Catholic Apologist claims Catholics and Muslims worship

[Mikey]

Jame White's response

 

[atpollard]

Joe is being a little dishonest. If I say “No, Christians and Muslims do not worship the same God.” … then that would suggest that Christians and Muslims worship DIFFERENT Gods.

Are there really multiple Gods?

No, there is only one God (supreme creator). So, when a Muslim or Hindu acknowledges a CREATOR (as Romans 1 suggests all men know), then they are worshiping “THE GOD” … there IS only one. However, the being described in the Quran is NOT the Jesus Christ of the New Testament who claimed to be that one GOD.

Therefore, it really is a YES and NO question that cannot be answered as Joe would have liked without giving a false answer. The Philosophers and Theologians that Joe quoted and mocked, all attempted to acknowledge that the being described in the Quran is not the Jesus Christ of the Bible, but there is only one God … not a God of Islam and a God of Christianity. (our God is not bigger than your God, God is the one and only God.)

 

[37818]

Yahweh or Allah? Then they might not be the same God.
Depends whether Allah is the Name or term Th'God, the God.

My first poll answer was, No.

 

[atpollard]

Yahweh or Allah? Then they might not be the same God.
Depends whether Allah is the Name or term Th'God, the God.

My first poll answer was, No.

… and whether what they offer to THE ONLY GOD is indeed “worship”.


When an ancient Israelite sacrificed their child to the fires of Molech, was that “worship” to the one True God?
There is only one God and the child was an act of worship.

Likewise, when a devout Muslim embraces the command to convert or destroy all non-Muslims are they “worshiping” God? The “synagogue of Satan” (of which scripture warns) has been supplanted by the “Mosque of Satan” … but both are puppets to “the god of this world” rather than the One True God.

 

[atpollard]

"And there is salvation in no one else; for there is no other name under heaven that has been given among mankind by which we must be saved." - Acts 4:12 [NASB]

… it is either TRUE or it is NOT TRUE.

 

[Cathode]

People need to take the requisite time to think this through.

 

[Cathode]

Yahweh or Allah? Then they might not be the same God.
Depends whether Allah is the Name or term Th'God, the God.

My first poll answer was, No.

I suggest a quality Church warden pipe.

And 5lbs of the finest aged Black cavendish to think this through.

 

[Eternally Grateful]

The jew crucified their God

I am sure the Muslim would crucify him also

And the catholics. they would not like his message either. so they too most likely would crucify him

 

[Mikey]

Additional Responses

 

[Blank]

According to Islam;
1. God has no Son, and
2. God is not love.

Immediately with #1, he is a different deity.

Verses from the qur'an about Allah has no son

Read the verses from the Qur'an which mention Allah (swt) being alone without a partner or son (total of 13 ayat/verses).

myislam.org