• Welcome to Baptist Board, a friendly forum to discuss the Baptist Faith in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to all the features that our community has to offer.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

Christ set forth as a Propitiation

Martin Marprelate

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Scripture does not say the wrath of God gets propitiated.
Romans 3:25. God set Him forth as a propitiation by His blood.' What do you think that means? Do you suppose that God is not propitiated by the death of Christ? Would that not suggest a serious failure on God's part in setting Him forth to no avail, and on Christ's part if the shedding of His blood failed to propitiate God towards sinners?
God's wrath is against the wicked.
God conformes us into the image of Christ
God recreates us in Christ
God gives us a new heart and a new spirit
God will refine us as gold and silver are regined
What need therefore for the Lord Jesus to suffer and die? God has sorted it out.
We must die to the flesh and be made alive in Christ
We must repent, turn from evil and to God
We must be born of the Spirit
We must be made alive in Christ
It sounds like a lot of work. How do we accomplish these things? And if God is going to do it all for us, on what basis will He do it?
God will judge the wicked on "the Day of Wrath"
God will separate the people on that Day
God will punish the wicked on the Day of Judgmeny
Shouldn't that come before the last bit?
Christ became a life giving Spirit
In Christ there is no condemnation

If, on the day of judgment, you remain wicked then you will face condemnation

If you have been conformed into the image of Christ, been made a new creation, been born of the Spirit, been refined, died to the flesh then you will live.
So why the cross?
Christ IS the Propitiation for human sin.
How exactly? I know, and so do most of the people on this board, but I don't think you do. Why could He not be the propitiation for human sin by doing 20 press-ups or doing some more miracles or...... anything really apart from dying on a wooden cross?
God set forth Christ AS a Propitiation
Just so, but you left out the phrase that follows.
In Him we escape the wrath to come
In Him we are reconciled to God.
Again, how exactly?
 

JonC

Moderator
Moderator
Romans 3:25. God set Him forth as a propitiation by His blood.' What do you think that means? Do you suppose that God is not propitiated by the death of Christ? Would that not suggest a serious failure on God's part in setting Him forth to no avail, and on Christ's part if the shedding of His blood failed to propitiate God towards sinners?

What need therefore for the Lord Jesus to suffer and die? God has sorted it out.

It sounds like a lot of work. How do we accomplish these things? And if God is going to do it all for us, on what basis will He do it?

Shouldn't that come before the last bit?

So why the cross?

How exactly? I know, and so do most of the people on this board, but I don't think you do. Why could He not be the propitiation for human sin by doing 20 press-ups or doing some more miracles or...... anything really apart from dying on a wooden cross?

Just so, but you left out the phrase that follows.

Again, how exactly?
God set forth Jesus as a Propitiation by His blood.

It is not hard to understand.

God (here the Father as Jesus offered Himself in obedience to the Father).
Set forth (put forth, sent)
Him (Jesus, the Son)
as a (a preposition to show a role or function)
Propitiation (a noun, something that brings favor, from "propitius" which means favorable or gracious).
In His blood (points to Christ's obedience tp death, His crucifixion


Therefore, since the children share in flesh and blood, He Himself likewise also partook of the same, so that through death He might destroy the one who has the power of death, that is, the devil, and free those who through fear of death were subject to slavery all their lives.


In Christianity we are reconciled to God, not like the pagan sacrifices but by being recreated in Christ.

Scripture speak once of God being propiated, and this is by mediation (Christ, as our High Priest, interceding for us when we sin). But we read elsewhere that Chriat Himself is this Propitiation (we are clothed with His righteousness, being conformed into His image).


Scripture interprets Scrioture, @Martin Marprelate . No need for theories.

Christ is our propitiation.
We are reconciled to God in Christ.
We are being conformed into His image.
In Him we escape the wrath to come.
We are made new creations in Christ.

You are so focused on paganism you cannot grasp God's words right in front of you.
 
Last edited:

JonC

Moderator
Moderator
And early has been attacked by the "new view of Paul" gang, headlined by NT Wright and his gang
This is actually not quite true. What you mean is "the new perspective on Paul". Here there are many theories, but the general idea is only new in relation from arising within Reformed theologians.

The movement began in Lutheran theology in the early 1960's.

But it was merely a shift from Reformed tradition to seek out a more biblical view. These scholars recognized a major issue within their traditions and sought to bring their churches into a stronger standing biblically.

Ironically it has been primarily the Reformed scholars who specialize in studying the Pauline epistles that recognize the error of the Reformers. They just realized what most Christians know.

Anyway, this issue has nothing to do with Penal Substitution Theory per se. Stendahl was a Kutheran who held to Satisfaction/ Substitution. But it is a related theory (it is what Penal Substitution Theory sought to reform).


This movement, like Calvinism, carries way too much baggage and tradition.
 

JonC

Moderator
Moderator
What need therefore for the Lord Jesus to suffer and die? God has sorted it out.

It sounds like a lot of work. How do we accomplish these things? And if God is going to do it all for us, on what basis will He do it?

Shouldn't that come before the last bit?

So why the cross?

How exactly? I know, and so do most of the people on this board, but I don't think you do. Why could He not be the propitiation for human sin by doing 20 press-ups or doing some more miracles or...... anything really apart from dying on a wooden cross?

Just so, but you left out the phrase that follows.

Again, how exactly?
1. I realize that you have not use for Christ's death. We have discussed this before and again I will say you are wrong.

The Bible tells us why Jesus had to die in order to redeem us. You just reject those passages.

He had to die "so that through death He might destroy the one who has the power of death, that is, the devil, and free those who through fear of death were subject to slavery all their lives."

2. Yes, God has it sorted out.

3. Why the cross? Because God used it as a symbol in Scripture. When the Isralites considered somebody guilty of a crime worthy of death they were esteemed stricken by God. But we also have history (since you seem so averse to Scripture). If Jesus was actualky cursed by God He would have been murdered under the Law (the punishment fir blasphemy is death by stoning).

But crucifixion was unmistakable - it was the ultimate punishment by the "powers of darkness" at the time (Rome). It was not a punishment prescribed for sin against God but for crimes against an evil and pagan nation.

4. Christ is the propitiation for the sins of the World. There is no "how" in that verse because the word is a noun. You mean "why". The reason is in Scripture.

In Him we escape the wrath to come.
We are made new creations in Christ.
He became a life giving spirit.
We are conformed into the image of Christ.
God gives us a new heart, a new spirit, puts His Spirit in us.
There is no condemnation in Christ.
We are clothed in His righteousness.
The mind set on the Spirit is life.
Christ is the Life.
We are reconciled to God in Christ.

5. #4 answered your question.

I know that God's actual words are foolishness to you. You have made that abundantly clear. It is not what God said, in your estimation, that matters but what the men you worship have told you that the Bible teaches.

There is not a person alive who believes thar the Bible teaches "what is written" in the biblical text who will agree with you. You have not even been able to provide one verse that states Jesus suffered God's wrath. And that is just a four word sentence - think about all the other myths you believe.
 

Martin Marprelate

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
God set forth Jesus as a Propitiation by His blood.

It is not hard to understand.

God (here the Father as Jesus offered Himself in obedience to the Father).
Set forth (put forth, sent)
Him (Jesus, the Son)
as a (a preposition to show a role or function)
Propitiation (a noun, something that brings favor, from "propitius" which means favorable or gracious).
In His blood (points to Christ's obedience tp death, His crucifixion
It seems hard for you to understand. The Old Testament was written in Hebrew, and the New in Greek, but you have to resort to Latin to try (and fail) to give us the meaning. In fact, propitius is an adjective, not a noun, so in any case it cannot help us to find the meaning of hilasterion, which is a noun. As I wrote in the O.P., it refers to the “mercy seat” (Hebrews 9:5) which was the cover of the ark of the covenant which resided in the Holiest Place in the Tabernacle. It was where the Jewish High Priest went once a year on the Day of Atonement to offer sacrifices, first for himself and then for the people (Heb. 9:7). This was the most solemn of all the Jewish ceremonies. The sacrificial offering was a death in the place of the one who offered it (Leviticus 16:6). A propitiation is a sacrifice that turns away wrath. If a man were to upset his wife in some way, he might buy her a bunch of flowers as a propitiation, to satisfy her outraged sense of wrong and turn away her righteous anger. Of course, the man would not know if these flowers would be sufficient for that. His wife might hold out for a meal in a slap-up restaurant! But we know that God is satisfied by the suffering and death of Christ because it was He who set Him forth. Christ was our substitute. He was pierced for our transgressions; He was crushed for our iniquities. The punishment that brought us peace was upon Him (Isaiah 53:5, NIV).
JonC said:
Therefore, since the children share in flesh and blood, He Himself likewise also partook of the same, so that through death He might destroy the one who has the power of death, that is, the devil, and free those who through fear of death were subject to slavery all their lives.
Amen! Thank you for some Scripture which is grievously lacking in most of your posts. But tell me, how do you think the death of Christ destroyed the devil? How did it free anyone?
In Christianity we are reconciled to God, not like the pagan sacrifices but by being recreated in Christ.

Scripture speak once of God being propiated, and this is by mediation (Christ, as our High Priest, interceding for us when we sin). But we read elsewhere that Chriat Himself is this Propitiation (we are clothed with His righteousness, being conformed into His image).
So the Levitical sacrifices were pagan, were they? Did God not authorize, and indeed, command them? So the LORD is a pagan deity, is He?Christ is indeed our propitiation or 'mercy seat.'
Christ's session as our Great High Priest comes after His death, resurrectionand ascension.
And if the propitiation is nothing else but our clothing with righteousness and being conformed into His image, what need was there for our Lord to suffer and die? Why did He refuse the wine mixed with myrrh in Mark 15:23?
Scripture interprets Scrioture, @Martin Marprelate . No need for theories.
You should stop trotting out yours then.
Christ is our propitiation.
We are reconciled to God in Christ.
We are being conformed into His image.
In Him we escape the wrath to come.
We are made new creations in Christ.
You still can't explain how all this comes to be. 'The LORD ...... will not at all acquit the guilty' (Nahum 1:3). '...Keepimg mercy for thousands, forgiving iniquity, transgressions and sin, by no means clearing the guilty' (Exodus 34How is it possible for God to forgive iniquity, transgressions and sin and by no means to clear the guilty? Only through the Lord Jesus whom God set forth as as the propitiation for our sins (1 John 4:10). 'By His wounds, we are healed.' Penal substitution in a nutshell.
You are so focused on paganism you cannot grasp God's words right in front of you.
Yeah right! You think God's a pagan; we know that already.
 

JonC

Moderator
Moderator
It seems hard for you to understand. The Old Testament was written in Hebrew, and the New in Greek, but you have to resort to Latin to try (and fail) to give us the meaning. In fact, propitius is an adjective, not a noun, so in any case it cannot help us to find the meaning of hilasterion, which is a noun. As I wrote in the O.P., it refers to the “mercy seat” (Hebrews 9:5) which was the cover of the ark of the covenant which resided in the Holiest Place in the Tabernacle. It was where the Jewish High Priest went once a year on the Day of Atonement to offer sacrifices, first for himself and then for the people (Heb. 9:7). This was the most solemn of all the Jewish ceremonies. The sacrificial offering was a death in the place of the one who offered it (Leviticus 16:6). A propitiation is a sacrifice that turns away wrath. If a man were to upset his wife in some way, he might buy her a bunch of flowers as a propitiation, to satisfy her outraged sense of wrong and turn away her righteous anger. Of course, the man would not know if these flowers would be sufficient for that. His wife might hold out for a meal in a slap-up restaurant! But we know that God is satisfied by the suffering and death of Christ because it was He who set Him forth. Christ was our substitute. He was pierced for our transgressions; He was crushed for our iniquities. The punishment that brought us peace was upon Him (Isaiah 53:5, NIV).

Amen! Thank you for some Scripture which is grievously lacking in most of your posts. But tell me, how do you think the death of Christ destroyed the devil? How did it free anyone?

So the Levitical sacrifices were pagan, were they? Did God not authorize, and indeed, command them? So the LORD is a pagan deity, is He?Christ is indeed our propitiation or 'mercy seat.'
Christ's session as our Great High Priest comes after His death, resurrectionand ascension.
And if the propitiation is nothing else but our clothing with righteousness and being conformed into His image, what need was there for our Lord to suffer and die? Why did He refuse the wine mixed with myrrh in Mark 15:23?

You should stop trotting out yours then.

You still can't explain how all this comes to be. 'The LORD ...... will not at all acquit the guilty' (Nahum 1:3). '...Keepimg mercy for thousands, forgiving iniquity, transgressions and sin, by no means clearing the guilty' (Exodus 34How is it possible for God to forgive iniquity, transgressions and sin and by no means to clear the guilty? Only through the Lord Jesus whom God set forth as as the propitiation for our sins (1 John 4:10). 'By His wounds, we are healed.' Penal substitution in a nutshell.

Yeah right! You think God's a pagan; we know that already.
No. I already told you why we differ.

I believe the words of God ARE what the Bible teaches.

So I believe that God laid our dins on Him, that He was crushed for our iniquities, that it is by His stripes we are healed.

You believe what the men you have chosen to worship tell you that means.

ANE paganism did not view God as making man into a new creation.

These pagans believed that the wrath of their gods could be appeased. So they offered sacrifices to manipulate their gods.

The reason there are the pagan ideas in your faith is not because you look back to pagan Rome but is because you hold a reformed Roman Catholic faith (those ideas were within your tradition).

That is why I can provide verses stating my faith. I have not denied any passages - I have denied what those men you worship say the passages teach. Snd you declare God's words alone as paganism.

I get that. God's words to you are foolishness. You look to men, to philosophy, to theory. His words alone simply do not make sence to you. The natural cannot understand the things of the Spirit. So you have to trust in men, in your own understanding.


And we can all see that.

God's word says one thing, you believe anither thing (what you think is really taught, your understanding).

You should have trusted not in your own understanding but in every word that comes form God.

This is a very solid presentation among all who believe and Know the truth. You compare scripture with scripture to refine your understanding which is essential. Those who have turned from truth might suggest this is a theory rather than biblical teaching, it could be they do not understand what you have presented, or perhaps they have gotten lost in the theological weeds. This teaching is welcome in every church I have attended or visited, except for one little apostate methodist church. Thanks for this fine post!
The passages @Martin Marprelate present are indeed excellent and relevant.

The problem is that a few of you (you, @David Lamb , @Martin Marprelate ) seem to consider those passages alone as foolishness.

Rather than taking God's words for what they are in themselves you trust in what men have said they "realky m" teach.

This is no different from any cult (in method) who tell their disciples what God "really" teaches.
WHAT IF those passages are teaching EXACTLY "what is written"?? What is Scripture interprets Scripture?
Then you all would be wrong.

Instead of picking a sect of men to believe, why not just believe God? The difficult oassages will be ime less difficult the more you rest in His words. Don't pick men. Choose God.

Notice how John posts partial verse not even in dispute, the rewords others to try and justify his nonsense. You see this in post 48..he lists things no one is asking about! he then changes the concept that Paul gave us in Romans 1:
18 For the wrath of God is revealed from heaven against all ungodliness and unrighteousness of men, who hold the truth in unrighteousness;
he has been asked dozens of times , what happens to the wrath that was upon all of us? he skips over it and says...the wicked will be punished, ignoring the wrath that was upon us also.LOL We are not supposed to notice how he skips past it, look at all his posts. he has the same M.O. ship the real question, then offer verses no one is asking about, then claim you only go by scripture, sad and laughable at the same time.
Yes, you cannot dispute my belief without disputing God's word. But you do anyway.

You ask nonsense questions (like "what happens to God's wrath?" as if wrath were a material thing God keeps in His pocket).

The wicked store up wrath for themselves for the day of wrath. (Yes, that is a verse in the Bible...God's words).

Where do the wicked put this wrath while they are waiting for that Day? Why don't they just flush it down the toilet?

Why does God put it that way - that the wicked are the ones storing up this wrath?
 

JonC

Moderator
Moderator
Evidence would be when JonC keeps repeating god will not judge another for anothers sins, will not bring to blame someone not guilty of the sin, so woudl not be any way to have the sinless lamb of god per him get that wrath of God, yet if the atonement of the Cross was not Pst, then again, where and how did that deserved wrath towards us get propiated?
I just quoted those passages. I did not defend them. My defence is they ate God's actual words (verbatim, the words that God said).

I do not believe that i need to defend the words of God other than by pointing out that they are His words and not mine.

Now....you keep asking "what happens to that wrath". Have you noticed that this wrath is the wrath that "the wicked store up for themselves for the day of wrath:?

The Bible tells us what happens to this wrath the "wicked are storing up for themselves for the day of wrath".
God will punish them.

Your conclusion comes from believing that the righteouss are also storing up wrath for themselves, that they are never made new creations in Christ, that they will not be conformed into tthe image of Christ.

But the Bible tells us even what happens to the wrath we had been storing up for the day of wrath. We die to sin, we die to the flesh, we put to death the flesh, we are refined as gold and silver is refined.

On the day of wrath if you are one of the wicked who have been storing up wrath for yourself then you will perish. BUT if you have been conformed into the image of Christ you will live.


Trust not in your understanding (or understanding you borrowed from others) but on every word tgat comes from God.
 

JonC

Moderator
Moderator
Notice how John posts partial verse not even in dispute, the rewords others to try and justify his nonsense. You see this in post 48..he lists things no one is asking about! he then changes the concept that Paul gave us in Romans 1:
18 For the wrath of God is revealed from heaven against all ungodliness and unrighteousness of men, who hold the truth in unrighteousness;
he has been asked dozens of times , what happens to the wrath that was upon all of us? he skips over it and says...the wicked will be punished, ignoring the wrath that was upon us also.LOL We are not supposed to notice how he skips past it, look at all his posts. he has the same M.O. ship the real question, then offer verses no one is asking about, then claim you only go by scripture, sad and laughable at the same time.
God's wrath remains on the wicked, on all unrighteousness. The wicked are storing up wrath for themselves for the day of wrath.

This does not change. If you trust in the philosophy of men, the wisdom of men, and reject God and the words that come from God then you are storing up wrath for yourself for the day of wrath. If this is the case and you are never conformed into the image of Christ but remain wicked then you will perish.
 

Martin Marprelate

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
God's wrath remains on the wicked, on all unrighteousness. The wicked are storing up wrath for themselves for the day of wrath.

This does not change. If you trust in the philosophy of men, the wisdom of men, and reject God and the words that come from God then you are storing up wrath for yourself for the day of wrath. If this is the case and you are never conformed into the image of Christ but remain wicked then you will perish.
Well that's it then. We're all doomed. 'The LORD ...... will not at all acquit the guilty' (Nahum 1:3). There is is; the plain words of God. End of story, so far as @JonC is concerned.
 
Top