• Welcome to Baptist Board, a friendly forum to discuss the Baptist Faith in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to all the features that our community has to offer.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

Why is all Israel not Israel???

Brother Bob

New Member
Rippon said:
BB: I had said way back in post #112 that Jesus is the very embodiment of the Kingdom of God .
Embodiment can be misinterpted so many ways. Your use of that word, are you saying Jesus was speaking of Himself, when He said the Kingdom is among or within you????

BBob,
 

Isaiah40:28

New Member
Brother Bob said:
My point is, they could see Jesus, but they could not see the Kingdom, because it is within God's children.
Okay, is it also possible that they could not spiritually see Jesus' kingdom manifest as Himself? And that the rest of the passage goes on to say that the kingdom will be revealed once again in His person at His second coming in all its majesty and glory?
 

Brother Bob

New Member
Isaiah40:28 said:
Okay, is it also possible that they could not spiritually see Jesus' kingdom manifest as Himself? And that the rest of the passage goes on to say that the kingdom will be revealed once again in His person at His second coming in all its majesty and glory?

I don't think so Isaiah myself, you may be right but to me they were asking to see the Kingdom and Jesus said it comes not by observation, (you can't see it with your natural eyes).

BBob,

Isaiah; do you believe the Kingdom is Jesus that was among them???
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Isaiah40:28

New Member
Brother Bob said:
I don't think so Isaiah myself, you may be right but to me they were asking to see the Kingdom and Jesus said it comes not by observation, (you can't see it with your natural eyes).
I'm not sure, Bob what the phrase, "not come with your careful observation" means. Does it simply mean, you can't see it "with your natural eyes"? I tend to think not. I just checked an online commentary (IVP from Biblegateway)and something else that was suggested in addition to "legal observation" is this:
is it an allusion to the apocalyptic signs that are supposed to accompany the kingdom's coming? Jesus argues that the kingdom's coming does not require apocalyptic observation, since that was the normal expectation. The initial phase of the kingdom does not come that way.

Bob said:
Isaiah; do you believe the Kingdom is Jesus that was among them???
When I read this passage here, that's what seems to be a natural reading.
Matthew 3:2-3 seems to reflect this view as well.
Am I dogmatic that this is what it means? no.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Brother Bob

New Member
Isaiah40:28 said:
I'm not sure, Bob what the phrase, "not come with your careful observation" means. Does it simply mean, you can't see it "with your natural eyes"? I tend to think not. I just checked an online commentary (IVP from Biblegateway)and something else that was suggested in addition to "legal observation" is this:

Well, we have two things that I am basing my belief on. One is observation, the other is "within" you. I have preached for 35 years the Kingdom is within you, and will continue to do so.


When I read this passage here, that's what seems to be a natural reading.
John 3:2-3 seem to reflect this view as well.
Am I dogmatic that this is what it means? no.
No, you are being honest and that is what I like. I have no problem with Jesus being the Kingdom, except the observation part.

I hope we all can end up believing the Kingdom is Jesus.

BBob,
 

Isaiah40:28

New Member
Brother Bob said:
No, you are being honest and that is what I like. I have no problem with Jesus being the Kingdom, except the observation part
And I have two things going for me:
1) I haven't preached anything for 35 years. LOL. So I have no track record to uphold. :)
2) Commentators seem to leave room for several different interpretations of the phrase "careful observation".
 

TCGreek

New Member
Brother Bob said:
Please explain "it comes not by observation"???

Is Jesus not your King now????

BBob

Whether Jesus is my king or not is totally irrelevant regarding Luke 17:21. That is not the issue.
 

Brother Bob

New Member
TCGreek said:
Whether Jesus is my king or not is totally irrelevant regarding Luke 17:21. That is not the issue.
Well is Jesus the Kingdom that comes not by observation???

And if Jesus is your King, it has a lot to do with Luke 17:21. Kinda hard to be a King and not have a Kingdom. King of what???
 

TCGreek

New Member
Brother Bob said:
Please explain "it comes not by observation"???

1. The Phrisees' idea of a kingdom was one riding on a white horse for battle against the enemies and then establishing his kingdom--that's the observation Jesus is dismissing.

Are you saying that Jesus is not your King now?????

2. If this question is based on Luke 17:21, then it is irrelevant.

So, you can see inside of yourself????

3. What is the point of this question?

Among you and not able to see it, just plainly do not go together. That is just common sense.

4. I am sorry that you are missing what Jesus is really saying---it seems like you are looking for an institution like those Pharisees Jesus was addressing.
 

TCGreek

New Member
Brother Bob said:
Well is Jesus the Kingdom that comes not by observation???

And if Jesus is your King, it has a lot to do with Luke 17:21. Kinda hard to be a King and not have a Kingdom. King of what???

Jesus was addressing some of his critics--Pharisees---I am not a critic of Jesus.
 

DeafPosttrib

New Member
To my understand.

Many Jews and Pharisees were expecting to see their own King in power and glory, wear gold crown, fancy robe, with rod, ride on horse. They expect their important top ranked person to appear the world with glory and power to overthrown Roman Empire, and establish Judasism and religion political in Jerusalem to be the world's capitol.

When Jesus came to earth. He was not an important person, he was not a rich. He was very poor and humble. I am sure that he wore cheap robe or dress. Hard for Pharisees and Jews to believe that Jesus is the true Kinbg of Israel, because they were not able to reconginize Jesus is the son of God and truly King, because he was poor and dress in cheap clothing. Also, Jesus have no role or job on earth. He was just as servant.

Pharisees and Jews demanded their own King come in glory and power to overthrown Roman Empire, so, they expecting to see Kingdom appear earth in power. They have the wrong idea about Kingdom. Kinbgdom was not like as 'fanasty dream'.

Jesus told them, kingdom was not come with observation, it come within them. I believe he means that he is already present with them, they didn't realize that the King is already right there within few feet away from them. Jesus is the King. That why, they failed for recognize(notice) Jesus is the King. Actual, they rejected Christ as truly Messiah, King, and Son of God.

Premill believes kingdom was postoned (delay) till millennial, because Jews rejected Christ as King.

But, the kingdom was already brought by Jesus Christ.

In Matthew 4:17 tellsus, when after Jesus was baptized, and fasted for 40 days. He began to preach and he said, "Repent: for the kingdom of heaven is AT HAND." My understand what He means. He commands them to repent sins, for the kingdom of heaven is now at present.

Clear, Christ already bring kingdom to Israel. But most Jews and Pharisees were blind and reject him.

Does, Christ postponed the kingdom wait till millennial, because they reject him?

No. He already bring it to Israel. And the kingdom was start with in Jerusalem. When the Holy Spirit poured upon disciples on Pentacost Day of Acts chapter 2. They spread the kingdom over the world from Jerusalem.

We already have kingdom within us.

Kingdom is all about Jesus Christ and gospel. Kingdom is not about political or government as fansasty dream.

Kingdom is spiritual right now.

When Jesus comes again, kingdom shall become visible will be on new earth, and we shall reign with Christ forever and ever.

In Christ
Rev. 22:20 -Amen!
 

Brother Bob

New Member
DeafPosttrib said:
To my understand.

Many Jews and Pharisees were expecting to see their own King in power and glory, wear gold crown, fancy robe, with rod, ride on horse. They expect their important top ranked person to appear the world with glory and power to overthrown Roman Empire, and establish Judasism and religion political in Jerusalem to be the world's capitol.

When Jesus came to earth. He was not an important person, he was not a rich. He was very poor and humble. I am sure that he wore cheap robe or dress. Hard for Pharisees and Jews to believe that Jesus is the true Kinbg of Israel, because they were not able to reconginize Jesus is the son of God and truly King, because he was poor and dress in cheap clothing. Also, Jesus have no role or job on earth. He was just as servant.

Pharisees and Jews demanded their own King come in glory and power to overthrown Roman Empire, so, they expecting to see Kingdom appear earth in power. They have the wrong idea about Kingdom. Kinbgdom was not like as 'fanasty dream'.

Jesus told them, kingdom was not come with observation, it come within them. I believe he means that he is already present with them, they didn't realize that the King is already right there within few feet away from them. Jesus is the King. That why, they failed for recognize(notice) Jesus is the King. Actual, they rejected Christ as truly Messiah, King, and Son of God.

Premill believes kingdom was postoned (delay) till millennial, because Jews rejected Christ as King.

But, the kingdom was already brought by Jesus Christ.

In Matthew 4:17 tellsus, when after Jesus was baptized, and fasted for 40 days. He began to preach and he said, "Repent: for the kingdom of heaven is AT HAND." My understand what He means. He commands them to repent sins, for the kingdom of heaven is now at present.

Clear, Christ already bring kingdom to Israel. But most Jews and Pharisees were blind and reject him.

Does, Christ postponed the kingdom wait till millennial, because they reject him?

No. He already bring it to Israel. And the kingdom was start with in Jerusalem. When the Holy Spirit poured upon disciples on Pentacost Day of Acts chapter 2. They spread the kingdom over the world from Jerusalem.

We already have kingdom within us.

Kingdom is all about Jesus Christ and gospel. Kingdom is not about political or government as fansasty dream.

Kingdom is spiritual right now.

When Jesus comes again, kingdom shall become visible will be on new earth, and we shall reign with Christ forever and ever.

In Christ
Rev. 22:20 -Amen!

Thanks Deafposttrib;
Sure is good to have some support on here. I feel like I am swiming in swift waters here.

BBob,
 

Brother Bob

New Member
TCGreek said:
Jesus was addressing some of his critics--Pharisees---I am not a critic of Jesus.

The question was simple, is Jesus the Kingdom??

How many believe that Jesus is the Kingdom?? Instead of believing the Kingdom is within you?
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Brother Bob

New Member
TCGreek said:
1. The Phrisees' idea of a kingdom was one riding on a white horse for battle against the enemies and then establishing his kingdom--that's the observation Jesus is dismissing.

So, not being able to see the Kingdom, means no white horse or battle?


2. If this question is based on Luke 17:21, then it is irrelevant.

It is not irrelevant, if Jesus is King, He must have a Kingdom.


3. What is the point of this question?



4. I am sorry that you are missing what Jesus is really saying---it seems like you are looking for an institution like those Pharisees Jesus was addressing.
Not me, I am trying to tell you that I believe in a Spiritual Kingdom, one where we can worship God in Spirit and in Truth. You, and others seem to deny it.


BBob,
 

TCGreek

New Member
Brother Bob said:
The question was simple, is Jesus the Kingdom??

How many believe that Jesus is the Kingdom?? Instead of believing the Kingdom is within you?

BBob, good day,

1. I don't do well with the Either/Or fallacy--it is either this or that.

2. Here's a third position according to Rippon, which I hold to and makes sense of several statements and actions of Jesus--Jesus was the embodiment of the kingdom---kingdom refers to the rule of God in Christ earthly ministry at the time.

3. How then was Jesus able to say that because He cast out demons by the Spirit, that meant the kingdom had come (Matt 12:28, a text I see you have not dealt with properly)? It must be because the kingdom concept was present in what He was doing.

4. Based on Luke 17:21 I cannot say that the kingdom is within me---Jesus was addressing some of His critics the Pharisees and said the kingdom was among them.
 

Brother Bob

New Member
TCGreek said:
BBob, good day,

1. I don't do well with the Either/Or fallacy--it is either this or that.

2. Here's a third position according to Rippon, which I hold to and makes sense of several statements and actions of Jesus--Jesus was the embodiment of the kingdom---kingdom refers to the rule of God in Christ earthly ministry at the time.

3. How then was Jesus able to say that because He cast out demons by the Spirit, that meant the kingdom had come (Matt 12:28, a text I see you have not dealt with properly)? It must be because the kingdom concept was present in what He was doing.

4. Based on Luke 17:21 I cannot say that the kingdom is within me---Jesus was addressing some of His critics the Pharisees and said the kingdom was among them.
Most translations says "within" you.

rule of God in Christ earthly ministry at the time
So, the Kingdom is the "rule of God in the ministry of Christ"??? Do you honestly think that makes sense TC; So, everywhere the "rule of God in the ministry of Christ is," is the Kingdom, is that what you are saying??

You believe Christ is a King but you will not say, what He is King of, amazing!


BBob,
 
Last edited by a moderator:

TCGreek

New Member
Brother Bob said:
Most translations says "within" you.

1. When is the majority always right?

So, the Kingdom is the "rule of God in the ministry of Christ"??? Do you honestly think that makes sense TC; So, everywhere the "rule of God in the ministry of Christ is," is the Kingdom, is that what you are saying??

2. How then do we make sense of Matt 12:28?

You believe Christ is a King but you will not say, what He is King of, amazing!


BBob,

3. Jesus is king of my life.
 

Brother Bob

New Member
TCGreek said:
1. When is the majority always right?



2. How then do we make sense of Matt 12:28?



3. Jesus is king of my life.

And He is "within" you!!!! Simple isn't it??

Rom 8:10And if Christ [be] in you, the body [is] dead because of sin; but the Spirit [is] life because of righteousness.
 

TCGreek

New Member
Brother Bob said:
And He is "within" you!!!! Simple isn't it??

Rom 8:10And if Christ [be] in you, the body [is] dead because of sin; but the Spirit [is] life because of righteousness.

As long as you are not piggy-backing on Luke 17:21, that is fine with me.
 
Top