• Welcome to Baptist Board, a friendly forum to discuss the Baptist Faith in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to all the features that our community has to offer.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

Have Any Spiritual Gifts Ever "Died Out"?

Status
Not open for further replies.

DHK

<b>Moderator</b>
I could also share a test done by so called specialist proving otherwise! But I would rather take what the word of God says about them!
NO ONE taught me how to speak in tongue! No one can if it is biblical tongues! It is the Holy Spirit that gives the utterance! It is the Holy Spirit that gives the interpretation!
Funny how your men above did not bring out one scripture! I believe the Word of God over any man's conclusion!
Where does the Word of God support what you have?
What does the Word of God say about what you do? (answer--nothing)
What are Biblical tongues?
Answer: Biblical tongues are the languages of the Bible or Bible times: Greek, Hebrew, Aramaic, Latin, Chaldee, (in Israel), and other languages like Egyptian, Persian, etc. in the rest of the world. What are the Biblical languages that you speak? Please inform us.
A biblical tongue/language can easily be identified. I have studied some of them.
The word "utterance" means "ability to speak". Look it up.
You claim that the Holy Spirit gave you the ability to speak Biblical languages. Now tell the truth or admit you lie and hypocrisy. Which of the Biblical languages did the Holy Spirit give you the ability to speak. Perhaps we can carry on a limited conversation in one of those languages right on this board. Language is a means of communication.
Now you also claim that the Lord not only gave you the gift of tongues, but also gave you the gift of interpretation. You should be doubly aware of what you are speaking and understanding. Perhaps you know Greek and are able to interpret it into Hebrew. Is that the gift you have?

I am basing my questions on Scripture and on your experience. I don't need to quote Scripture except to remind you of the definition of Biblical words. I trust you can answer this post and clear things up.
 

DHK

<b>Moderator</b>
Your judgment of my walk does not change the facts in my own life...not can you get off me personally and address the Word of God. I have posted several post that no one has addressed. I assume it is because I covered it scriptures and they can not be refuted!
The gifts of the Spirit include the gifts of healing, of miracles, of languages. This is not an attack on your walk, so quit playing the martyr!
1. Have you ever demonstrated the gift of miracles in your life?
2. Have you ever demonstrated the gift of healing in your life--not a simple answer to prayer, but as Peter did in Acts 5:16: thousands receiving healing, and no exceptions.
3. Have you ever received the gift of languages--the ability to speak in foreign languages without interpretation as they did on the Day of Pentecost. They spoke in other known languages and they knew what they were saying. They were not mindless robots.
Yes! I am blessed because I bless them!
Really. Look again:
Genesis 12:2 And I will make of thee a great nation, and I will bless thee, and make thy name great; and thou shalt be a blessing:
3 And I will bless them that bless thee, and curse him that curseth thee: and in thee shall all families of the earth be blessed.
--Is this your promise, directed to you
?

It says that God will bless those that bless you and God will curse them that curse you. It also says that out of you God will make a great nation; your name will be great.
All of that you have claimed for yourself.
You said "yes." Really? Or is this another hypocritical lie, typical of Charismatics.
Your examples are futher proof that you can not refute my post! You steer all threads to my personal walk and stay clear of the scripturess presented to you! I have dealt with that many times and have learned that about those that are blinded to what the scriptures are really teaaching. Futhermore...You want to claim the gifts are gone because I myself do not walk in the ones you posted. I have admitted several times that miracles are not done through me by the Holy Spirit! But I will not say it will not happen! Tongues and healings have! I have laid hands on several and they have recovered just as Mark says!
My examples are simple. Not every promise in the Bible is a promise that a believer living today can claim. The Abrahamic covenant was given to Abraham not to you, for example.
The gifts of the Spirit were given to first century churches before the Bible was complete and before the Apostles had died.
Today: miracles do happen; healing does happen, and people are able to LEARN other languages.
However:
1. You do not have the gift of miracles--2Cor.12:12; Heb.2:3,4--the sign of an apostle to perform many signs and wonders or miracles to demonstrate that he was an apostle. You cannot do that. You don't have that gift.
2. You don't have the gift of healing, as Peter had that gift and demonstrated it in Acts 5:16.
3. You don't have the gift of languages as Paul did or the 120 did. You can't speak in other known languages.
So you will take the dictionary's word for the ones you agree with but throw out the ones like "manifestation"...Well, It is plain in that scripture that faith is believing before you SEE it!
Words have meanings. When you change the meanings of words you simply end up with foolishness. That is what you have done.
Concerning "manifestation," I don't like to use it because you have redefined it and given it an existential meaning. Concerning faith, you don't have a proper definition of it either. Use a dictionary!
Again you give illustrations that steer away for the plain truth! My facts are based on what the NT says! I am again sincerly sorry that you are in unbelief and will not walk in what it says we can have! Your not doing a very good job of keeping this post on subject of the Bible an off peoples personal walks!
The illustration I gave demonstrates that you don't have a clear definition of what faith is. You are redefining the word according to your own Charismatic beliefs.
So if I can show you one time that the apostles could not heal someone...will you drop this attempt to prove that the apostles could heal everyone without exception!
Acts 5:16 There came also a multitude out of the cities round about unto Jerusalem, bringing sick folks, and them which were vexed with unclean spirits: and they were healed every one.
--This is a demonstration of the gift of healing.
It is a gift you don't have, nor do any of your Charismatic friends. They are wolves in sheeps clothing--frauds.
Maybe if you would quit seeking tongues to do something other than what He said in scriptures it was for. What you are saying is that God gave tongues to evangalize. Isn't that what missionaries do?
Don't lie. Don't twist my words. I never said I was seeking tongues.
I said clearly that I know I have to learn languages. It would have been nice if that gift were in existence, but it is not and I clearly knew that. But for you to say that I sought for tongues is an outright slanderous lie.

William Carey was the father of the modern missionary movement.
He went to Indian in the 1800's. He didn't have the gift of so-called tongues. He studied. By the time his life was over he had translated the Bible or parts thereof into 44 different languages. Carey had no formal education. He was a shoe-cobbler. The learning of languages came from hard work, not miraculous intervention.
I hope neither of us have to have a miracles done in our lives! But on the same hand if I need one I know my God can still preform them anyway he choses!
More misrepresentation.
I never said that God does not do miracles.
I said that the gift of miracles has ceased. There is a difference.
Do you have the gift of miracles? Are you able to do the signs and wonders that Paul could (2Cor.12:12). Do you have that gift? If not why claim that you do, or even that it is still in existence if you can't point to anyone that has it? Pure hypocrisy!
Oh, but the whole Bible has to do with faith! We can not please God without faith! Man's misinterpretation and teachings is why we have stopped believing what God said is to be here until we see him face to face or known AS WE ARE KNOWN.
You don't even know what that verse means.
We please God by a walk of faith. That is true, but not by wishing for promises that are not directed to us, like parting the Red Sea, or wishing to have the gift of miracles which you don't have.
Your misinterpretation of God's Word leads people into unbelief and into emotional turmoil and destruction.
But they are scriptural and they were given for the church! The last time I looked he has not come for his bride that he gave the gifts too!
gift of Miracles? gift of healings? gift of languages?
Nope. Haven't seen them. There is no evidence. Hasn't been for more than 1900 years. They were given to the churches of the first century. Read the context of the Scriptures when you read them.
Nowhere in the scriptures does it say that I can divide the seas... So you can not take away what my Father in heaven promised me and I received by faith!!!!!
That is in Acts chapter two. And nowhere does that promise include the sign gifts. It simply means that they who believe in Christ will receive the indwelling of the Spirit as opposed to the Spirit coming upon them as did happen in the OT. God would be with them continually forever. He would never leave them nor forsake them.
1. Do you hear a sound from heaven like a mighty rushing wind fill your house every time you "speak in tongues."
Then you know it is not Pentecost, not of God.
2. Do you see cloven tongues like fire above your head (use a mirror). Then you know it is not Pentecost and not of God.
3. It is a real "Biblical" language that others can understand and say: "I am amazed that I am hearing this foreign language which is my actual mother tongue." If not it is not of God.
My history book is the Bible! You need to study your history books a little deeper concerning the manifestation of the Holy Spirit!
Biblical history ended 2,000 years ago.
There is something to be said for history since that time; it cannot be dismissed. There is something to be said about what is happening today as well. You don't live in isolation. You don't have sole claim on the Word of God. Your attitude of everyone in the span of 1900 years is wrong, and I am the only one is right, is the height of arrogance; unbelievable vanity!
So I am to throw the last 10 years of my walk with Jesus away because people on this board disagree with the plain truth in scriptures!
Examine your position on scripture. Perhaps you don't have the plain truth on Scripture and have likely been deceived.
NO WAY! No one has shown me in the Word of God that they have ceased! They did share their interpretation of scriptures which contradict other scriptures! The way I believe and live out does not contradict scriptures!
It does contradict other Scriptures. But you refuse to listen; refuse to be taught or have a teachable spirit.
I am not asking someone to accept a movement! I am sharing the Word of God! YOu are the one that brings that up to lead people away from studing what the scriptures say and focusing on religions and movements!
You are a Charismatic, and as such have associated yourself with the entire Charismatic movement. You have embraced false doctrine. The doctrine you share is not the truth. It is Scripture that has been twisted from its context and oft times been redefined to mean something it doesn't mean. It is error.
 

Thomas Helwys

New Member
I could also share a test done by so called specialist proving otherwise! But I would rather take what the word of God says about them!
NO ONE taught me how to speak in tongue! No one can if it is biblical tongues! It is the Holy Spirit that gives the utterance! It is the Holy Spirit that gives the interpretation!
Funny how your men above did not bring out one scripture! I believe the Word of God over any man's conclusion!

I have given you scripture after scripture with the correct interpretation in context. You have deflected, ignored, denied this, and lied about what I said. It is not possible to have an honest discussion with you. You have an unteachable spirit. You are deceived.

It is a proven fact from missionaries on the mission field that tongue-talk is not a language but simply gibberish.
 

Thomas Helwys

New Member
I have tried to offer plenty of evidence that after salvation there is a voluntary second experience of the Holy Spirit which is for empowering a Christian and which has the different outward evidence. We honor God when we prayerfully seek His truth with an unbiased, teachable spirit, and my hope and prayer is that what I presented has given you some food for thought and some Scriptures for prayerful consideration. Whatever you believe, if you have trusted in Jesus alone as your Savior then you are my brother or sister in Christ, and I look forward to meeting you when we all get Home!


And you have failed because this view has been totally refuted from scripture taken in context. You are promoting a false, arrogant, divisive doctrine.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

awaken

Active Member
I have given you scripture after scripture with the correct interpretation in context. You have deflected, ignored, denied this, and lied about what I said. It is not possible to have an honest discussion with you. You have an unteachable spirit. You are deceived.

It is a proven fact from missionaries on the mission field that tongue-talk is not a language but simply gibberish.
So you are taking the fake to prove the real wrong??

I have not lied about what you said! I questioned what you said and you got offended!
 

awaken

Active Member
Where does the Word of God support what you have?
What does the Word of God say about what you do? (answer--nothing)
What are Biblical tongues?
Answer: Biblical tongues are the languages of the Bible or Bible times: Greek, Hebrew, Aramaic, Latin, Chaldee, (in Israel), and other languages like Egyptian, Persian, etc. in the rest of the world. What are the Biblical languages that you speak? Please inform us.
A biblical tongue/language can easily be identified. I have studied some of them.
The word "utterance" means "ability to speak". Look it up.
You claim that the Holy Spirit gave you the ability to speak Biblical languages. Now tell the truth or admit you lie and hypocrisy. Which of the Biblical languages did the Holy Spirit give you the ability to speak. Perhaps we can carry on a limited conversation in one of those languages right on this board. Language is a means of communication. Now you also claim that the Lord not only gave you the gift of tongues, but also gave you the gift of interpretation. You should be doubly aware of what you are speaking and understanding. Perhaps you know Greek and are able to interpret it into Hebrew. Is that the gift you have?

I am basing my questions on Scripture and on your experience. I don't need to quote Scripture except to remind you of the definition of Biblical words. I trust you can answer this post and clear things up.
I will ignore any post that I am called a liar on! Which by the way is against the rules, isn't it? Or do you not have to abide by them???
I will answer this LAST personal question...and from this point on I will only answer the post you refute the Word that is presented and not my personal walk!
The above in bold is what I have answered over and over...I do not have to prove anything to you about my personal walk, period! Does that prove I am a liar, NO!
I have showed you over and over what the BIble says concerning tongues and interpretation. YOu can decide as others......believe or stay in unbelief concerning them!
You ask for proof because of your own lack of belief! Because the Word is clear that the person that is speaking does not know the language they are speaking! This subject will be closed between us...because you do not bring anything new to the debate that has not already been discussed!
 

awaken

Active Member
And you have failed because this view has been totally refuted from scripture taken in context. You are promoting a false, arrogant, divisive doctrine.


That is your choice to believe or not to believe what was presented! I kept it in context and not one scripture contradicted the other! You theory on the other hand does contradict other scriptures. If you would like to state you side of the debate, fine! But the last few pages of this thread was nothing but personal attacks and opinions about what I posted instead of scripture proof!
 

awaken

Active Member
The gifts of the Spirit include the gifts of healing, of miracles, of languages. This is not an attack on your walk, so quit playing the martyr!
1. Have you ever demonstrated the gift of miracles in your life?
2. Have you ever demonstrated the gift of healing in your life--not a simple answer to prayer, but as Peter did in Acts 5:16: thousands receiving healing, and no exceptions.
3. Have you ever received the gift of languages--the ability to speak in foreign languages without interpretation as they did on the Day of Pentecost. They spoke in other known languages and they knew what they were saying. They were not mindless robots.
.
I only read this far and the personal questions stopped me! Keep my personal walk out of the post! Stick to the post that I stated scriptures and rebute with scriptures or our debate will be through!
 

Yeshua1

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
My problem with that is that others than the apostles manifested those gifts!
If we have the Baptism of the Holy Spirit...we have the same Holy Spirit they did! That same Spirit can manifest through us just as He did them..at His will!

they were associated with the Apostles of jesus though, for did not mark and Luke receive inspiration derived from association with peter and paul? That the HS moved upon them, as the Apostolic "umbrella' covered them also?

So IF you want to say the Gifts of today are being done by those NOT Apostles, problem is that you eed to have real biblcial Apsotles living to be the witness/confirming testimony those others are doing it by the lord!

And that God does miracles and healings at times, NONE here dispute, but NO verses supportingongoing sign gifts to the church!
 

Yeshua1

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
It is easy for modern Christians to assume that our non-miraculous church experience is normal, and that the people in the early years of the Church were "special" people living in a "special" time who experienced a "supercharged" form of church life. But what infallible source of information are we using which tells us that a lack of miracles is normal for modern times? The only infallible source of written information that we have is the Bible, and the Bible shows that miracles are to be expected throughout the Church Age. The New Testament does not provide us with any instructions or examples for a non-miraculous form of church. Instead, the New Testament is filled with instructional examples of how signs, wonders, miracles, and the supernatural gifts of the Spirit are supposed to operate throughout the Church Age, and there are numerous instructions given to us for the orderly use of these miraculous spiritual gifts in the body of Christ (read chapters 12, 13, and 14 of 1 Corinthians).

Further, neither Jesus nor the writers of Scripture ever described two Churches, meaning an "early Church" (which ended when the New Testament was completed) and a "modern Church," so these terms are misleading. There is only one Church, and only one Church Age, and only one body of Christ, and therefore we are part of the same New Testament Church that was born at Pentecost. To illustrate this, consider a new Christian who has not absorbed any biases from Christian friends or church leaders. Imagine that he is so hungry to know the Lord that he reads through the entire New Testament several times. When this person goes to church for the very first time in his life, wouldn't he expect to see people sometimes speaking in tongues, laying hands on the sick, prophesying, and so on? After all, this is the only type of church experience which is described in the New Testament!

The entire Church Age (from Pentecost until the Rapture) is supposed to be an age of miracles, and this includes all of the miraculous gifts of the Spirit. Jesus told the disciples that they will receive power when they are baptized in the Holy Spirit, and this happened after they were saved. After we become saved, we also need to be baptized with the Holy Spirit in order to receive spiritual empowerment.

Did paul and His gift of healing waned away near end of his life?

Did he heal himself, or timothy of his ailments?

if not, could it just be that the Lord period of doing things that way was ceasing?
 

awaken

Active Member
they were associated with the Apostles of jesus though, for did not mark and Luke receive inspiration derived from association with peter and paul? That the HS moved upon them, as the Apostolic "umbrella' covered them also?
Where do you come up with this stuff?? Show me in scripture where you get this?

So IF you want to say the Gifts of today are being done by those NOT Apostles, problem is that you eed to have real biblcial Apsotles living to be the witness/confirming testimony those others are doing it by the lord!

And that God does miracles and healings at times, NONE here dispute, but NO verses supportingongoing sign gifts to the church!
No verse says they have ended! You have to add to the scriptures to come up with that theory!
 

Yeshua1

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
they were associated with the Apostles of jesus though, for did not mark and Luke receive inspiration derived from association with peter and paul? That the HS moved upon them, as the Apostolic "umbrella' covered them also?
Where do you come up with this stuff?? Show me in scripture where you get this?


No verse says they have ended! You have to add to the scriptures to come up with that theory!

the Apostolic Age church receiced mark and Luke as being inspired of/by the same HS way the Apsotles were, as they derived it from being associated with the Apsotles, as many hold that mark recorded basically the memiors of peter, while luke was the beloved Dr that traveled around with Paul!
 

awaken

Active Member
Did paul and His gift of healing waned away near end of his life?
NO! To say that is to say that God was not able to continue...because it was God not Paul!

Did he heal himself, or timothy of his ailments?
I have posted this on other thread..but for your sake I will post it again...
Paul told Timothy to drink wine and not just water, because Timothy was experiencing frequent stomach illnesses (1 Timothy 5:23). Based on this verse, people sometimes claim that Paul couldn't heal Timothy, as if Paul was "losing" his ability to heal people. But clearly Paul was writing to Timothy. Paul was nowhere near Timothy and couldn't have laid hands on Timothy even if he wanted to! Notice that Timothy didn't have an "illness" (singular), but instead he had several illnesses (plural). Since he had "frequent illnesses" (plural), this shows that in some way his stomach illnesses were healed each time. This verse doesn't support the idea that healing was "dying out" in the first century.








if not, could it just be that the Lord period of doing things that way was ceasing?
It is more like man's unbelief got in the way of God working through them! Not Paul! Because I do not see anytime where he claimed it would!
 
Last edited by a moderator:

awaken

Active Member
they were associated with the Apostles of jesus though, for did not mark and Luke receive inspiration derived from association with peter and paul? That the HS moved upon them, as the Apostolic "umbrella' covered them also?

the Apostolic Age church receiced mark and Luke as being inspired of/by the same HS way the Apsotles were, as they derived it from being associated with the Apsotles, as many hold that mark recorded basically the memiors of peter, while luke was the beloved Dr that traveled around with Paul!
Again..a scripture????

It is the Holy Spirit that was poured out for all that is called by God! Not just the apostles! YOu can not find that anywhere in scriptures!
 

Yeshua1

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Again..a scripture????

It is the Holy Spirit that was poured out for all that is called by God! Not just the apostles! YOu can not find that anywhere in scriptures!

Who checked that mark/Luke were inspired of God? the Apsotles recognised that and confirmed that, for thsoe letters/books were written during lifetime of the Apsotles, why would say Paul?john allow books to come to local churches NOT of the lord?
 

DHK

<b>Moderator</b>
I only read this far and the personal questions stopped me! Keep my personal walk out of the post! Stick to the post that I stated scriptures and rebute with scriptures or our debate will be through!
Look, if I claim that I can walk across Niagara Falls I would expect others to say "prove it."
This has nothing to do with your private life, so quit playing the martyr.
If you make claims then back them up. If you can't back them up then you are a fraud. IT is plain and simple. Where is the evidence; the proof?
 

awaken

Active Member
Look, if I claim that I can walk across Niagara Falls I would expect others to say "prove it."
This has nothing to do with your private life, so quit playing the martyr.
If you make claims then back them up. If you can't back them up then you are a fraud. IT is plain and simple. Where is the evidence; the proof?
Then prove you are a child of God! Do you see what you are doing? You claim you are a christian...Prove it! No difference! Stick to scriptures and I will not have to prove my personal walk and neither will you!
 

DHK

<b>Moderator</b>
Then prove you are a child of God! Do you see what you are doing? You claim you are a christian...Prove it! No difference! Stick to scriptures and I will not have to prove my personal walk and neither will you!
Yes, I can demonstrate that I am a Christian.
I can give you the date that I was saved, that I trusted Christ as my Savior.
I can even give you the approximate time.
I can give you the names of the two people that were there who explained the gospel message to me, and why it was then and there.
I can tell you that at that time I was sure that I was going to heaven, as I still am sure to this day, just as sure as if I was already there.
"He that hath the Son hath life; he that hath not the Son hath not life."
Absolutely, I can give you my testimony of my salvation, as I do to others on a regular basis.

OTOH, you cannot give evidence of a single miracle.
You cannot stand in front of a crowd doing signs and wonders like Peter or even Philip did.
Nor can you heal thousands like Peter did.
Nor can you speak many different languages like Paul or the 120.
You say you can, but you can't. That is hypocrisy. It is a fraudulent religion.
 

awaken

Active Member
Yes, I can demonstrate that I am a Christian.
I can give you the date that I was saved, that I trusted Christ as my Savior.
I can even give you the approximate time.
I can give you the names of the two people that were there who explained the gospel message to me, and why it was then and there.
I can tell you that at that time I was sure that I was going to heaven, as I still am sure to this day, just as sure as if I was already there.
"He that hath the Son hath life; he that hath not the Son hath not life."
Absolutely, I can give you my testimony of my salvation, as I do to others on a regular basis.

OTOH, you cannot give evidence of a single miracle.
You cannot stand in front of a crowd doing signs and wonders like Peter or even Philip did.
Nor can you heal thousands like Peter did.
Nor can you speak many different languages like Paul or the 120.
You say you can, but you can't. That is hypocrisy. It is a fraudulent religion.
Well, I can give the same testimony about both of my experiences with God!
Have I been called to manifest a miracle, no! But does that prove that he does not manifest today because I do not? NO!

You are trying to prove or disprove the Bible by one person's testimony. Stick to the scriptures!

You have one word...out of one chapter...out of one book...out of the whole Bible to prove your theory! I have gives dozens! Stick to scriptures to prove your theory!
Let the greater weight of scriptures be the proof!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top