BobRyan
Well-Known Member
I think it's a little more complicated. The catechism clearly states that only Christ is the mediator and the way of salvation. Catholics generally affirm that the "Church" referrs to not only the Roman Catholic institution, but also the whole of all Christian believers who accept and affirm Christ as the mediator and the way of salvation.
This is what Catholics tell us over and over again with consistency and frequency, yet we continue to tell them what we think they're supposed to believe. We accusing them of following blindly what they'er told, yet when they tell us otherwise, we tell them what we think the RCC doctrine is supposed to be, and then get mad at them for not following blindly what they are told.
I understand the frustration and the need to be accurate. But in this "everybody is a member of the catholic church" idea - the RCC itself is very clear that such is not the case.
For example - "the New Covenant" is not applicable to non-Catholics according to the RCC. Hint - this means that you and I are not saved under the Biblical New Covenent - by Catholic standards.
Christ said "this is the cup of the New Covenant in my blood" - Catholics argue that this is very specifically - the Catholic Eucharist. While they allow this for Eastern Orthodox as well - they do not allow it for Baptists, or Methodists or Seventh-day Adventists etc etc.
Hence - they do not practice open communion.
In the Catholic model - those non-Catholic groups are saved by some "other method" other than the New Covenant method of scripture.
I've got as much issue with RCC practices as the next person, but we seem to be rather hypocritical in the above area.
I agree with you that accuracy is an important point to keep in mind.
in Christ,
Bob