• Welcome to Baptist Board, a friendly forum to discuss the Baptist Faith in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to all the features that our community has to offer.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

Why The Second Amendment?

TCassidy

Late-Administator Emeritus
Administrator
Let's not act like they were just some innocent group minding their own business and the big bad white man came a long and took every thing from them.
Yes, all those women and children were horrible killers.
 

Use of Time

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Indians never owned any land and hated the idea that anyone would claim ownership. The Indians fought among themselves on a regular basis over hunting rights in different areas. Most tribes but a few were actually nomadic. They killed and slaughtered each other over "land" or hunting areas. Let's not act like they were just some innocent group minding their own business and the big bad white man came a long and took every thing from them. Its just not reality.

What in the world is the matter with you.
 

Reynolds

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Indians never owned any land and hated the idea that anyone would claim ownership. The Indians fought among themselves on a regular basis over hunting rights in different areas. Most tribes but a few were actually nomadic. They killed and slaughtered each other over "land" or hunting areas. Let's not act like they were just some innocent group minding their own business and the big bad white man came a long and took every thing from them. Its just not reality.
It is indeed reality. You going to blame American slavery on the fact that tribal wars in Africa were the root of the slave trade? This is just typical pc Crap. Blame the Indian for everything involving the white man and blame the white man for everything involving the black man. The American Indian did not ask Europeans to come here. We did not ask them to butcher us. We did not ask them to bring disease to us that wiped us out. I sure don't need you to tell me how they did us a huge favor by coming here.
 
Last edited:

Reynolds

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Tom, IIRC, Indians did not gain 14th Amendment citizen status until the 1920s.
All gained it then. It was kind of mixed application prior to that. Another thing that annoys me about this nation, universally blacks were citizens over 50 years before Indians.
My lineage is weird. The thread of white blood that runs through it goes all the way back to the first Royal Governor of Georgia.
 

Salty

20,000 Posts Club
Administrator
All gained it then. It was kind of mixed application prior to that. Another thing that annoys me about this nation, universally blacks were citizens over 50 years before Indians. ...

Did/do the Indians want American citizenship.

A few years ago, the Iroquois wanted to go overseas to play in a LaCrosse playoff tournament.
However they refused to use American passports - and demanded to use their own, but
the hand written passports would not be accepted by Europe.
 

Squire Robertsson

Administrator
Administrator
My remark was made in reply to Tom's that the Indians at Wounded Knee had their Second Amendment Rights as citizens violated. That is a different situation than the Iroquois a hundred plus years later.
Did/do the Indians want American citizenship.
 

Reynolds

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Did/do the Indians want American citizenship.

A few years ago, the Iroquois wanted to go overseas to play in a LaCrosse playoff tournament.
However they refused to use American passports - and demanded to use their own, but
the hand written passports would not be accepted by Europe.
Honestly today almost all of the members who still live on the reservation want the best of both worlds. They want to be independent when it benefits them, but they sure are not going to give up all that Federal money they get. The Indians on the reservation have been reduced to welfare dependent, defeated, pitiful people. I associate with many tribesmen who left the reservation, but I don't like the mentality or mindset of most of those that remain there. I have nothing in common with them.
 
Last edited:

Revmitchell

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
It is indeed reality. You going to blame American slavery on the fact that tribal wars in Africa were the root of the slave trade? This is just typical pc Crap. Blame the Indian for everything involving the white man and blame the white man for everything involving the black man. The American Indian did not ask Europeans to come here. We did not ask them to butcher us. We did not ask them to bring disease to us that wiped us out. I sure don't need you to tell me how they did us a huge favor by coming here.

no one including me blamed anything on the black man or the indian.
 

TCassidy

Late-Administator Emeritus
Administrator
Tom, IIRC, Indians did not gain 14th Amendment citizen status until the 1920s.
That is correct, but that status was retroactive. And the Constitution applies to all who are on US soil and subject to US law (IE not having diplomatic immunity), not just to citizens.
 

Squire Robertsson

Administrator
Administrator
Regretfully, the government forces at Wounded Knee didn't take your position.
That is correct, but that status was retroactive. And the Constitution applies to all who are on US soil and subject to US law (IE not having diplomatic immunity), not just to citizens.
 

FollowTheWay

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Used communally not owned communally
This was the basis for the fight between cattlemen and farmers in the West. The cattlemen wanted a free range to graze their herd while the farmers wanted to fence it in to protect their crops. So you're arguing that cattlemen had no right to use that land? Farmers would have been justified in attacking and killing them?
 
Top