Charles,
I think I understand what you are saying. Please correct me if I am wrong.
I see your view and it has merrit, but I think you feel as if you are backed into a corner and it sounds like you are just defending your point instead of either being willing to accept the truth or explaining the truth out in full.
if David had of lived under the Grace Covenant and not repented, that he surely would be in Hell.
I do not believe for a second that you actually believe this. If you do, then you are preaching a fall from grace. I don't think you are meaning to say that but it is whats being said. Again, please correct me if I am wrong.
Lets face the facts. If God saves you then you are saved! Period!!!
You cannot undo what God Himself has done.
Now, the real question is
can a Christian commit a sin?
I have seen quotes from both sides of the debate using scripture out of context. Either trying to prove a point or just not understanding what the scripture is truley saying. I have done it myself on many occations only to find out later.
If we are all calm and honest, we will come to the understanding that we all, Christian or not, still commit sin. Remember, according to Christ, if we even get angry with a brother for no cause, it is the same as murder. If I get angry in that fashion, and have a heart attack and die, it will not cause me to go to hell. If I live for 5 years and never repent of it, If I was saved before hand, I am still saved now.
What I think he might be saying (I appologize if I speak incorrectly) is that a Christian will repent of their sin. If they don't, they will have no peace until they do. It will bear on a Christian until they do repent. If they have no desire to repent,
that should be a huge red flag, meaning they never were saved to begin with.
I think if we are honest, we all know of people who "Play church". They go every weekend but there has been no change in their life. Some people look the other way, some are very vocal to point it out. Lets face it, if you are born again, you are a new creature. There will be a change!!!!
What sin can a Christian commit?
We are commanded to be holy as He is holy. It is not permitted for us to commit any sin. Making excuses doesn't cut it. If you tell a lie or commit adultry, it is a sin. We are all COMMANDED TO BE PERFECT!
I for one fall short daily in some aspect. If we truly examine ourselves, I feel we will all admit that, maybe not, but I do. I find myself many times a day thanking the Lord for the blessings and what He has done for me, I also find myself asking Him to forgive me of all my short commings....(Sin). There is always more I can do, when I don't do it, to me it is sin and I need to repent of it!
Can a Christian commit adultry, murder, or stay out of church for a year or two? I have to be honest, I don't know. If they are saved before hand, they are still saved. If they are able to live like that and feel no regret or need of repentance, I will boldly say that should be a huge red flag. If they do it once and repent (I mean true repentance, not just saying they are sorry) and do not continue in that lifestyle, again, that should be a red flag too. I also believe that there may still be big consequences for those actions. But thats another long story...
Charles, you may not agree with me on that last point (Maybe nobody agrees with me on any point), but this is how I see it.
The inward man is sealed. It cannot perform sin. It is perfect because it is born of the Spirit of God. When God looks at us He sees the blood of Christ. If it was applied to a persons soul then they are sealed. As long as we are in these body's, we are always at war. If we fall short on anything, it is a battle we have lost, but the war is already decided. If you have Christ, you have the victory.
I don't know anyones heart, I only see the fruits they bear. God searches the hearts of men. We have the strength to live a perfect life but I don't think any do. I am truly torn on the subject, but I have to believe that if I stop leaning on Christ and try to do things my way, it won't be long before I sin and the longer I try to work it out myself, the deeper I will go. This would either mean I was decieved this whole time, in claiming to be something I was not, or I have lost the joy of my salvation. I don't think it was that I was saved and then slid back out of grace.
I enjoy this discussion, we all may learn something.