• Welcome to Baptist Board, a friendly forum to discuss the Baptist Faith in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to all the features that our community has to offer.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

can One Be Charasmatic And NOT Be In Word of faith?

Status
Not open for further replies.

DHK

<b>Moderator</b>
Well, Gods ways are far above your ways...and He says building up your selves on your most holy faith, PRAYING IN THE HOLY GHOST!
You are referring to Jude 1:20. Let me say this. I just finished preaching through the Book of Jude last September. I started in the beginning of February. It took me 8 months to preach through those 25 verses. There is no commentary that I came across anywhere that suggest what you are suggesting. Jude does not suggest anything about praying in tongues. Everyone of us are commanded to pray in the Holy Spirit. One of the best and most well written articles on that passage was by Spurgeon:
Praying in the Holy Ghost is praying in fervency. Cold prayers ask the Lord not to hear them. Those who do not plead with fervency, plead not at all. As well speak of lukewarm fire as of lukewarm prayer--it is essential that it be red hot. It is praying perseveringly. The true suppliant gathers force as he proceeds, and grows more fervent when God delays to answer. The longer the gate is closed, the more vehemently does he use the knocker, and the longer the angel lingers the more resolved is he that he will never let him go without the blessing. Beautiful in God's sight is tearful, agonizing, unconquerable importunity. It means praying humbly, for the Holy Spirit never puffs us up with pride. It is His office to convince of sin, and so to bow us down in contrition and brokenness of spirit. We shall never sing Gloria in excelsis except we pray to God De profundis: out of the depths must we cry, or we shall never behold glory in the highest. It is loving prayer. Prayer should be perfumed with love, saturated with love--love to our fellow saints, and love to Christ. Moreover, it must be a prayer full of faith. A man prevails only as he believes. The Holy Spirit is the author of faith, and strengthens it, so that we pray believing God's promise. O that this blessed combination of excellent graces, priceless and sweet as the spices of the merchant, might be fragrant within us because the Holy Ghost is in our hearts! Most blessed Comforter, exert Thy mighty power within us, helping our infirmities in prayer.
Others said the same thing, but far more succinct--as in one or two sentences.

Here you go again..calling God's gift gibberish! Are you saying God does not know every language? My faith is in God that gave us the Holy Spirit...which is the Spirit that gives the utterance! The part in bold I have already covered over and over!
First, you DO speak gibberish.
Second, gibberish is not a gift of God, you just are deceived in thinking it is. For 1900 years no one spoke this gibberish except pagans and cults. It is not a Christian practice.
God does know every language. Gibberish is not a language, not even by the most advanced and scholarly linguistics standards. It is proven that it is simply nonsense syllables run together. No one can understand that which is completely incomprehensible, not even God.
You have blind faith, not in God, but in the gibberish that you speak, that it is from God, when it is not.
No, you have failed to understand! Paul calls it praying in the spirit! speaking to God, magnifying God! I can do this in private! With my understanding and with the spirit.
No one called gibberish praying in the spirit.
No one called speaking in languages praying in the spirit either.
On both counts you are wrong.
Furthermore, ALL gifts were given for the edification of the ENTIRE body.
Do you think God would give you the gift of healing, for example, to go home and heal yourself, just yourself! In the same way speaking other languages was never intended for your own private use. It was to the edification of the entire body.
Show me in scripture
where I have to know the language! Not your opinion! I trust God and His Word over your opinion!
I have shown you scripture. You keep on rejecting it. What was the gift that was given on the Day of Pentecost? It was tongues. That was the miracle. They spoke in other languages. They knew what they were saying, otherwise they couldn't speak it. For example if they were going to recite Psalm 8 or comment on it in Arabic, they would have to think in Arabic first in order to express themselves before opening their mouths. That was the ability that God gave them.
Nowhere does it say they understood! I have shown you over and over that! IF they understood they would not have to pray for an interpretation!
What do you think "gift of languages" mean. If I, as a missionary, were given the gift of languages, then I wouldn't have to learn the language of the country I go to, correct? Think it through.
Letting the Holy Spirit give you the utterance...is also a purpose! Speaking to God is prayer!
You get hung up on those 25 cent words like utterance and manifestation don't you. You need more simple language that you can understand.

Acts 2:4 They were all filled with the Holy Spirit, and began to speak with other languages, as the Spirit gave them the ability to speak. WEB
"utterance" = "the ability to speak"
They had the ability to speak the language that God gave them; the ability to understand and therefore speak.
NO, you did not explain why we need an interpreter if we know the language! There is a difference in interpretation and translation! We do not know what we are speaking..vs. 2 and vs 13 of Corinthians 14 prove that!
There were always two language groups present.
Paul preached in synagogues.
It was a sign to the Jews (one language group) -Hebrew)
In a city like Corinth there were often people traveling from other nations where they may not have spoken Greek--another language group. Tongues would be spoken for their sake and translated back into Greek.
God does not like you calling His gift gibberish!
Gibberish is the devil's gift. Why do you persist in speaking it?
Spiritual things have to be spiritually discerned! You are trying to reason this out in your mind!
I stand on the Word of God. Tongues ceased. What you speak no one can understand. It is pure gibberish.
Ask God to reveal the truth to your spirit!
He already has.
I have given every scripture that He has brought to my mind concerning tongues! Vs. 2 does not say that God does not understand!
Verse two is a rebuke to those that have the ability to speak in tongues or languages. He tells them don't do it.
Paul did not say say it was selfish when interpretated! I pray for the interpretation! God honors His Word!
But you don't get interpretation. What languages do you speak in?
Actual languages do have understanding, but only if they are interpreted for the benefit of all. If there is no interpretation then your spirit prays, and your understanding is limited. You always understand more in your own language. Therefore pray in your own language and your own understanding.
You need to read that again! Praying in the spirit is the one that he says you give thanks well! ...but the others are not edified! So if I pray in public without the interpretation it is of no use to the congregation! BUT NO WHERE IN SCRIPTURES DOES IT SAY I CAN NOT PRAY IN PRIVATE...WHETHER IN THE SPIRIT OR MY UNDERSTATNDING!
Where does it say you can heal in private, do miracles in private, etc.
Every gift was given for the edification of the entire body.
You limit the gifts of God to just your understanding! I have shown over and over that it is praying! Can He use it for a sign? Yes! Can He use it for the Apostles? Yes! But I do not limit Him on how He wants to manifest!
Not a single verse have you given me.
NO, it is Biblical! I trust His word over what past churches have done! Denomination after denomination has failed God! THere unbelief in His Word is pathetic! God is raising up a bride that will worship Him in Spirit and Truth...one that will be walking in His power! He is not coming after a hag! He is coming for a glorious church! The lukewarm churches he will spew out of His mouth! God is going to shake everything in the Last Days! The End time church is called to conquer!
PENTECOST DID NOT END IN THE FIRST CENTURY...THE LAST DAYS ARE UPON US! The church will be revived not divided! God will pour out His Spirit, release (manifest) His gifts, and send the saving message of Jesus's cross to the ends of the earth!
You deny 1900 years of Christian history and put your trust in a movement that started in 1905, a movement that started to speak gibberish back then, a phenomena known only to paganism and extreme cults. And then you try to convince us that it is of God. Do you know how ridiculous that sounds??
 

Yeshua1

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Nowhere does my experience contradict scriptures! Nowhere did I say the written word was being added to or taken away!
His rhema word is for today!

can yo define for us what the Logos and he Rhema word of God is?

isn't that what the heretical word of faith teachers espouse?
 

Thomas Helwys

New Member
Nowhere does my experience contradict scriptures! Nowhere did I say the written word was being added to or taken away!
His rhema word is for today!

Actually it does. Babblings are not the tongues of the NT. What you have described of your experience does not line up with tongues as a language as in the NT.

You may be sincere, but I believe you are sincerely wrong.
 

awaken

Active Member
So do you define charasmatic experiences as being what the word of faith , or the prosperity/Health and wealth supporters say it as being?
I have never studied out the prosperity teachings, so I can not say what I believe on that!
I do believe that healing is part of the cross! Spiritual, mental and physical!
 

awaken

Active Member
You are referring to Jude 1:20. Let me say this. I just finished preaching through the Book of Jude last September. I started in the beginning of February. It took me 8 months to preach through those 25 verses. There is no commentary that I came across anywhere that suggest what you are suggesting. Jude does not suggest anything about praying in tongues. Everyone of us are commanded to pray in the Holy Spirit. One of the best and most well written articles on that passage was by Spurgeon:
There are many prayers in the spirit...tongues being one of them! You can not ignore that Paul called it praying in the spirit in 1 Cor. He also said tongues was praying to God. Also it edifies us! So it does not contradict what Jude is saying!




First, you DO speak gibberish.
NO!
Second, gibberish is not a gift of God, you just are deceived in thinking it is. For 1900 years no one spoke this gibberish except pagans and cults. It is not a Christian practice.
God does know every language. Gibberish is not a language, not even by the most advanced and scholarly linguistics standards. It is proven that it is simply nonsense syllables run together. No one can understand that which is completely incomprehensible, not even God.
You have blind faith, not in God, but in the gibberish that you speak, that it is from God, when it is not.
You accuse unjustly once more! My faith is in His Word and I have proven over and over tongues is for today and it is speaking to God/ prayer/ magnifying God!

No one called gibberish praying in the spirit.
You did! Because tongues is praying in the spirit!
No one called speaking in languages praying in the spirit either.
How many times do I have to quote this scriptures for you to see it!
"For if I pray in an tongue, MY SPIRIT PRAYETH...I will PRAY WITH THE SPIRIT and I will pray with the understanding also..."VS. 14-15 This is in context with tongues!
On both counts you are wrong.
Then we just disagree!
Furthermore, ALL gifts were given for the edification of the ENTIRE body.
Do you think God would give you the gift of healing, for example, to go home and heal yourself, just yourself! In the same way speaking other languages was never intended for your own private use. It was to the edification of the entire body.
Praying is not selfish!! Do you pray privately? Yes! Whether I pray in the spirit or pray with my understanding..either way I can do it in public or in private.
I have shown you scripture. You keep on rejecting it. What was the gift that was given on the Day of Pentecost? It was tongues. That was the miracle. They spoke in other languages. They knew what they were saying, otherwise they couldn't speak it. For example if they were going to recite Psalm 8 or comment on it in Arabic, they would have to think in Arabic first in order to express themselves before opening their mouths. That was the ability that God gave them.
No where does it say they themselves understood what they were saying! ONly the ones listening! You are assuming that to fit your theology...but that would then contradict 1 Cor. where it says to pray for the interpretation! ANSWER THIS: WHY DOES IT SAY TO PRAY FOR THE INTERPRETATION IF YOU ALREADY KNOW WHAT YOU ARE SAYING???
What do you think "gift of languages" mean. If I, as a missionary, were given the gift of languages, then I wouldn't have to learn the language of the country I go to, correct? Think it through.
You again have to believe it this way to fit your interpretation! But you can not find one example of tongues being used to evangalize in scripture. It is plain tongues is speaking to God not to man..1 Cor. 14:2 "For he that speaketh in an unknown tongue speaketh not unto men, but unot God..." YOu have to ignore that scripture along with others to believe the way you do!

You get hung up on those 25 cent words like utterance and manifestation don't you. You need more simple language that you can understand.
Sounds more like you are having more trouble with them than I am! BECAUSE THEY SPEAK LOADS OF TRUTH! Something you want to ingore!

Acts 2:4 They were all filled with the Holy Spirit, and began to speak with other languages, as the Spirit gave them the ability to speak. WEB
"utterance" = "the ability to speak"
They had the ability to speak the language that God gave them; the ability to understand and therefore speak.
Without the Holy Spirit one can not speak in tongues! It is through the Holy Spirit!

There were always two language groups present.
Paul preached in synagogues.
It was a sign to the Jews (one language group) -Hebrew)
In a city like Corinth there were often people traveling from other nations where they may not have spoken Greek--another language group. Tongues would be spoken for their sake and translated back into Greek.
I see you continue to ignore and never answer that question...WHY PRAY FOR THE INTERPRETATION IF YOU ALREADY KNOW THE LANGUAGE??

Gibberish is the devil's gift. Why do you persist in speaking it?
That is getting old and it shows your inability to answer the post!
I was speaking about God's gift/tongues! You continually call God's gift gibberish!

I stand on the Word of God. Tongues ceased. What you speak no one can understand. It is pure gibberish.
As I have said many times before..stay in your unbelief concerning tongues!



Verse two is a rebuke to those that have the ability to speak in tongues or languages. He tells them don't do it.
You are not speaking the truth about that verse He does not say do not do it...because then he would contradict his statement "forbid not to speak in tongues." You need to read that verse again!

But you don't get interpretation. What languages do you speak in?
If you could answer this question it would give you the answer to those questions you keep asking over and over while ignoring vs. 13." Why does he tell us to pray for the interpretation if we know what we are saying?"
Where does it say you can heal in private, do miracles in private, etc.
Every gift was given for the edification of the entire body.
So now you are going to limit the power of the Holy Spirit on all the gifts? Where does it say can not!! It says to lay hands on the sick...they could be in the hospital, in their bed at home...anywhere! YOU LIMIT GOD! He does not put limits on where He will or can manifest in any of His gifts!

Not a single verse have you given me.
Do you deny that 1 Cor. 2 says we speak to God (that is prayer), vs. 14-17 ..We give thanks in the spirit (that is praying/speaking to God). If you are going to ignore those...why give more?
You deny 1900 years of Christian history and put your trust in a movement that started in 1905, a movement that started to speak gibberish back then, a phenomena known only to paganism and extreme cults. And then you try to convince us that it is of God. Do you know how ridiculous that sounds??
I do not ignore it! I just do not build a doctrine on it! I believe what the word say over any movement or religion/man made theology.
 

awaken

Active Member
Actually it does. Babblings are not the tongues of the NT. What you have described of your experience does not line up with tongues as a language as in the NT.

You may be sincere, but I believe you are sincerely wrong.
Well..you are entitled to your opinion! Just glad I do not base by life with Christ on it! I base it on the Word of God!
 

awaken

Active Member
can yo define for us what the Logos and he Rhema word of God is?

isn't that what the heretical word of faith teachers espouse?
Graphe is the "written word" "writings"
Logos is the "understood message of the graphe/writings/scriptures"
Rhema is the Logos declared. Rhema is utterance, words spoken or decalred.

The graphe (book/Bible/written) gives us the logos (understanding of the graphe) so we can Rhema (declare/stand on).
Rhema is what the Spirit uses in warfare.
 

DHK

<b>Moderator</b>
Graphe is the "written word" "writings"
Logos is the "understood message of the graphe/writings/scriptures"
Rhema is the Logos declared. Rhema is utterance, words spoken or decalred.

The graphe (book/Bible/written) gives us the logos (understanding of the graphe) so we can Rhema (declare/stand on).
Rhema is what the Spirit uses in warfare.
Other religious groups have been observed to practice some form of theopneustic glossolalia. It is perhaps most commonly in Paganism, Shamanism, and other mediumistic religious practices.[52] In Japan, the God Light Association used to practice glossolalia to cause adherents to recall past lives.[53]
Glossolalia has even been postulated as an explanation for the Voynich manuscript.[54]
Certain Gnostic magical texts from the Roman period have written on them unintelligible syllables such as "t t t t n n n n d d d d d..." etc. It is conjectured that these may be transliterations of the sorts of sounds made during glossolalia. The Coptic Gospel of the Egyptians also features a hymn of (mostly) unintelligible syllables which is thought to be an early example of Christian glossolalia.[citation needed]
In the 19th century, Spiritism was developed by the work of Allan Kardec, and the phenomenon was seen as one of the self-evident manifestations of spirits. Spiritists argued that some cases were actually cases of xenoglossia.
Glossolalia has also been observed in the Voodoo religion of Haiti,[55] as well as in the Hindu Gurus and Fakirs of India.[56][57]
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Speaking_in_tongues#cite_note-57
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Speaking_in_tongues#cite_note-57




[/quote]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Speaking_in_tongues

True Christian gifts cannot be duplicated so easily by Satan, and so often by Satan. Satan flees at the power of God. But here he is mocking it. Why? Because what is being done in the name of Christianity isn't genuine Christianity. It is imitation, fake, fraudulent. Satan knows it, and also is mocking it in other pagan religions.
 

evangelist-7

New Member
You deny 1900 years of Christian history and put your trust in a movement that started in 1905,
a movement that started to speak gibberish back then, a phenomena known only to paganism and extreme cults.
And then you try to convince us that it is of God. Do you know how ridiculous that sounds??
Yup, it sure does sound ridiculous ... there's no question about that!

But, I think you're tired of reading what I've been saying for months:
God reveals spiritual Truths through spiritual revelation.

Of course, this includes when one is reading the Scriptures.

Add to that ... God moves in mysterious ways.
He has explained that He enjoys making people look foolish who think they are so wise (1 Cor 1).
It's all about blessing SOME people with far-out spiritual truths, which seem idiotic to others.
Ref. the "foolish" gospel (1 Cor 1:18).
If not this example, why not others? ... God certainly is capable of it.

I think you're also tired of seeing this passage:
“And I (Jesus) will pray (to) the Father, and He will give you another Helper,
that He may abide with you forever -- the Spirit of truth
… you know Him, for He dwells with you and will be in you.
I will not leave you orphans; I will come to you.
… If anyone loves Me, he will keep My word; and My Father will love him,
and We will come to him and make Our home with him.
… But the Helper, the Holy Spirit, whom the Father will send in My name,
He will teach you all things, and bring to your remembrance all things that I said to you.”
(John 14:16-26)


You might just consider that this teaching can go beyond only the interpreting of Scripture.

Signing off now from Star #3846192 ...

.
 

DHK

<b>Moderator</b>
Yup, it sure does sound ridiculous ... there's no question about that!

But, I think you're tired of reading what I've been saying for months:
God reveals spiritual Truths through spiritual revelation.

God's revelation is closed. We have the Word of God--God's complete revelation to mankind. To put yourself on the same level as God's inspired prophets and apostles who by the inspiration penned the very words of God, is blasphemous.
Of course, this includes when one is reading the Scriptures.

Add to that ... God moves in mysterious ways.
But not contrary to His Word, as you would have us to believe.
He has explained that He enjoys making people look foolish who think they are so wise (1 Cor 1).
Are you admitting that you are looking foolish these days?
It's all about blessing SOME people with far-out spiritual truths, which seem idiotic to others.
God doesn't have "far-out" spiritual truths. He is a God of order and not of chaos.
Ref. the "foolish" gospel (1 Cor 1:18).
Do you think the gospel is foolish? Sad.
If not this example, why not others? ... God certainly is capable of it.
God does not go against His Word.
The gift of languages has ceased.
God does not recognize your gibberish as "His" gift. It is not. It belongs in the enemy's camp.
I think you're also tired of seeing this passage:
“And I (Jesus) will pray (to) the Father, and He will give you another Helper,
that He may abide with you forever -- the Spirit of truth
… you know Him, for He dwells with you and will be in you.
I will not leave you orphans; I will come to you.
… If anyone loves Me, he will keep My word; and My Father will love him,
and We will come to him and make Our home with him.
… But the Helper, the Holy Spirit, whom the Father will send in My name,
He will teach you all things, and bring to your remembrance all things that I said to you.”
(John 14:16-26)
He doesn't teach you all things does he? Are you omniscient? God?
The verse doesn't apply to you. He was speaking to his disciples who would later pen the words that are now recorded in the NT. Unless you can claim the same omniscience that God has "all truth" that verse was not written to you.
You might just consider that this teaching can go beyond only the interpreting of Scripture.

Signing off now from Star #3846192 ...
No, I don't consider anything beyond what the Scripture teaches.
That is what Gnosticism is all about.
Is that what you teach?
 

CHS

New Member
You definitely could be" pentecostal"and not be word of faith. A lot of Pentecostals do not like nor agree with much of the word of faith teachings. But about all Pentecostals would agree that physical healing was provided for us in the atonement.
 

awaken

Active Member
[/SIZE][/URL]




http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Speaking_in_tongues

True Christian gifts cannot be duplicated so easily by Satan, and so often by Satan. Satan flees at the power of God. But here he is mocking it. Why? Because what is being done in the name of Christianity isn't genuine Christianity. It is imitation, fake, fraudulent. Satan knows it, and also is mocking it in other pagan religions.

WHat????? How does this prove what was shown in scriture to be wrong? Why can't you just stick to scripture!
 
Last edited by a moderator:

DHK

<b>Moderator</b>
WHat????? How does this prove what was shown in scriture to be wrong? Why can't you just stick to scripture!
2 Timothy 3:8 Now as Jannes and Jambres withstood Moses, so do these also resist the truth: men of corrupt minds, reprobate concerning the faith.
--These two magicians were emissaries for Satan imitating the miracles of Moses. But they could not do very much. God's power was too great. There came a point when even the magicians told Pharaoh that the God of Moses was the true God, and that He was destroying the land.

The true power of God cannot be imitated by Satan.
That is why Jesus and the apostles warned to beware of false prophets. You shall know them by their fruits (doctrine). They shall come to you as wolves in sheep's clothing. These are the Charismatics.
The real wolves are openly out there. I gave you an URL to where they practice their religion: Voodooism, Hinduism, Mormonism; they all speak in tongues.
The same wolves dress up in sheep's clothing wander among the sheep and pretend to do God's will. But what they have is not of God, and never was of God. Their "tongue" is gibberish, not real "languages" as it was in Biblical times. It always has been gibberish. It is a pagan practice, and never came on the "Christian" scene until 1905.
But the Bible says:

2 Corinthians 6:14 Be ye not unequally yoked together with unbelievers: for what fellowship hath righteousness with unrighteousness? and what communion hath light with darkness?
15 And what concord hath Christ with Belial? or what part hath he that believeth with an infidel?
16 And what agreement hath the temple of God with idols? for ye are the temple of the living God; as God hath said, I will dwell in them, and walk in them; and I will be their God, and they shall be my people.
 

Thomas Helwys

New Member
I'll tell you another way to recognize a false prophet: money. These people on television who are always begging for money are false prophets. Mike Murdock is one of the worst, always exhorting people to sow a $1000 seed or other amount and telling them they'll never be poor again.

He and his kind are not prophets; they are "profits".
 

awaken

Active Member
2 Timothy 3:8 Now as Jannes and Jambres withstood Moses, so do these also resist the truth: men of corrupt minds, reprobate concerning the faith.
--These two magicians were emissaries for Satan imitating the miracles of Moses. But they could not do very much. God's power was too great. There came a point when even the magicians told Pharaoh that the God of Moses was the true God, and that He was destroying the land.

The true power of God cannot be imitated by Satan.
That is why Jesus and the apostles warned to beware of false prophets. You shall know them by their fruits (doctrine). They shall come to you as wolves in sheep's clothing. These are the Charismatics.
The real wolves are openly out there. I gave you an URL to where they practice their religion: Voodooism, Hinduism, Mormonism; they all speak in tongues.
The same wolves dress up in sheep's clothing wander among the sheep and pretend to do God's will. But what they have is not of God, and never was of God. Their "tongue" is gibberish, not real "languages" as it was in Biblical times. It always has been gibberish. It is a pagan practice, and never came on the "Christian" scene until 1905.
But the Bible says:

2 Corinthians 6:14 Be ye not unequally yoked together with unbelievers: for what fellowship hath righteousness with unrighteousness? and what communion hath light with darkness?
15 And what concord hath Christ with Belial? or what part hath he that believeth with an infidel?
16 And what agreement hath the temple of God with idols? for ye are the temple of the living God; as God hath said, I will dwell in them, and walk in them; and I will be their God, and they shall be my people.

Well, again you have taken scriptures and added your own little twist to it. I could do the same, but I am not going to play that game!

If Charismatic is believing in the manifestations of the Holy Spirit in 1 Cor. 12...then I am one.. along with others on this board! So according to your post we are unrighteous, darkness, wolves in sheep clothing, infidel and the devil etc. Is this what you stoop to when you can not answer questions like...WHY DOES IT SAY TO PRAY FOR THE INTERPRETATION IF WE KNOW THE LANGUAGE OR UNDERSTAND WHAT WE PRAY?Would you like me to post all the verses on unbelief?
 

awaken

Active Member
I'll tell you another way to recognize a false prophet: money. These people on television who are always begging for money are false prophets. Mike Murdock is one of the worst, always exhorting people to sow a $1000 seed or other amount and telling them they'll never be poor again.

He and his kind are not prophets; they are "profits".
I will agree with this...if the main focus is money...watch out!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top