CatholicConvert
New Member
Hello Grant --
You are correct. I was not saying that the beliefs are extreme. But the language is intemperate at best and at worst, in a Protestant perspective, scandalous.
You must realize that for those who have NEVER been Catholic, never been given any idea of the motherhood of the Blessed Virgin, or have any concept of the Church's early teachings, such as the quote which Carson gave from the fourth century, these kinds of statements seem completely disconnected from the larger body of Scripture.
The issue then becomes whether Scripture is all encompassing and complete just as written, or if there are underlying themes which must be exegeted out of it. The Blessed Virgin as the New Eve is one of those themes, and it is particularly well hidden to those who are not trained to see it in Scripture. So for Baptists and others who have never been trained for this kind of thinking and are unfamiliar with the mindset of the first, second, and third century Church, it just looks like idol worship, plain and simple.
As I said, even for me, as a very young convert to the faith, these quotes absolutely make me WINCE!! I am simply not used to this kind of overflowing of praise and honor which seems to take the place of our Lord, and it is going to take a long time for me to "think Catholic" and retool my understanding.
The Marian doctrines are by far the largest hurdle which most Protestants have to clear on the last lap to "Swim the Tiber". The kind of language which Liguouri and others have used in the past is most certainly NO HELP AT ALL in overcoming these difficulties. It's like teaching a five year old to swim by tossing him into the Atlantic Ocean in the middle of a typhoon!!
Brother Ed
You are correct. I was not saying that the beliefs are extreme. But the language is intemperate at best and at worst, in a Protestant perspective, scandalous.
You must realize that for those who have NEVER been Catholic, never been given any idea of the motherhood of the Blessed Virgin, or have any concept of the Church's early teachings, such as the quote which Carson gave from the fourth century, these kinds of statements seem completely disconnected from the larger body of Scripture.
The issue then becomes whether Scripture is all encompassing and complete just as written, or if there are underlying themes which must be exegeted out of it. The Blessed Virgin as the New Eve is one of those themes, and it is particularly well hidden to those who are not trained to see it in Scripture. So for Baptists and others who have never been trained for this kind of thinking and are unfamiliar with the mindset of the first, second, and third century Church, it just looks like idol worship, plain and simple.
As I said, even for me, as a very young convert to the faith, these quotes absolutely make me WINCE!! I am simply not used to this kind of overflowing of praise and honor which seems to take the place of our Lord, and it is going to take a long time for me to "think Catholic" and retool my understanding.
The Marian doctrines are by far the largest hurdle which most Protestants have to clear on the last lap to "Swim the Tiber". The kind of language which Liguouri and others have used in the past is most certainly NO HELP AT ALL in overcoming these difficulties. It's like teaching a five year old to swim by tossing him into the Atlantic Ocean in the middle of a typhoon!!
Brother Ed