• Welcome to Baptist Board, a friendly forum to discuss the Baptist Faith in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to all the features that our community has to offer.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

What is a cult

Status
Not open for further replies.

Van

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
i don't see anything particularly wrong with having a denominational wide statement of belief. As you said if someone disagrees then they can go to a different church. The church chooses to be part of the denomination and can choose to leave.
I am sorry, but one of the Baptist distinctives is that our local churches are autonomous, rather than required to swear allegiance to a "denominational statement of belief."
 

Van

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Really how so? You are changing to topic of the conversation, from are confessions bad in of themselves to the issue with how confessions are used. I have not had a clear answer to my posts, if you agree or disagree with what i've stated. Do you agree with my statement that Creeds = Confessions = Statements of Faith = "What we believe".? if you agree that there is nothing wrong with a confession in of themselves then we can more on to the topic of the issues in how confession are used/viewed.

Without going into the various church poliety, as im do not know enough about all the specifics, however in general i see no real difference in a denominational wide confession and a individual church confession. As you stated before, if a person doesnt agree

Are you accusing me of being a Liberal? Can you explain how how "what we believe" is not a Confession?

You are redefining "denominational wide creeds and confessions" as individually written local church statements of faith.
 

Mikey

Active Member
You are redefining "denominational wide creeds and confessions" as individually written local church statements of faith.

No my argument is that a confession can be either a "denominational wide creed" and/or a individaul churches statement of belief. The issue is how they are used. So confessions are good and every church has them the issue is how they are used. So your "what we believe" is a confession held by your church alone.

thats not a redefining, it is what it is. Confession is just a old term that some continue to use.
 

Mikey

Active Member
I am sorry, but one of the Baptist distinctives is that our local churches are autonomous, rather than required to swear allegiance to a "denominational statement of belief."


again that is an argument against how confessions are used not the confession (statement of belief).

How is it wrong for seperate churches to use the same Statement of Faith? If the statement of Faith expresses scriptural truths in a clear and succinct manner, then why not use it?
 
Last edited:

Mikey

Active Member
I am sorry, but one of the Baptist distinctives is that our local churches are autonomous, rather than required to swear allegiance to a "denominational statement of belief."

"swear allegiance" really? do your elders swear allegiance to your church statement of faith? Church polity is a seperate (and important) issue.

But before we can discuss the issues of usage, we first have to settle if confessions = "what we believe" statements
 
Last edited:

Yeshua1

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
So Adam was not a son of God. Got it. Born anew believers are not "sons of God." Got it...
How can Y1 be wrong nearly all the time?
They are sons of God by adoption, but Jesus was and is by very nature of being God!
 

Yeshua1

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Yes, thats why confessions should not be used as a lense which to study Scripture. Or "venerated" and viewed as something more than it is. Sadly this seems to happen with some people, who adopt a confession for the purpose of being "confessional".
I have ran into this much more in Presby reformed then we Baptists, as they tend to almost always been using the Westminster Confession all the time!
 

Yeshua1

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
again that is an argument against how confessions are used not the confession (statement of belief).

How is it wrong for seperate churches to use the same Statement of Faith? If the statement of Faith expresses scriptural truths in a clear and succinct manner, then why not use it?
I see the Confessions as basic guidelines on the major doctrines, to make sure stay within boundary.
 

Yeshua1

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
what is your definition of a cult?
A Biblical Cult would be a church or a group that uses biblical jargon, but denies Jesus is God, denies God is a trinity, denies Pauline Justification, and who adds to the scriptures additional sources to them of divine revelation, which in effect renders the Bible null and void!
 

Mikey

Active Member
A Biblical Cult would be a church or a group that uses biblical jargon, but denies Jesus is God, denies God is a trinity, denies Pauline Justification, and who adds to the scriptures additional sources to them of divine revelation, which in effect renders the Bible null and void!

Ok. From that would it be accurate to describe a organisation as "Christian" (and therefore not a cult) would be holding to the Nicene Creed plus the 5 Solas of the Reformation?
 

Mikey

Active Member
A Biblical Cult would be a church or a group that uses biblical jargon, but denies Jesus is God, denies God is a trinity, denies Pauline Justification, and who adds to the scriptures additional sources to them of divine revelation, which in effect renders the Bible null and void!

For me there are conotations attached to the word cult which i don't think is appropriate to describe some institutions. the phrase "Cultish practices" I'm sure generates a certain image. I think how the organisation behaves matters in what word we use.
 

Yeshua1

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Ok. From that would it be accurate to describe a organisation as "Christian" (and therefore not a cult) would be holding to the Nicene Creed plus the 5 Solas of the Reformation?
Any particular group in mind?
 

Yeshua1

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
For me there are conotations attached to the holding the reasl God of the Bible and to the real Gospel?word cult which i don't think is appropriate to describe some institutions. the phrase "Cultish practices" I'm sure generates a certain image. I think how the organisation behaves matters in what word we use.
Cult to me really gets to the point are they holding to the real God of the Bible and to real Gospel?
 

Alcott

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
"Cult" is to faith/religion/church as "neurosis" is to psychology. It has a such a broad meaning that virtually anyone in psychology, and any organization in faith/religion/church, qualifies.

Nevertheless, my own meaning would be this in regard to the Christian faith:
An organization, or at least a unified purpose, of religious doctrine and practice characterized by an attack on longer established assemblies and doctrines of Christian faith, by claiming to be the only channel by which the Supreme Being communicates with people today-- either by direct revelation or by possessing the only flawless understanding of the scriptures-- by having a strong emphasis on wedge issues; that is, beliefs and practices that the established assemblies have thought or practiced in the "wrong" way [the sabbath, dietary restrictions, blood transfusions, what happens to the soul after physical death,....], and finally by requiring commitments by members to regard the organization or unified purpose as the top priority in a person's life, including requiring to various degrees that a member cut ties with acquaintances or family members who may influence the member in another direction.

How's that for a sentence?
 

Yeshua1

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Once again, Y1 has posted a complete and total falsehood concerning adoption.
We are adopted by God the Father when reborn again, and Jesus is the Son by nature of being Himself very God!
 

Van

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
No my argument is that a confession can be either a "denominational wide creed" and/or a individaul churches statement of belief. The issue is how they are used. So confessions are good and every church has them the issue is how they are used. So your "what we believe" is a confession held by your church alone.

thats not a redefining, it is what it is. Confession is just a old term that some continue to use.
Now we have the liberal redefining the meaning of redefining. Go figure

The poster was asked to provide a link to a confession (such as the Westminster Confession) but was unwilling or unable to provide a link. Then he sought to discuss how confessions are used, rather than the bogus doctrine contained in many of them.
 

Van

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
We are adopted by God the Father when reborn again, and Jesus is the Son by nature of being Himself very God!
On and on, Y1 posts false doctrine. Adoption refers to our bodily redemption at Christ's second coming.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top