Alcott said:
Then consider me as you say, as long as it's known that "history is out of God's control" means he doesn't control it, rather than he can't. I don't think the Roman church controlling every nation and kingdom in central and western Europe for 1000 years was forced by God, nor everyone tortured and burned at the stake who opposed it, nor millions of natives in the Americas wiped out by diseases against which they had no immunity,....
==I'm not sure I understand what you are trying to say. So I will just make several points that I think need to be stressed:
1. What you or I "think" is totally beside the point. Personal opinions are worthy nothing outside of our own skulls. Everything must be backed up with Scripture.
2. Nobody said God forced anything. However God can force whatever He wants to force. God is 100% free to do as He wishes (Ps 135:6, Is 46:10, Ps 103:19, Dan 4:35). So God is not be unjust in anything he "forces" on anyone.
3. God's sovereignty rules over all (Ps 103:19). God rules over all things. So everything that happens in creation happens because God did it or allowed it. No place in Scripture does it say that God will stop bad things from happening. In fact, Scripture is clear that bad things
will happen in a fallen world. But nothing happens apart from God causing it or allowing it. Think about Job. Nothing happened to him apart from God allowing it.
4. If God is not sovereign (in control) then you can forget Bible prophecy, eternal security, assurance of salvation, or any other such doctrine. All of those doctrines rest on Biblical truth that God is in control. God's control over all creation is one thing that gave assurance to many Christians who have been persecuted or martyred for the faith.
5. Point of history: Many of the Puritans believed that God used disease to wipe out the Native Americans, who they called savages, so that European Christians could settle in the new world. There is indirect (secondary) evidence that suggests that some Natives believed that the European's God was behind the diseases as well. Interesting, though not part of this conversation/thread.