• Welcome to Baptist Board, a friendly forum to discuss the Baptist Faith in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to all the features that our community has to offer.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

Does the Word of God evidence the Trinity or is the Godhead simply reasoned out from Scripture?

Status
Not open for further replies.

JonC

Moderator
Moderator
Yes indeed, but I am trying to show the impossibility of finding a single text that will convince any Unitarian of the Trinity.
You won't find a single test that will convince an atheist that God created man either. But it is in the text of Scripture.
 

SavedByGrace

Well-Known Member
Be gentle, for we know not the depth of understanding in Scriptural matters this new poster brings.

Some come to the BB without understanding and need to be patiently taught.

and there are those, who pretend to be "baptist", and probably JW's, who bring their demonic teachings about the God of the Bible!
 

JamesL

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
James!
You say that you are a Baptist -
and the Trinity is one of our basic doctrines
So why are you a Baptist -if you disagree with one of the major doctrines??

Your local church states that you accept the BF&M, 2000
From the BF&M
"...The eternal triune God reveals Himself to us as Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, with distinct personal attributes, but without division of nature, essence, or being."
I have little problem with what you quoted from the 2000 BF&M. There's a difference between "reveals...with distinct personal attributes" and "exists as 3 CoEternal Persons"

Maybe Baptists aren't as staunchly Trinitarian as you think
 

AustinC

Well-Known Member
I have little problem with what you quoted from the 2000 BF&M. There's a difference between "reveals...with distinct personal attributes" and "exists as 3 CoEternal Persons"

Maybe Baptists aren't as staunchly Trinitarian as you think
Maybe Donnell and Connell need to have a wee bit of a talk with ye there Patrick. You been watching too much Voltron have ye?
 

JamesL

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
If there are 3 CoEternal Persons, how is it possible that the Son does not know the hour of His coming? How is it that the Son was granted to have life within Himself?
 

JamesL

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Maybe Donnell and Connell need to have a wee bit of a talk with ye there Patrick. You been watching too much Voltron have ye?
If those Lutherans were to appeal to scripture rather than councils of men, they would have some good footing. Wasn't it even Luther himself who insisted that the Catholics reason from scripture instead of tradition.

That's funny, imho
 

JamesL

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
When we get into "natures" and "persons" then we do approach reasoning out of Scripture.
people should be honest enough to admit that there's a difference between "scripture clearly states xyz" and "this seems to be the best understanding of the scripture, imho but I could be wrong"

Nobody understands the Trinity because such is beyond human understanding
true it's beyond human understanding. But the question should be if scripture is clearly and emphatically teaching a particular view or if it's possible a whole of people are wrong

I remember "it is like an onion"...then "an apple".
hear here

But sometimes we get caught up in things that are not at all the point.
That's for sure
 

SavedByGrace

Well-Known Member
I agree that God is One, and that He is Triune in some manner.

I can't get on board with 3 Persons.
I think people want so badly to see their doctrines in scripture that they won't allow themselves to be honest.

There is a way to understand the Tri-Unity of God without "Persons"

And most who have chimed in have gone outside the parameters of the OP and have made mere assertions that cannot be found in any text of scripture.

Those people should be disqualified from the discussion, imho

I said that what you have written is RANK HERESY, and you marked it as FUNNY? You must be NUTS, certainly NO "baptist"!!! :Mad
 

JamesL

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
I said that what you have written is RANK HERESY, and you marked it as FUNNY? You must be NUTS, certainly NO "baptist"!!! :Mad
So what if you say it's heresy? Who died and made you God? Condemn me from scripture or condemn yourself for being presumptuous.
 

SavedByGrace

Well-Known Member
So what if you say it's heresy? Who died and made you God? Condemn me from scripture or condemn yourself for being presumptuous.

John 1:1, is VERY CLEAR, that "The Word", and "The God", Who He is WITH, are TWO DISTICT PERSONS, Both equally Almighty God!. You are trying to pretend that you are "baptist", while openly rejecting the Bible as God being One Godhead, and Three distinct Persons!. Either the Father, Son and Holy Spirit are PERSONS, or they are THINGS. Now you have to CHOOSE, which you accept. One is Biblical TRUTH, the other from the PIT OF HELL!
 

JamesL

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
John 1:1, is VERY CLEAR, that "The Word", and "The God", Who He is WITH, are TWO DISTICT PERSONS, Both equally Almighty God!. You are trying to pretend that you are "baptist", while openly rejecting the Bible as God being One Godhead, and Three distinct Persons!. Either the Father, Son and Holy Spirit are PERSONS, or they are THINGS. Now you have to CHOOSE, which you accept. One is Biblical TRUTH, the other from the PIT OF HELL!
Umm, no. It's not clear, nor is it VERY CLEAR.

Here's a challenge for you:
Tell me what ONE "Person" is, and I'll tell you if God is comprised from 3 of "them"

You can read into it what's been spoon-fed to you if you want. I prefer not to be dogmatic where scripture is silent.

And you argue like a juvenile.
 

SavedByGrace

Well-Known Member
Umm, no. It's not clear, nor is it VERY CLEAR.

Here's a challenge for you:
Tell me what ONE "Person" is, and I'll tell you if God is comprised from 3 of "them"

You can read into it what's been spoon-fed to you if you want. I prefer not to be dogmatic where scripture is silent.

And you argue like a juvenile.

A living, self-conscious being, as distinct from an animal or a thing; a moral agent” (Webster’s English Dictionary, 1913 ed)

Definition of Personality. Personality exists where there is intelligence, mind, will, reason, individuality, self-consciousness, and self-determination. There must be not mere consciousness—for the beast has that—but self-consciousness. Nor is personality determination—for the beast has this, too, even though this determination be the result of influences from without—but self-determination, the power by which man from an act of his own free will determines his acts from within.

Neither corporeity nor substance, as we understand these words, are necessarily, if at all, involved in personality. There may be true personality without either or both of these.

(William Evans, The Great Doctrines of the Bible, p.22)

PERSONALITY. In the first place, we endeavor to establish the personality of the Holy Spirit. By this we here mean that the Holy Spirit is a real being, possessing intelligence, and performing personal actions; not, however, a being distinct and separate in essence from the Father. We understand the one undivided essence or being in the Godhead to exist in three distinct persons—the Father, Son, and Holy Ghost. We would prove the personality of the Holy Ghost, 1. By the appellations; 2. By the actions; 3. By the honors, ascribed to him. If these be such as can only be applicable to a real and personal existence, then the inference will be clear that the Holy Spirit is a real and personal being, and not a mere abstract attribute, energy, or influence.”

(Thomas Ralston - Elements of Divinity, p.40)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top