With regard to the socialist question you still haven't answered. So, again, are you a socialist or not?
NO! I couldn't be, if I said I didn;t trust any of the systems, as you answered below. But it seems like "socialist" to you is anyone who does not think Capitalism is from God. Now are you a fascist?
I ask because you seem to really be down on capitalism.
Because I live here with it, on the lower end of it, and see its flaws, and then see a buch of people who think it is virutally perfect, yet blame all of its problems on socialism (in the form of "the government"). The auto bailout was Obama's fault. High prices are all because of taxes, wasted on "social programs". It's never corporate greed, because they "deserve" everything, and more (i.e. they're the true "victims" of this "socialist" government).
Also, there's really no winning or loosing in this forum in case you haven't figured that out yet! No one is going to concede and no one is going to call a winner or a loser. I am not doing this to win a debate with you - I don't care if you agree or not!
Your tactic of throwing out this "socialist" label is an attempt to "win" in a way. That's the ultimate proof that the other person is just evil, unAmerican, and ungodly/on Satan's side, and then there, you can rest your case, and walk away feeling vindicated.
What don't you stop your blanket categorizations? I don't object to criticism about the short comings our system nor ideas as to how it can be improved. But I certainly do object to the tearing down of the very foundations of those systems such as your assertion that God has not blessed our nation from its beginnings until now and that it is fundamentally no better than any other systems in the world otherwise known as normalization.
So I have to believe that there was some special act of God in founding this nation, then, in order to not offend you. It seems to be like part of the Gospel, and faith in God itself. Here grilling me on whether I'm a socialist, like some trial, or a McCarthy witch hunt or heresy trial or something. You want that much control over what someone else believes!
Yet is this in the Bible? There is way too much speculation about "what God is doing". Just like the charismatics, who claim all those tongues and healings and other forms of "revival" they do is some special work of God, you're doing the same thing in political history. The problem is, every man selects whatever events he likes, and then claims they are God's works we should ALL just accept as such. Yet there is no proof of any of it after the Bible record ends. God is believed by faith, and yet, men try to get their own agendas into this, and it becomes what one says versus what another says. People over the ages thought some world event was finally "the end", (i.e. God's final
work in this age), and it always turned out not to be.
So no one is really tearing down anything. You have bult it up into something you it is not, and there is no
scriptural warrant for claiming (whether it "seems" like it in the world or not). So to level it back to its rightful height seems to you like tearing down.
First, I didn't address this to you but I see you've grabbed all the comments to Billwald as well. I think you want to argue the point! No it's not a justification for slavery. You conveniently left out some of the additional comments I made didn't you? You know what I'm talking, don't you? This part: "I'm glad America eventually rose above all that and more towards the ideals established by its independence. Aren't you?" So, since you jumped on this, can you answer the question or do you think it's all about winning some argument? It's not!
I had even gone back over the comment to check the context, and the way you threw that in there still did look like a justification. Saying you're glad they later overcame slavery is one thing, but one still has to
justify it in the earlier period to maintain your stance of it being guided by God's providence.
That's what the argument is about. If that was God's providence, then He must have
favored the slavery. And many arguing that do appeal to the Old Testament where He once did.
It's sad when so called Christians buy into liberal ideology to such a large degree that they end up despising the goodness of God. To deny that God has greatly blessed this nation is to not only deny fact but it is to dishonor God and fail to give Him proper praise. America is here today for one reason - there is a merciful God in heaven who has given us far more than we deserve.
It's sad that so many Americans hate America. I guarantee you that if they lived somewhere else where the government crushes the people under foot, where the people have no individual freedoms, where the there is no sense of equality whatsoever, that these America haters would feel much different. The reason so many people pour into America every year is because, despite our faults and shortcomings, this is still the best country on earth. Give God the praise and glory for everything good in this nation, and pray that He will forbear our current wickedness and preserve this nation for future generations.
Now just who's going down the rabbit trail? I think we started with you "demonizing" capitalism and equating the power of government to the power of business. I keep making the point that capitalism works very well even though it does have some faults and there is a role for government to regulate it in the interest of justice. I also have made the point that government has the force of law behind it while free market regulates capitalism.
I will call being anti-American what it is because it is a grave threat to our nation regardless the motive behind it. We can destroy this country from within before an enemy even starts to attack from without. One big step towards that is the idea that socialism might be a good replacement for capitalism and using the government is the way to get there.
No, it started with you demonizing the government and blaming it for everything (including stuff like the auto bailouts, which is clearly a case stemming from corporate greed), and then
becoming defensive when the sin of that side is pointed out. Yet you (and others) keep throwing up this term "Anti-American", or "
hating America" like the whole definition of an American is someone who favors whatever corporations do, uncritically (corporations
who themselves care little about the country, ironically, as they will milk it dry and then move on elsewhere, while all the dittohead sheep blame "the liberals" only). So you can't even know what "wickedness" to pray that God will forbear. You're looking for it all in
one direction, and apparently denying that one whole side of it is even wickedness; calling anyone who says it is, "unAmerican".
So I'm tired of your little villifying catch phrases; as if
God Himself declared that anyone who criticizes capitalism is unAmerican. You find a scripture that obligates us to favor capitalism, or just cut it out already! (It's also pointed out that the "Democracy" taught by the founders is not necessarily capitalism, anyway, and that capitalism as it is being practiced today, is really a corruption of it).
It seems your entire egos are hooked up in this, and I could well accuse you of making a god out of capitalism, if I were to take your route.
Just look at the quotes. It's all about us, and our goodness (and others' wickedness), and them trying to get us by replacing our sacred system with somethign else. Who do we really think we are? Once again; show me this stuff in the Bible! Are we really praising God, when we seem to be exalting ourselves to His level so much?
Again, why don't you two be thankful when you feel like blaming liberals for everything. You sure don't sound thankful then. But you try to dictate how others think, though.