedByGrace

Well-Known Member
what makes you think that is not a true story.
In fact, If I am not mistaken - that is the only parable which gives the name of one of the individual.

I said that there are SOME who use this idea that parables do not need to be factual. I believe that every parable that Jesus uses, including the Rich Man and Lazarus, IF it can be included in this class, are completely factual illustrations, that can be fully relied on.
 

SavedByGrace

Well-Known Member
The general call or invitation goes out to everyone who is within the hearing of it. In other words, everyone who hears the gospel or the word of God is invited to come by this general call. And it is REAL. Any one of those who hear this and come to Christ by faith will be saved. Were they elect? Yes, looking back - but that's as far as we can speculate.

blah, blah, blah...

You guys speak in riddles, and not consistent to what the Bible teaches!

IF, the Gospel Call or Invitation is given to ALL, that is, the entire human race. Then this can only be SINCERE, if God has made provision for the ALL, in the Death of the Lord Jesus Christ. He must have Died for these ALL. Otherwise it is no more than a SHAM!

The Universal Call of the Gospel Message, to "every human created", as Mark 16:15 tells us, can only be serious, when we accept the Universal Death of Jesus Christ on the Cross. Not the same as Universal salvation.

This negates the TULI in TULIP!
 

agedman

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
blah, blah, blah...

You guys speak in riddles, and not consistent to what the Bible teaches!

IF, the Gospel Call or Invitation is given to ALL, that is, the entire human race. Then this can only be SINCERE, if God has made provision for the ALL, in the Death of the Lord Jesus Christ. He must have Died for these ALL. Otherwise it is no more than a SHAM!

The Universal Call of the Gospel Message, to "every human created", as Mark 16:15 tells us, can only be serious, when we accept the Universal Death of Jesus Christ on the Cross. Not the same as Universal salvation.

This negates the TULI in TULIP!

We are merely “seed” sowers.

The seed is indiscriminately sown.

God is in charge of the dirt.

He makes the determination as to the use and conditions of the soil, not we.

The call goes out to all, for that is the will of the Father.

We may plant, we may water, “but God gives the increase.”
 
Top